I think we all can enjoy, have fun, respect, honor, and give the teams their due/credit---and also critique, expect to achieve at the highest level, get mad, and still love the team.
Sorry, I want to hold the teams up to high standards. I want to see them achieve to their talent levels.
Saying that, 12-1 is awesome. But, going to the National Championship and getting obliterated and saying nothing is acceptable? Or going to the final 4 and getting your doors blown off by a team that they beat 3 times?
Sorry, I think calling them out is OK. Not calling them crap people or players or other names, that is unacceptable. But, we have to accept our best players will/should rise to the occassion. Right now our Hockey/Hoops/Football teams top players didn't rise to the occassion in the last and most important game. Is it bad to say that?
I love Notre Dame! I have my Prof. Cert from the Irish. But, we didn't rise to the occassion. Maybe myself as a fan didn't rise either saying our teams choked. I still believe that, and if that makes me a bad fan/Alum then fine I performed the same as the teams did in the most important games. I love Manti, he is my Fav. Player. But, he didn't rise to the occassion in the Nat. Champ game--missed tackles, pushed back, missed assignment for a TE TD (Gruden pointed that out too), Eifert is was fine not dominant. Nix was fine but not dominant. They had a plan to take out our best and they didn't overcome. Skylar and McBride 8-35 shooting. ONe can have a bad game but not both. They rose, and rose all year like our football guys. But, when all the marbles were out there at the end. They didn't rise. Is it bad to say, whine, etc??? But, look at the finished and last product it is the truth. The seasons were spectacular and wouldn't have gotten anywhere close to there if it weren't for them and how they turned around a program. I love them, I love the school. But, if we want to be viewed as "The Best" we have to do it when it counts most. And we haven't done it.
37-3 for the Ladies Hoops and Mens Football, and they both get destroyed in the last game and the best players didn't rise to the occassion. Look at it without the Gold Colored Glasses and hold our teams up to the highest standard and expect the best. I know they expect the best and that is why they looked so hurt, they expect the best too. No name calling, no degrading. But, call it as it was--a major disappointment and I still think a choke job. Coach said they looked nervous, and nerves cause tighness that leads to that bad work "choke". Does Lewis 7-12 6 REB, Stewart (Freshman) 10-16 29 points 4-5 3pt, Dolson 9 points and 5 blocks as their best 3 rise to the occassion? Does AJ, Lacey, Dee Womack, Jones rise for Alabama?
But, they are expected to rise for their teams by their fans and coaches. WE have to expect the same. Whining is OK, as long as you don't call the kid names and what not.
I still think we had a great season, and enjoyed it a ton. And will still support the team and school for ever. But, we have to expect the best if we want to be the best.
Go Irish!