I used the "experienced" settings, but I still use the one button hitting. Square for power, "X" for regular, "O" for contact. I try to use the left joystick to follow the pitch through the zone with the locator, but I usually end up guessing the pitch as well and then I get too excited if I guess right, and then I swing at crap and put the locator completely opposite of where the pitch ends up anyway.
Trying to pull back on the right stick and then push forward for the timing swing style was way too difficult for me.