NFL Fantasy Football Keeper 2020

wizards8507

Well-known member
Messages
20,840
Reaction score
3,291
Changing my keepers.

Edelman (6th, was 7th)
Guice (11th, was 12th)
Trubisky (15th, was UFA)
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
KEEPERS: (2018/2019)

Rhode:
Alvin Kamara 11/10
Kerryon Johnson 6/5
George Kittle 9/8

Wiz:
Julian Edelman 7/6
Darius Guice 12/11
Mitch Trubisky UDFA/15

IrishLion:
Nick Chubb 9/8
Matt Ryan 8/7
Tarik Cohen 13/12

GK:
Aaron Jones 7/6
Damien Williams UDFA/15
Michael Thomas 6/5

Kaneyoufeelit:
Patrick Mahomes 14/13
Baker Mayfield UDFA/15
Calvin Ridley 8/7

Bkess8:
James White 9/8
Adam Thielen 10/9
Phillip Lindsay UDFA/15

Armyirish47:
Davante Adams 14/13
James Connor 9/8
Evan Engram 15/14

Evilirish:
JuJu Smith Schuster 14/13
Tyreek Hill 13/12
Deshaun Watson 15/14

Gattaca!:
Tyler Lockett 12/11
OJ Howard 9/8
Cooper Kupp 11/10

Ironman8:




Junkhead:




irish o'phile:
 
Last edited:

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
Draft date is the 4th, so I'm going to enter the keepers at midnight on the 31st to give people enough time to plan ahead and get their draft boards in order. That is unless everyone has given me their keepers before then.
 

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,003
I would like to again comment that our keeper policy is way too rewarding. Someone who happens to get a James Conner or other good player as an UDFA can basically keep that player for 8+ years before they even have to think about another option. UDFAs should be kept in a much earlier round (i.e. 12) and the penalty for keeping should be much higher than 1 round. 3 rounds to me makes much more sense.

What if starting next year UDFAs are Round 12 picks and the penalty is 3 rounds for all other players? That lets you keep a UDFA for year 1 (round 12), year 2 (round 9) and year 3 (round 6).

Alternatively, keepers could be dropped to 2 total. It's not really fun when 15 of the top 25 players are not even draftable.
 

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,003
I am in a complaining mood here is another...the draft should be 16 rounds. In a snake draft you can't have the #1 team picking first in the last round as well. They are supposed to be getting the worst option for kickers or defenses. I guess I just noticed this since I am the 11th pick.
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
I would like to again comment that our keeper policy is way too rewarding. Someone who happens to get a James Conner or other good player as an UDFA can basically keep that player for 8+ years before they even have to think about another option. UDFAs should be kept in a much earlier round (i.e. 12) and the penalty for keeping should be much higher than 1 round. 3 rounds to me makes much more sense.

What if starting next year UDFAs are Round 12 picks and the penalty is 3 rounds for all other players? That lets you keep a UDFA for year 1 (round 12), year 2 (round 9) and year 3 (round 6).

Alternatively, keepers could be dropped to 2 total. It's not really fun when 15 of the top 25 players are not even draftable.

I tend to agree with your first part. Someone like Alvin Kamara might retire before Rhode has to give him up. That doesn't seem that fun to me.
 

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
18,622
Reaction score
8,366
I thought there was a 3-year limit on having a single player.

I think this is the final year Rhode could keep Kamara, for example.
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
I thought there was a 3-year limit on having a single player.

I think this is the final year Rhode could keep Kamara, for example.

- There are no limits to the amount of seasons a player can be kept for, until said player would be the equivalent of a 2nd round pick.

From the OP of rules GK keeps updated.
 

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
18,622
Reaction score
8,366
From the OP of rules GK keeps updated.

Well shoot. That's a bummer lol.

I felt okay about my keepers until I saw that Evil has Deshaun Watson, Juju Smith-Schuster and Tyreek Hill for 12/13/14.

That's crazy lol. I would have to have a perfect draft to have a chance at competing with any roster he builds (unless he totally fucks up his draft lol).
 

EvilleIrish

Well-known member
Messages
1,869
Reaction score
1,013
Well shoot. That's a bummer lol.

I felt okay about my keepers until I saw that Evil has Deshaun Watson, Juju Smith-Schuster and Tyreek Hill for 12/13/14.

That's crazy lol. I would have to have a perfect draft to have a chance at competing with any roster he builds (unless he totally fucks up his draft lol).

Hey now. Don't bring me into this. I have been in the league for 5 minutes....
 

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
18,622
Reaction score
8,366
Hey now. Don't bring me into this. I have been in the league for 5 minutes....

Haha I didn't mean it in a combative way.

I mean it in a "why can't I hit on big-time keeper value like that" way lol

(I feel pretty good about where I'm able to keep Chubb)
 

EvilleIrish

Well-known member
Messages
1,869
Reaction score
1,013
Haha I didn't mean it in a combative way.

