toronto, you are missing the point.
It doesn't matter whether its 100k, 3M, or 10 people. Civil liberties aren’t a math equation. The constitutional principle is the same: the government cannot strip rights based on identity or dissent.
Branding a class of people (COVID-policy dissenters then, trans people now) as security risks because of their opinions or identity violates viewpoint neutrality (First Amendment) and equal protection, unless the group is traditionally linked to violence. To be clear: I do not think that trans people as a whole are violent; the trans population has violent people like many other groups on both sides of the political spectrum, but the trans population is not a terrorist organization. clearly.
Once the state is allowed to brand a whole group, the precedent is set for whoever’s next. Better hope you don't have personal interests that your government randomly chooses to dislike one day.
Further, saying “they can file lawsuits” ignores that civil liberties exist to prevent the harm before it happens. Saying “sue later” is just an admission you’re fine with rights being trampled so long as the victims can fight in court years after the damage is done.
That's what I've been saying... Someday the oppression of this admin will fall on you...
But, you're missing the point...
1) You're antivax and COVID arguments are not of an equivalent scale - You're looking at abstractly and the Left did this, now the Right is doing this (see, I told you, it would get ugly and some day oppression would come for you).
- I agree with the tenants of what you're saying, but you have to step back and look at it from a much bigger picture - This is not strictly abuse of Federal power for specific groups, this time by the Left, the next by the Right
- They're all wrong and oppressive (I for one was in favor of Vax choice since the RNA ones were not fully vetted IMO, but I think the Federal government thought it was taking the right position in the crackdown, but again it was wrong); I will say, outside the Fed and Healthcare, there were ways to work around this forced Vax policy of corporations and universities, and maybe some healthcare and Fed, and exempt yourself)
- I don't think the Federal govt in COVID times was applying these forced regulations in pursuit of some uber power - They thought it was in the best interest of the country; and Lord knows, both sides make mistakes in these areas (think Japanese internment camps during WWII)
2) Branding the Trans population as NVE is not just an isolated incident taking advantage of the Charlie Rich assassination in an isolated manner.
- Trump and the very large team of Constitutional and Legal experts are targeting groups, laws, institutions (as Bannon was recorded saying today "dismantle the institutions" so that "the Democrats can never steal the vote again like in 2020!") so as to neuter them as ineffective and never allow any other party to win any govt branch elections, ever again and that is their stated goal
- All we need to do is see Project 2025 and listen to guys like Bannon, Kevin Roberts, Russell Vought, Stephen Miller, JD Vance, DJT himself to know what the plan and goals are
- If DJT and his admin have their way, there won't be any future opportunities for any other party like the Democrats to apply Federal regulations that are oppressive; it will be done continually by the Trump admin because there will be no opposition to stop them or entity with the ability to counter this authoritarian regime - Capisce?
That's a little more important degree of abuse of power and oppression. You're acting like this is bullshit Left, Right, and what about-isms.
Fuck that - This is our Democracy and Constitutional Republic going down the drain.
And don't even try and give me "you're being dramatic","you're being emotional," "you have TDS," etc.
Sit back and look and see the current Forest for the Trees...
At this point, DJT and his admin have complete control (Govt, Courts, Media, Universities, ICE/Prisons) and they will be using law fare, insurrection threats, and executive orders to make it so elections never happen again, starting with the mid term elections - See exhibit A (
EO, March 25, 2025: PRESERVING AND PROTECTING THE INTEGRITY OF AMERICAN ELECTIONS) and B (It's already starting:
DOJ Sues Maine, Oregon in Aggressive Move to Seize State Voter Data)
¡Hasta la vista American Democracy!