Georgia is used to three week breaks between winning SEC championships and playing in semi finals though
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sure, but the other semi-finalist was also on a three week break so there was rust on both sides under the old format. There will be no rust on Notre Dame today. Georgia is covered in it.
The poor performances by the "bye" teams in the first half of these quarter-finals is an indication that rust may a factor. One can argue BSU and ASU weren't ready for the spotlight and were overmatched anyway and that's fair. But no one can question how poorly Oregon looked yesterday in the first half. That was embarrassing. Another data point will be provided today with Georgia. If they come out really flat and ND gets up by double digits by the half, a lot of people are going to start questioning the value of the "bye" because right now it looks like it's a disadvantage. It feels like the value of the bye starts to diminish after a couple of weeks of rest. So it's a big advantage if it's two weeks, but at some point (who knows maybe it's after three weeks) it starts to become a disadvantage if you're sitting around while your future opponent is playing.
If that proves to be the trend, it will only further diminish the conference championship games. If losing the game doesn't knock you out of the playoff (which the committee acknowledged this year), but winning it gives you the bye and the associated disadvantage of sitting out 3-4 weeks, why would any team play their starters beyond the 1st quarter in their conference championship games? Treat it like an NFL pre-season game and get some reps, then play the backups, see what you've got then get ready for the first round of the playoff.
There is lots of good coming from the first 12 team playoff, but I think the committee and teams are still on a pretty steep learning curve about how to navigate it best. Lots of good ideas are being considered. Get rid of 4 auto-bid byes, reseed after the first round, go to 14 or 16. Observe, learn and adapt. All good.