'24 MI QB CJ Carr (Notre Dame Signee)

[T-Boone]

Right I’m done with Singer.

 

[SoIll]

I know its cheap, but I still cant fathom why anyone is still signed up with On3. Absolute Trash.

 

[IA4irish]

I feel badly for Carr because he is a competitor. Screw em. Use it as a chip. Kid is a stud and natural leader. I’m all in on him

 

[Reaper97]

The 247 recap video, which is about 30 minutes long (so I’m not going to paste), gives you a hint that 247 isn’t moving Carr up.

They have a segment discussing players who lived up to the hype, and dude on talking about Carr says CJ was on the cusp of 5 Star status going into the Elite 11, but he needed to see more from CJ. He didn’t do enough yet.

So top 3 in multiple events & top 5 in another wasn’t enough? Yet some other 5 Star QBs didn’t do that.

 

[T-Boone]

Let’s talk about the kind of cancel culture we can all get on board with. In this fine country, we have this thing called capitalism, which leads to a little thing called consumerism. Well, we as consumers have the absolute right to determine if we deem a product absolute shit, thereby granting us the power to choose NOT to purchase said product. Well, fuck on3. Let us cancel the shit out of them by striking their half-assed recruiting assessments by canceling subscriptions. Let a company fuck around and find out.

Word

 

[T-Boone]

I feel badly for Carr because he is a competitor. Screw em. Use it as a chip. Kid is a stud and natural leader. I’m all in on him

It’s obvious he is a leader but how do we know he is a competitor?

 

[Reaper97]

247 has Carr 5th in their final rankings but doesn’t think he did enough to get a 5 Star rating. But in some bizarro world they have Davis 6th?
247 loves Davis. It’s ridiculous.

 

[NDFAN420]

Word

I had the temerity to question the on3 rankings in general a few months ago and Singer threw a hissy fit using Carr as his specific example. I guess he really showed me

So I got a nice hat and 1.25 years of on3 for $1. Overpriced for what they offer, but worth the eval. It's Sports Illustrated for Kids.

 

[ndinoxford]

The 247 recap video, which is about 30 minutes long (so I’m not going to paste), gives you a hint that 247 isn’t moving Carr up.

They have a segment discussing players who lived up to the hype, and dude on talking about Carr says CJ was on the cusp of 5 Star status going into the Elite 11, but he needed to see more from CJ. He didn’t do enough yet.

So top 3 in multiple events & top 5 in another wasn’t enough? Yet some other 5 Star QBs didn’t do that.

Needed to see more? Did any of them give specifics?

 

[Irish4life]

Needed to see more? Did any of them give specifics?

The only thing that was said was they needed to see CJ give "a little more urgency". Whatever that means.

 

[T-Boone]

The only thing that was said was they needed to see CJ give "a little more urgency". Whatever that means.

I always said that about Tom Brady. Get some hustle.

 

[IrishLax]

On3 is a scam. It’s built around becoming an NIL partner/middleman for athletes. It’ll be a worse version of ESPN rankings where kids who want to work with them and give them access will be propped up and those that don’t they have no incentive to rank highly.

 

[Crazy Balki]

On3 is a scam. It’s built around becoming an NIL partner/middleman for athletes. It’ll be a worse version of ESPN rankings where kids who want to work with them and give them access will be propped up and those that don’t they have no incentive to rank highly.

Yep.

I'm not one to rag on Singer or the guys at B&G illustrated. They do a decent enough job and the community is pretty solid.

But WOW is On3 BAD at their job. Like, speaking of ESPN, On3 is giving them a run for their money in terms of porous recruiting analysis. And ESPN at least has the excuse that their investment in recruiting is a fraction of a percent of their overall coverage.

For On3, THAT'S THE MONEY MAKER!

I get the feeling Pat Engel was looking for any opportunity under the sun to get out of dodge while he had the chance.

 

[IrishLax]

 

[ndinoxford]

The FSU kid who had the worst pro day performance is above Carr? Alright.

