You realize the JMU players that are kicking the shit out of 5 stars were ranked lower than the players he is currently brining in out of high school right? How do you know they aren’t going to be underrated just like the players he brought to JMU? He will then supplement with transfers for any holes. How is it not sustainable.
I think we saw the issue with relying on the portal with Florida State. One year, it paid off big time. The next, it was a complete and utter disaster.
It works for Cignetti right now, because these JMU players are 5th/6th year guys and have all been in the same system the entire time. Those guys will be gone in 2026. Cig is going to have to rely on new incoming transfer guys and they may not have the same cultural buy-in than the JMU guys had, who had been with Cig for 5-6 years.
Now, I'm not saying that IU crashes and burns next year. Cig is good enough of a coach where he could very realistically keep everything in check. But I do think that's a very legitimate concern when building a roster via the portal.