'24 MI QB CJ Carr (Notre Dame Signee)

[BeauBenken]

Both comments are basically fact. One kid going to Navy.

I mean you literally had someone point out that Hudsonville has plenty of size. They pointed out that the two teams combined have multiple kids going D1. And they pointed out that Hudsonville went to the playoffs 4 out of the last 6 years.

Some of the things you are acting like need to be necessary for Carr's team and his competition only applies to a handful of teams in any state. Not every program is IMG.

 

[du Lac]

I mean you literally had someone point out that Hudsonville has plenty of size. They pointed out that the two teams combined have multiple kids going D1. And they pointed out that Hudsonville went to the playoffs 4 out of the last 6 years.

Some of the things you are acting like need to be necessary for Carr's team and his competition only applies to a handful of teams in any state. Not every program is IMG.

None of that is fact

 

[BeauBenken]

None of that is fact

 

[Veritate Duce Progredi]

None of that is fact

You are relentless; a true competitor who doesn't care how many times they get knocked down.

You keep trying du Lac, you are bound to be correct eventually..... or just broaden your definition of correct. Or revert half of your original statement and agree to disagree. Or throwout percentages, you can always frame those in various ways.

 

[BeauBenken]

Both comments are basically fact. One kid going to Navy.

Also doesn't saying "basically fact" mean that it is indeed not a fact?

 

[GATTACA!]

Also doesn't saying "basically fact" mean that it is indeed not a fact?

Fact adjacent.

 

[IHateMarkMay]

I'm not going to figure out the height thing. Playoffs:

21-22 - did not make it
20-21 - made it, lost first round
19-20 - made it, won two games
18-19 - made it, won one game
17-18 - did not make it
16-17 - made it, lost first game

This is fact, according to MaxPreps.com

 

[ulukinatme]

Amazing that a state that smells like old hot dog water has such heavy sway with it's Electoral College points. Zero chance James Madison saw that or Rich Rodriguez coming.

 

[du Lac]

 

[Irish4life]

I'm not going to figure out the height thing. Playoffs:

21-22 - did not make it
20-21 - made it, lost first round
19-20 - made it, won two games
18-19 - made it, won one game
17-18 - did not make it
16-17 - made it, lost first game

This is fact, according to MaxPreps.com)

They also play in the highest division in Michigan high school football, and in one of the best divisions in Michigan (Ottawa-Kent Red)

 

[ColinKSU]

and this is why I would never get in to ND. I just caught this.

I’m an idiot. I just thought they wanted those numbers when they got to campus.

 

[MacIrish75]

…Somebody should probably tell Jack Kiser that you can’t be successful at ND if you don’t play in the higher football classifications in your state association…

 

[Jiggafini19Deux]

Not every program is IMG.

Right. They're real high schools as opposed to football camps of an AAU type nature.

100%

 

[StPaul_Irish]

I could be overthinking this, but could all this CJ reclassifying stuff just be media ploy to pressure Avery Johnson to make up his mind and pick ND?

Watch us screw this up and CJ decommits because we keep on him about it. That would be the ultimate Tommy F UP

 

[Irish#1]

Both comments are basically fact. One kid going to Navy.

You're correct, it's not as low as it gets. It's 1A in Michigan. However, I can say, these are low to mid range 1A. Not a single kid on either team will get recruited for D1 football outside of CJ Carr. Doubtful anyone on the opposing team ever sees the field in D2.

Lol, du Lac is relentless with his opinions but they always seem to be wrong. Love how you are unfazed and just keep posting, assuming you'll eventually get it right. Cheers to the optimists of the board!

 

[Irish#1]

.

 

[du Lac]

If my math is correct, that is exactly 45 yards, thrown with relative ease, to the back shoulder, in stride.

 

[GATTACA!]

If my math is correct, that is exactly 45 yards, thrown with relative ease, to the back shoulder, in stride.

I thought he sucked?

 

[du Lac]

I thought he sucked?

Find where I even remotely hinted that he “sucked”. That is absurd. Criticized his play I suppose if you call stating the fact that he turned the ball over a couple times and had poor like blocking. Very different. Not to mention, in the same statement which was pure facts, that he was starting out having a rough night, I mentioned his beautiful pass which nobody else could make.

 

[GATTACA!]

Find where I even remotely hinted that he “sucked”. That is absurd. Criticized his play I suppose if you call stating the fact that he turned the ball over. Very different. Not to mention, in the same statement which was pure facts, that he was starting out having a rough night, I mentioned his beautiful pass which nobody else could make.

Calm down koon that wasn’t directed at you.

 

[du Lac]

Calm down koon that wasn’t directed at you.

Is that a racist slur? That name doesn’t ring a bell besides in that context.

If not directed my way, I apologize. I actually didn’t even look at who I was responding to. Just thought it was the usual suspect. Had I looked at the name I’d not have thought anything of it.

 

[ACamp1900]

I thought he sucked?

That’s the word on the streets these days,……

 

[GrangerIrish24]

That’s the word on the streets these days,……

What’s even better is we orginally were mad at Tommy for even considering Avery Johnson

 

[INLaw]

Is that a racist slur? That name doesn’t ring a bell besides in that context.

If not directed my way, I apologize. I actually didn’t even look at who I was responding to. Just thought it was the usual suspect. Had I looked at the name I’d not have thought anything of it.

Its after a poster you are a little reminiscent of. Like today you are both the driskell and koon but its not really a dig or race related

 

[du Lac]

 

[GATTACA!]

Its after a poster you are a little reminiscent of. Like today you are both the driskell and koon but its not really a dig or race related

Funny thing is what made me think of the connection was their shared opinion on white players sucking. I can vividly remember Koon getting a temp ban for his hot take on white WRs and corners.

 

[StPaul_Irish]

That’s the word on the streets these days,……

$20 is $20

 

[IrishBoognish]

$20 is $20

143245


(if you know you know)

 

[GATTACA!]

143245


(if you know you know)

Amount of cash on hand the FUND has?

 

[Irishdrunk]

Notre Dame makes a move to persuade 5-Star QB C.J. Carr to reclassify

Riddle me this...

www.onefootdown.com