- Messages
- 20,894
- Reaction score
- 8,126
Of course Christianity can be good (and has many times throughout history) been good for the poor but I think that one of the biggest problems with having Christianity as the basis for our society is that it has become divisive. Instead of bringing us together it is tearing us apart. I don't pretend to have all of the answers but I think we need to find something that binds us together not that creates divides. I am loathe to say nationalism because historically it has not worked out well and in the current environment I think that it would definitely not work well.
Nationalism requires a common culture around which a people can rally, and Americans don't have that. We're too ideologically divided. And, as you mentioned, nationalism has led to some pretty atrocious outcomes in the 20th century. I mentioned this recently, but each culture is organized a cultus, a sacred sense of order, a cosmology that roots its moral demands within a metaphysical framework. That's what we have to recover if our republic is going to continue; at the Founding, even though Americans belonged to many different denominations, the common foundation of their Christian faiths still bound them together as a single We, the People.
Now that our society is post-Christian, I have no idea what could possibly fill that void.
*The divisiveness isn't all caused by Christianity, some of it is being caused by secular people as well.
It's just human nature.