‘23 TN QB Kenny Minchey (Notre Dame Signee)

[BeauBenken]

Pitt lovers need to tell me where to bar hop next time and maybe I'll get the chance to give it another try.

 

[rtrn2glory]

Ranking the Midwest/Ohio Valley, here’s my personal thoughts. Chicago doesn’t count, as I’d rank it first every time.

Louisville
Pittsburgh
Milwaukee
Cincinnati
Columbus
Detroit
Cleveland

Been to Louisville once and outside of the track I thought it was a pretty overrated city TBH.

 

[Irish du Nord]

Ranking the Midwest/Ohio Valley, here’s my personal thoughts. Chicago doesn’t count, as I’d rank it first every time.

Louisville
Pittsburgh
Milwaukee
Cincinnati
Columbus
Detroit
Cleveland

Where’s Indy? Milwaukee would be my number 1 of the listed. I also consider MN Midwestern and I rank the Twin Cities ahead of Chicago fwiw, but that’s purely my home state bias

 

[stlnd01]

Where’s Indy? Milwaukee would be my number 1 of the listed. I also consider MN Midwestern and I rank the Twin Cities ahead of Chicago fwiw, but that’s purely my home state bias

Twin Cities is super cool. If I ever left Boston it’d probably be my first choice of cities to move to.

I’d also throw St. Louis on this list. Fun town and not just b/c I lived there for a decade. Lived in Indy for a little bit as well. Meh.

 

[Sea Turtle]

Why are we talking about rust belt dumps?

 

[Irish4life]

Ranking the Midwest/Ohio Valley, here’s my personal thoughts. Chicago doesn’t count, as I’d rank it first every time.

Louisville
Pittsburgh
Milwaukee
Cincinnati
Columbus
Detroit
Cleveland

Would switch Columbus and Louisville but otherwise agree

 

[StPaul_Irish]

Twin Cities is super cool. If I ever left Boston it’d probably be my first choice of cities to move to.

I’d also throw St. Louis on this list. Fun town and not just b/c I lived there for a decade. Lived in Indy for a little bit as well. Meh.

Don't you dare lump St Paul in with that shit hole across the river.

 

[Irish du Nord]

Don't you dare lump St Paul in with that shit hole across the river.

I love Minneapolis, I definitely prefer St Paul (it’s named after an apostle after all), but Minneapolis is great in its own right

 

[StPaul_Irish]

I love Minneapolis, I definitely prefer St Paul (it’s named after an apostle after all), but Minneapolis is great in its own right

Me fighting you right now

 

[du Lac]

I assume he’s referring to Lincoln Riley, but didn’t he accuse ND of something too?

 

[KPENN]

I assume he’s referring to Lincoln Riley, but didn’t he accuse ND of something too?

Tampering with Kenny Pickett

 

[du Lac]

Blow this Tweet up. We need this kid. And I want to see Narduzzi have a stroke. Twitter has warned that it contains sensitive content. Apparently not settling well with Pitt fans.

 

[INLaw]

What does sensitive content mean? Did he misuse a pronoun?

 

[INLaw]

Also i don’t social media so really don’t know

 

[INLaw]

Well that’s what they get for ever letting Dave Wanstedt get away

 

[arndtjc]

Blow this Tweet up. We need this kid. And I want to see Narduzzi have a stroke. Twitter has warned that it contains sensitive content. Apparently not settling well with Pitt fans.

Don’t tweet recruits, it’s weird as hell man

 

[du Lac]

Don’t tweet recruits, it’s weird as hell man

Liking is what I am referring to. So 700 people that liked his tweet are weird? LThey post that shit so people will like it. That’s their sole intent. Nobody said to tweet at him. I agree, tweeting kids is a bit weird. Liking the post is not. I think you misinterpreted my point. If not, you’re on the outside looking in so maybe you’re the weird one.

 

[BeauBenken]

Finally watched his film and honestly, I am impressed. He doesn't seem all that different from Dante.

