Looks like this has just been on Varsity which is weird because I could've sworn I started it on All-American (and it played like that on the first day of the dynasty for me). Maybe it got switched. I'll push it back to All-American and see how I fare.
I've been playing on varsity and winning vs the cpu (play now only). Home games are a breeze, but road games have felt pretty realistic with momentum shifts, with me eventually winning. Games have been vs good, but not great teams that aren't on our schedule. Penn St, Arizona St, Arkansas, TCU, BYU, etc.
White Out game vs Penn St had me falling behind early, coming back to take the lead in the 3rd, Penn St going ahead with 2 minutes left, and me winning on the last drive. Probably the most enjoyable game I've had yet.
I've been experimenting on 8-12 min quarters with accelerated clock to 15 seconds trying to find the right time limit for realistic stats.
I won't start my official Notre Dame Dynasty until there's a patch (or two) released, I find the perfect quarter times, maybe someone posts the perfect sliders, and I settle on a playbook.
It will definitely be on All-American or higher setting though.