I mean it in a "why can't I hit on big-time keeper value like that" way lol

(I feel pretty good about where I'm able to keep Chubb)

Lol, I know. Just giving you a hard time. Have to admit though, pretty nice walking into a spot where my roster was awful but I have three keepers until I'm dead.
 

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,003
Btw drafted the sexiest starting lineup ever last night. Had the 1st pick in a 12 man redraft:

QB: Baker/Lamar
RB: Saquon
RB: Dalvin Cook
WR: Brandin Cooks
WR: Tyler Lockett
Flex: Damien Williams
 

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
18,622
Reaction score
8,366
Btw drafted the sexiest starting lineup ever last night. Had the 1st pick in a 12 man redraft:

QB: Baker/Lamar
RB: Saquon
RB: Dalvin Cook
WR: Brandin Cooks
WR: Tyler Lockett
Flex: Damien Williams

Getting all three of those RB's is silly.

Rams WR's make me so nervous though lol
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
Are we sure IM8 is in? Haven't seen him active in this thread.

I just assumed he was confirmed. Anyone talk to him outside IE? I could see if I can get his email through yahoo.
 

irish o'phile

Well-known member
Messages
1,117
Reaction score
264
Hey All,

I was super busy. I am paid. My keepers are:

Tyler Boyd-WW last year
Devonta Freeman- 6th Rnd last year
David Njoku- 14th Round Last year
 

gkIrish

Greek God
Messages
13,184
Reaction score
1,003
wizards8507 (The Worldwide Leader) - PAID
IrishLion (IrishLion) - PAID
bkess (Go Luck Yourself) - PAID
gkIrish (JiveTurkeys) - PAID
Armyirish47 (Shanahan's Shamrocks) - PAID
EvilleIrish - PAID
Junkhead (Junkhead) - PAID
irish o'phile (O'Phile's Defilers) - PAID
Rhode Irish (#FreeBrady) - PAID
Gattaca (GATTACA) -
Ironman8 (Jaqen H'gar) -
kaneyoufeelit (Diggs Out for Harambe) -
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
13,028
Reaction score
9,209
KEEPERS: (2018/2019)

Rhode:
Alvin Kamara 11/10
Kerryon Johnson 6/5
George Kittle 9/8

Wiz:
Julian Edelman 7/6
Darius Guice 12/11
Mitch Trubisky UDFA/15

IrishLion:
Nick Chubb 9/8
DJ Moore 12/11
Tarik Cohen 13/12

GK:
Aaron Jones 7/6
Damien Williams UDFA/15
Michael Thomas 6/5

Kaneyoufeelit:
Patrick Mahomes 14/13
Baker Mayfield UDFA/15
Calvin Ridley 8/7

Bkess8:
James White 9/8
Adam Thielen 10/9
Phillip Lindsay UDFA/15

Armyirish47:
Davante Adams 14/13
James Connor 9/8
Evan Engram 15/14

Evilirish:
JuJu Smith Schuster 14/13
Tyreek Hill 13/12
Deshaun Watson 15/14

Gattaca!:
Tyler Lockett 12/11
OJ Howard 9/8
Cooper Kupp 11/10


irish o'phile:
David Njoku 14/13
Tyler Boyd UDFA/15
Devonta Freeman 6/5


Junkhead:
Desean Jackson 14/13
Jared Goff 15/14



Ironman8:
 
Last edited:

IrishLion

I am Beyonce, always.
Staff member
Messages
18,622
Reaction score
8,366
I have a change!

I'm gonna keep DJ Moore instead of Matt Ryan. He was a 12 last year, so he's an 11 now.
 

irish o'phile

Well-known member
Messages
1,117
Reaction score
264
KEEPERS: (2018/2019)

Rhode:
Alvin Kamara 11/10
Kerryon Johnson 6/5
George Kittle 9/8

Wiz:
Julian Edelman 7/6
Darius Guice 12/11
Mitch Trubisky UDFA/15

IrishLion:
Nick Chubb 9/8
DJ Moore 12/11
Tarik Cohen 13/12

GK:
Aaron Jones 7/6
Damien Williams UDFA/15
Michael Thomas 6/5

Kaneyoufeelit:
Patrick Mahomes 14/13
Baker Mayfield UDFA/15
Calvin Ridley 8/7

Bkess8:
James White 9/8
Adam Thielen 10/9
Phillip Lindsay UDFA/15

Armyirish47:
Davante Adams 14/13
James Connor 9/8
Evan Engram 15/14

Evilirish:
JuJu Smith Schuster 14/13
Tyreek Hill 13/12
Deshaun Watson 15/14

Gattaca!:
Tyler Lockett 12/11
OJ Howard 9/8
Cooper Kupp 11/10


irish o'phile:
David Njoku 7/6
Tyler Boyd UDFA/15
Devonta Freeman 6/5



Ironman8:




Junkhead:

I drafted Njoku in the 14th last season, not the 7th.
 
Top