 

[INLaw]

Finally watched his film and honestly, I am impressed. He doesn't seem all that different from Dante.

Maybe slightly less polished but also maybe a stronger arm. Hows Minchey’s competition?

 

[MacIrish75]

Thats what I thought too, Minchey has a stronger arm but Moore has a quicker release.

*Don’t make this a food thread*
*Don’t make this a food thread*
*Don’t make this a food thread*

It’s like Fruit Loops vs Great Value Fruit Rings. One isn’t as heralded, maybe not as refined, but pound for pound they still both have that same flavor.

I think if you like what Moore offers, Minchey has quite a few of those same qualities, and like others have said—maybe more natural arm talent. He just lacks a couple inches (in height) and the national pedigree.

I said it on another thread, but if we could go back before the ‘23 class really got rolling and we would take a high upside, high arm talent 4star in ‘23 and possibly the top QB in ‘24–who would’ve been upset at that?

Get this kid and let’s go.

 

[MacIrish75]

Also, PJP II is in the Nashville metro area. They play a very solid schedule, including Independence and Knox Catholic, among others.

 

[Irish#1]

Him tweeting like he did has to mean he's interested. The question is, "What level of interest?"

 

[ThePiombino]

Finally watched his film and honestly, I am impressed. He doesn't seem all that different from Dante.

Interesting take. So if this is denial, which stage is acceptance?

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

 

[du Lac]

He’s not as good as Novosad. He’s solid and the best we have left on the table. I’d be happy to get him.

Reports In From Elite 11 Finals On Pitt Commit Kenny Minchey

The Pitt commit was a "pleasant surprise" during day one of the Elite 11 Finals.

www.si.com

 

[BeauBenken]

Interesting take. So if this is denial, which stage is acceptance?

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

I still like Dante better, but they have similar skill sets. They can prolong plays outside of the pocket but they continue to look downfield and are pass first guys. They can both make the quick throws and fit balls into tight windows.

My only thing about Minchey is he completed a lot of heavily contested deep throws. They were dimes of throws but I saw at least a couple that seemed to go over the top of some triple coverage and it's great that he's confident enough to do that against his competition now, but I doubt he's going to get chances like that as he moves up.

It's funny to me that anyone has concern about Minchey's height when we were ready to take Moore who is certainly shorter.

I also for some reason doubt that this will be some kind of easy flip, but I do think we can pull it off.

 

[FightingIrishLover7]

I still like Dante better, but they have similar skill sets. They can prolong plays outside of the pocket but they continue to look downfield and are pass first guys. They can both make the quick throws and fit balls into tight windows.

My only thing about Minchey is he completed a lot of heavily contested deep throws. They were dimes of throws but I saw at least a couple that seemed to go over the top of some triple coverage and it's great that he's confident enough to do that against his competition now, but I doubt he's going to get chances like that as he moves up.

It's funny to me that anyone has concern about Minchey's height when we were ready to take Moore who is certainly shorter.

I also for some reason doubt that this will be some kind of easy flip, but I do think we can pull it off.

Moore certainly shorter? Idk about that. It's a push at best

 

[BeauBenken]

Moore certainly shorter? Idk about that. It's a push at best

Looking at their film to me it looks like Kenny sits taller in the pocket.

 

[du Lac]

I’m still thinking this is kinda funny as there hasn’t been even a whisper of mutual interest on his part.

 

[Dale]

Minchey is definitely shorter than Moore but not by much. Same with Moore versus Sayin. I never really got why Moore’s height never had any critique whereas Sayin got it all the time. Talking 6’1 vs 6’2 in both discussions IMO

 

[IHateMarkMay]

I’m still thinking this is kinda funny as there hasn’t been even a whisper of mutual interest on his part.

I know he hasn't said anything, but isn't the fact that he put on Twitter that he got an offer (from what I've read, the only offer he's posted about) something?

He's not going to publicly say he's interested and piss off Narduzzi. That guy is crazy.