 

[Reaper97]

247 had Davis #2 QB in the country.

So of course they had him 6th overall in their ranking. They have to keep him up.

 

[GATTACA!]

For On3, THAT'S THE MONEY MAKER!

We just need a few more dollars to really get this thing popping off!!

 

[IrishBoognish]

Yep.

I'm not one to rag on Singer or the guys at B&G illustrated. They do a decent enough job and the community is pretty solid.

But WOW is On3 BAD at their job. Like, speaking of ESPN, On3 is giving them a run for their money in terms of porous recruiting analysis. And ESPN at least has the excuse that their investment in recruiting is a fraction of a percent of their overall coverage.

For On3, THAT'S THE MONEY MAKER!

I get the feeling Pat Engel was looking for any opportunity under the sun to get out of dodge while he had the chance.

I agree with everything here except that Singer does "good enough at his job" I've never heard him give any real analysis... If you listen to him, all he seems to do is give some variation of, "Well let's talk about X Recruit... Seems like ND really likes him and you should watch his film and draw your own conclusion... He's from X High School and when I've talked to him, he seems like a solid guy. He plays X position and the Irish see him as a good fit. We'll see how it goes."

 

[Irishdrunk]

ND needs Carr to be a 5 star. It matters. Recruits look at rankings and ND hasn’t landed a 5 star since Jaylen Sneed and prior to that is Michael Mayer.

We are not landing these elite recruits.

 

[T-Boone]

Carr is tops but Got to wish we got Sayin.

 

[T-Boone]

I really hope Rees is fired from Bama before he gets to coach Sayin (nothing personal against Rees - it’s just if he is fired it will have meant Bama had a bad year this year which is always 2 on my want list for the season).

 

[Reaper97]

Carr is tops but Got to wish we got Sayin.

Carr is better.

Don’t get wrapped up in camp stuff.

 

[T-Boone]

Carr is better.

Don’t get wrapped up in camp stuff.

I’ll remind you of this post 3 years from now.

 

[Reaper97]

ND needs Carr to be a 5 star. It matters. Recruits look at rankings and ND hasn’t landed a 5 star since Jaylen Sneed and prior to that is Michael Mayer.

We are not landing these elite recruits.

ND landed an elite recruit in Carr.

He would be a top 20 player, 5 Star, if Charles Power didn’t rank him 193.

Remove that one absurd ranking & Carr is a 5 Star.

 

[Reaper97]

I’ll remind you of this post 3 years from now.

Okay.
Just don’t try to compare Bama vs ND.
Eli Manning and Ole Miss didn’t do crap, but he was better than all the QBs who won in college while he was there.
Carr is better than Sayin straight up.

 

[irishff1014]

ND needs Carr to be a 5 star. It matters. Recruits look at rankings and ND hasn’t landed a 5 star since Jaylen Sneed and prior to that is Michael Mayer.

We are not landing these elite recruits.

Carr is probably as good as a QB that we’ll have. He’ll be fine.

 

[FightingIrishLover7]

ND needs Carr to be a 5 star. It matters. Recruits look at rankings and ND hasn’t landed a 5 star since Jaylen Sneed and prior to that is Michael Mayer.

We are not landing these elite recruits.

... And before that, Bruce Heggie

 

[dublinirish]

I like my quarterbacks to have a healthy amount of sacks clearly


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Irishdrunk]

Carr is probably as good as a QB that we’ll have. He’ll be fine.

And that wasn’t my point. We need 5 Star talent to commit to ND. This will be the second class with Marcus Freeman as head coach with no five star commitments. This is not much better than Brian Kelly, who would get a five star once in a while.

 

[brewdog_14527]

And that wasn’t my point. We need 5 Star talent to commit to ND. This will be the second class with Marcus Freeman as head coach with no five star commitments. This is not much better than Brian Kelly, who would get a five star once in a while.

I found you some of those stars you are always worried about!!