Wow, this is big news. Check this out:
As an alum, I don't like this at all. Having a great business school that any ND student could take advantage of was one of the great advantages of an ND education vis-a-vis comparable schools such as UVa. One of my ND roommates entered ND intending to do pre-med, got a C in chemistry, realized he was unlikely to be admitted to med school if he was struggling in science, and switched to Mendoza for his sophomore year. He's now rising through the ranks at PWC and is a lock to make partner if he wants to. Under this new scheme, my friend likely would have never been able to get his accounting degree without transferring, and would have had to do some liberal arts major that he didn't care about just to get through school and would likely not have been as successful. I have some friends from UVa who have had this sort of thing happen to them: admitted to UVa, denied from business school, floundered through school as history majors or psych majors or whatever could get them the sheepskin. While most of them are doing fine, some are still floundering a bit.
I shouldn't even get into the recruiting implications, but ... will we be able to promise recruits that they will be admitted to Mendoza? Is that fair, when their roommates will be kids whose GPA/test scores are twice as high but weren't admitted to Mendoza? Leave football aside ... now the freshman class will be divided among kids who are pre-approved for Mendoza and kids who aren't. That could make for a lot of nasty resentment on campus.
Last I read more than a quarter of ND students were in Mendoza, and I get that ballooning business school enrollment causes problems, so maybe this is inevitable, but it's a shame.