College Football Playoff Invitational by ESPN

Are you in favor of Notre Dame getting a top four seed and a bye?


  • Total voters
    93

Me2SouthBend

Well-known member
Messages
2,929
Reaction score
3,660
so 11 - 2 Wake should be in because they can’t control their schedule, what about 11 - 2 UTSA/Memphis? 12 - 1 Liberty? 11 - 2 New Mexico? We just hand out playoff berths because they did the best they could?

Their 2nd best win per FEI right now is Purdue! In OT! ND at least had USC with Pitt.

View attachment 3065954
So SMU is behind Purdue in FEI? Or is this info from before that game?
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,194
so 11 - 2 Wake should be in because they can’t control their schedule, what about 11 - 2 UTSA/Memphis? 12 - 1 Liberty? 11 - 2 New Mexico? We just hand out playoff berths because they did the best they could?

Their 2nd best win per FEI right now is Purdue! In OT! ND at least had USC with Pitt.

View attachment 3065954

I think it is a mute point b/c they aren't dropping an SEC/B1G spot for a second ACC spot which is the larger point. ACC refuses to address the 800 pound gorilla of SEC hogging spots they really haven't earned. ND and BYU should have been in over Bama and OU last year but all we heard about was Miami taking the one available spot.

We still pretend those two teams weren't straight ass heading into the playoffs last year. Indiana beat the brakes off of Bama 38-3 less than 11 months ago but its been memory holed to the point we now have Bama at #3 with two losses. IDGAF what Bama's SoS or SoR or whatever was - they had three losses last year with every person on this board out rushing them in the SEC CCG the same week Hunter Lickadick said they needed to show something in their run game. But the shitbird ACC talks trash and plays the three month old ND @ Miami game on repeat for two days straight. Why not play 5-7 FSU smoking Bama by two TDs that same week?

It was proven last year when Miami - the last team in - made the finals that the answer was both ND and Miami and probably BYU should have been in the field if anyone gave a squat about "best teams" - OU and Bama were hot garbage at year end and they proved it in the playoffs. Bumping whoever SEC#4 ends up being for Wake Forest is not depriving us of a potential champion like pinching ND did in 2025. Bama/Tenn/Texas have no shot of going all the way even with all three in the field. Wake doesn't either but they at least deserve a shot to compete for some ACC respect. ACC #2 winning a playoff game might help the conference more than Miami winning it all.
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,888
Reaction score
6,256
My prediction is: Wake is out if they lose the ACCCG, Miami will still be in if they lose. Couple reasons: Miami is a bigger name and brings more eyeballs, and they won the first matchup with Toney, so they will give them a pass in a game without him.
I was always under the understanding that teams cannot be penalized for playing in the conference championship game. Obviously that did not apply to BYU last year. If Wake Forest is technically in before the championship game will the committee knock them out after they lose? Probably…
 

Blazers46

Adjectives: wise/brilliant/handsome.
Messages
8,888
Reaction score
6,256
Alabamas best wins…. SC will lose to Georgia. Kentucky might lose to Missouri and Louisville to end the season. There is absolutely no way the committee has a leg to stand one keeping them at 3 in the final ranking before CCGs are played. LSU could even end 0-2 to end the season. Texas AM might lose both. Their resume is going to be shit by seasons end.
 

MPClinton22

Well-known member
Messages
1,285
Reaction score
1,871
I was always under the understanding that teams cannot be penalized for playing in the conference championship game. Obviously that did not apply to BYU last year. If Wake Forest is technically in before the championship game will the committee knock them out after they lose? Probably…
It's just such nonsense that these games could be all upside for the participants. Like anything in life - if there's something to be gained, there has to be something to lose. Thank god they're gone after this year
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,194
Okay you’re just arguing a different debate. Wake has two wins that might be unranked wins as their best results. I don’t care what conference you’re in, I can fill that spot with non SEC teams if that plays out. SEC should not get a 5th bid so I’m not sure why you’re overemphasizing the SEC. Did I type anywhere that I want Kentucky or South Carolina to get in instead???

