‘25 NJ WR Quincy Porter (Notre Dame Transfer)

IRISHbluehen

Well-known member
Messages
955
Reaction score
1,927
I’m not up to speed here, what injury is he coming off of?

Is there a real concern he won’t get back to 100%?
I think there has been a little cageynous (if thats a word) about what his actual injury and surgery truly was. It was reported as knee clean up relating to his patella tendon. But a torn patella at worst case scenario can be a year recovery. The nature of the injury was also kinda secretive at OSU which also made it kind of weird. Everything reported by the beat has been that he should be ready by summer.
 

NDMD

Well-known member
Messages
545
Reaction score
971
I think there has been a little cageynous (if thats a word) about what his actual injury and surgery truly was. It was reported as knee clean up relating to his patella tendon. But a torn patella at worst case scenario can be a year recovery. The nature of the injury was also kinda secretive at OSU which also made it kind of weird. Everything reported by the beat has been that he should be ready by summer.

I'm speculating based on available info but "Cleanup" refers to debridement, he likely had some patellar tendinopathy (essentially loose collagen fibers that didn't heal right) from overuse that results in persistent pain. It should not affect functional ability long term
 

OhioIrish

Well-known member
Messages
477
Reaction score
497
He does come off like and ass in that video. That said, just watched his tape for the first time — I’ll be shocked if he is not starting by week 3.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,872
Reaction score
30,073
I'm speculating based on available info but "Cleanup" refers to debridement, he likely had some patellar tendinopathy (essentially loose collagen fibers that didn't heal right) from overuse that results in persistent pain. It should not affect functional ability long term
Yeah I don't know the medical terminology but this tracks or should at least be in the ballpark. What I heard was that they had to "clean out" his knee because it was locking up and giving him chronic pain. Don't know if that was cartilage, scar tissue, meniscus, etc. but personally I always get skeptical when there is opaque reporting around joint injuries. We will certainly know by fall camp what we've got.
 

FWIrish4

Well-known member
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
2,974
I'm speculating based on available info but "Cleanup" refers to debridement, he likely had some patellar tendinopathy (essentially loose collagen fibers that didn't heal right) from overuse that results in persistent pain. It should not affect functional ability long term
Sounds like what my left knee needs. Beer league softball at 34 ain’t the same as it used to be
 

NDMD

Well-known member
Messages
545
Reaction score
971
Yeah I don't know the medical terminology but this tracks or should at least be in the ballpark. What I heard was that they had to "clean out" his knee because it was locking up and giving him chronic pain. Don't know if that was cartilage, scar tissue, meniscus, etc. but personally I always get skeptical when there is opaque reporting around joint injuries. We will certainly know by fall camp what we've got.

Yep, I'm not familiar with the mechanism of the orignal injury. If there was no acute injury, it likely is "jumper's knee" and pretty benign. A worse possibility would be if he suffered a partial meniscal tear and it was a debridement of that, would typically require longer recovery on the order of months, not weeks.
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
6,159
Reaction score
7,349
Yeah, he literally just joked around with his teammates. Pretty standard stuff for an injured player. I guess if a kid isn't reciting the Nicene Creed on the sidelines, some of these dorks label him a diva and an ass.

Agreed, just young men talking smack to each other. It's great for team bonding and brotherhood.
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,981
Reaction score
6,111
Yeah, he literally just joked around with his teammates. Pretty standard stuff for an injured player. I guess if a kid isn't reciting the Nicene Creed on the sidelines, some of these dorks label him a diva and an ass.

He didn’t say “god” 15 times in 20 seconds, not an RKG.
 

NumbersGuy0520

Well-known member
Messages
989
Reaction score
1,375
Bumping this thread because I’ve seen a lot of comments lately about Porter’s readiness (or lack thereof) and so I found it interesting to reread his thread history.

Does anyone here—those with background on sports injuries/recovery timelines—think they have a better sense on what we have in Porter? Especially now that a few more months have passed and we’ve seen more from him?

Would be great to see him get back up to speed, but I’m growing pessimistic. Or maybe just impatient. I do think we thought he’d be further along by now.
 

TorontoGold

Mr. Dumb Moron
Messages
7,981
Reaction score
6,111
The media training these kids have is amusing.

The media any time a player does anything different - "He showed an ounce of personality? Yeah, that kid should be thrown away. I want my STUDENT athlete praising god 19 times and taking it one play at a time. THAT'S a true RKG".
 

Rocketman84

Well-known member
Messages
3,103
Reaction score
1,529
Yep, I'm not familiar with the mechanism of the orignal injury. If there was no acute injury, it likely is "jumper's knee" and pretty benign. A worse possibility would be if he suffered a partial meniscal tear and it was a debridement of that, would typically require longer recovery on the order of months, not weeks.
That's exactly what it sounds like in this case
 

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
17,405
Reaction score
17,796
Once again I'm more confused about his timeline than ever. We are now somewhere between a couple of weeks and he may never play football again.
 

Ndaccountant

Old Hoss
Messages
8,432
Reaction score
5,921
Once again I'm more confused about his timeline than ever. We are now somewhere between a couple of weeks and he may never play football again.
dumb-and-dumber-jim-carrey.gif
 
Top