Losing Taylor Decker will be a big deal even if we get Garnett, which is unlikely. You can never have too many lineman and Decker is exactly the kind of prospect who redshirts, plays a backup role for 2 years, then crushes it as a starter in his 4th and 5th year.
He looks to be following the same blue print for leaving that Warriner and Hinton left behind. Meyer takes job, shows interest in you. You say in order "I'm all ND","Here is where I want to be", "I'm committed to ND", then out of nowhere, we all wake up to "I'm leaving for Ohio State".
It's not easy recruiting for ND football anymore. It's an extremely uphill battle doing things "the right way". I think BK and company have been doing a fantasitic job, but it still isn't good enough. The reality is that we need a top 3 recruiting class every single year to even sniff at BCS hopes. We don't cut scholly's, pick up JUCO's, gray shirt, etc. So a top 10-15 class falls out of the top 25 three years down the road when you can't replace a few top guys that don't pan out with a Cam Newton, Nick Fairly, Terrence Cody et al. I don't think enought attention is paid to this. Just check out this article:
Alabama's Jesse Williams leads class of 2011 Top 25 juco prospects - NCAA Football - SI.com. Every year we expect our ND football program to finish like the end of Rock IV where 510" 191-pound Rocky Balboa that did things the right way defeats the evil 6'5" 261 pound roided up Ivan Drago. The only problem is we end up more like Apollo Creed and in real life Drago would destroy Rocky. In the end, what I am saying is that it is a huge deal if we don't keep Decker, can't get Darby back and pull in a few more top notch recruits because our current class is not good enough to be a National Championship contender. Well, I'm saying that and that Urban Meyer is a communist.