IU felt old to me in the early 90s, Now it's just laughable. Love the tradition, and the noise factor, but good Lord, bull doze the thing. Langford has zero support this year, and has started to wear down. Would love it if he stayed another year, but honestly I can't blaming for wanting to get the hell out either.
ND BB has the same challenges the FB team has, but doesn't have the tradition to fall back on. Not sure facilities make that big of difference (at ND), but it sure doesn't hurt. I just enjoy ND BB for what it is, and set the proper expectations lol. I've done the same with IU, although I did get sucked in to early excitement this year.
Even if TJ was doing well, ....... If having an average class rating of 65th over those two years (17 and 18) is OK, then by all means be happy. It's not going to be the typical recipe for a top 10 or even top 25 team though.
I'm just happy to see Brey do more with less, and occasionally make a run in the tournament.
2017 "class" was rated 108th - we took one guy who was the #49 guy in the country so you kind of have to take that in context. Add in Durham and you have two top 50 recruits in one class - when have we done that before exactly?
2018 ranked #15 - are we now saying five guys ranked #65, 86, 87, 100 and 316 is bad? #15 class in the country - when is the last time we reeled in six top 100 players in a four or five year cycle, let alone TWO.
2016 class was #40 with #88 Gibbs, #146 Mooney and #251 Djogo - Are we really saying two top 50 guys is dramatically worse than 88/146/251?
2015 #43 class of#103 Ryan, #116 Pflueger and #197 Burns
2014 #55 class of #126 Geben, #139 Colson and #422 Farrell
2013 #17 class of #34 DJ, #74 VJ, #106 Vasturia, #365 Torres
2012 #30 with #108 Auguste, #256 Burgett and #40 Biedscheid
2011 #57 with #97 Connaughton and #125 Katenda
Brey has a good track record of retaining his recruits - Biedscheid was it before Ryan and now Burns over six/seven classes - 3/18 if you exclude the freshmen? He has benefited more than he has lost in the transfer market for sure.
Oh - and 2018 at #15 is the highest rated class with only 2013 coming close. Are people expecting a top 20 class year in year out? I'm not. Every 2-3 years with consistent 30-50ish rankings in between and we have a pretty good recipe for Brey I think. Keep everyone in the 150 and up range with a few more top 50 guys and you improve the roster by raising the floor and the ceiling marginally.
As for numbers, we would have 13 on roster if Burns and Ryan were on campus. Rex/Carmody/Durham injured would still leave us 10 players to work with instead of eight now. Reality - taking two in 2017 would have given us four spots in 2018. Still would have had time to bring in Dougherty when Ryan bolted and he would have been a logical and realistic option to slow play with that understanding. Unless Brey is keeping one in the back pocket for potential transfers. Need to sign two for 2019 and feels like we will struggle to get one and are just hoping for a transfer with the other.