Te'o4Heisman
Well-known member
- Messages
- 2,510
- Reaction score
- 2,616
O)kay guys! I can't decide which is sadder all the bitches that said Bilal warn't sheet when he was being closed moufed about his recruitment, all giggly and happy like today; or those that think this guy isn't explosive!
This kid has (from what little I have heard) a legitimate 4.6 forty, but he has acceleration more like Jaylon. You cannot look at cell phone highlights! You need to look at actual game tape. And the whole thing, not sped up reframed top plays.
It is not whether anyone here is able to evaluate highlights, skill wise; it is whether they are going to commit the time! Anyone ever hear that film study is dedication not inspiration?
Some need to get a life. I am just aggravated that so many brought such garbage to a really great commits thread, and then marginalized him!
I will take Asmar every time!
Don't recall anybody saying he isn't explosive or marginalizing him. A few of us were not overwhelmed with his film. I was one of them, and offered my input on where I thought his greatest areas in need of improvement were. Others may express that they are frustrated that their opinions, although well thought out and explained, are seemingly not welcomed sometimes if they do not jive with the opinions of others just because a player has now become a ND commit. Some of what I say here is more about board posts in general than this thread particularly. It is OK to have differing opinions and be accepting and civilized in our different points of view is it not? Asmar is definitely explosive, fast, agile, etc. However, he lacks physicality, gets caught up in traffic more than you would like, does not always get down hill fast enough and doesn't defeat blocks consistently enough, in my opinion from what I see on film. All areas that he may or may not improve on as gets stronger and better coaching over the next 4 years. Right now though, those areas are liabilities in his game against high school competition. He is a good prospect, however he could just as easily end up being more Steve Filer than Jaylon Smith. Time will tell.