I'm talking Bama/Texas/Tennessee who should be fighting for two spots given SEC failure to show out in prior playoffs and all three have pretty bad losses. As Blazers points out - Bama's resume is falling apart fast yet they have #3 locked down for no good reason. Obviously they are jockeying to keep all three in even if they all end up with a third loss.

ACC should be fighting for a chance to upset the SEC circular reference that limits them to one team in the CFP. SMU WAS RANKED btw - why isn't that a quality win for Wake Forest? South Carolina loses BAD to dogshit Arkansas and stays ranked but SMU is viewed as not a quality win b/c Wake made it look EASY.

Stop carrying water for the committee.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,939
Reaction score
37,378
I'm talking Bama/Texas/Tennessee who should be fighting for two spots given SEC failure to show out in prior playoffs and all three have pretty bad losses. As Blazers points out - Bama's resume is falling apart fast yet they have #3 locked down for no good reason. Obviously they are jockeying to keep all three in even if they all end up with a third loss.

ACC should be fighting for a chance to upset the SEC circular reference that limits them to one team in the CFP. SMU WAS RANKED btw - why isn't that a quality win for Wake Forest? South Carolina loses BAD to dogshit Arkansas and stays ranked but SMU is viewed as not a quality win b/c Wake made it look EASY.

Stop carrying water for the committee.

lol I’ll say for a how many-th time. I don’t care to replace Wake with a SEC team.

I and everyone else think Bama should be lower, you’ve never seen me once say otherwise. What about a semi realistic one at this point? If Tennessee goes 10 - 2 you want to boot them no matter what for 11 - 2 Wake just out of some DEI representation thing? What if again Louisville loses to Kentucky? That just doesn’t matter? An almost direct H2H end of season comparison. If any of Texas, Tennessee or Alabama take a third regular season loss that changes things. But again I can fill that with Oregon or a Big 12 team too. I don’t have to stump for the SEC to not wanna see Wake. The ACC is already effectively getting a second bid, it’s called Notre Dame.

Why do you want Wake Forest in the playoff? Can you explain WITHOUT mentioning the SEC? You’re just firing off a bunch of anti SEC takes, can I hear why you actually want Wake? Wake better hope to God Louisville wins next week, that’s what I would wish for them.
 
Last edited:

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,719
Reaction score
6,754
Alabamas best wins…. SC will lose to Georgia. Kentucky might lose to Missouri and Louisville to end the season. There is absolutely no way the committee has a leg to stand one keeping them at 3 in the final ranking before CCGs are played. LSU could even end 0-2 to end the season. Texas AM might lose both. Their resume is going to be shit by seasons end.
It won’t happen b/c Dabo’s offense couldn’t score in a women’s prison w/ a fist full of pardons, but sure would be a nice time for Clemson to regain their pulse & beat South Carolina.
 

Lord Jim

Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
77
It won’t happen b/c Dabo’s offense couldn’t score in a women’s prison w/ a fist full of pardons, but sure would be a nice time for Clemson to regain their pulse & beat South Carolina.
Louisville beating Kentucky and Clemson beating South Carolina would be hilarious. It would completely kill the narrative and the committee would be forced to think of a different lie. If by some miracle Georgia Tech beat Georgia and Auburn beat Alabama, I think their heads might explode.
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,719
Reaction score
6,754
Louisville beating Kentucky and Clemson beating South Carolina would be hilarious. It would completely kill the narrative and the committee would be forced to think of a different lie. If by some miracle Georgia Tech beat Georgia and Auburn beat Alabama, I think their heads might explode.
UL loves to piss down their legs in the rivalry game vs KY. Even when UL is clearly the better team, they can’t help but piss it away.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,610
Reaction score
3,096
DeBoer's now stumping for the Tide. He must be reading all of the pushback on the committee and think Bama is going to get dropped down.


My neighbor is a huge Bama fan. He stopped me outside to ask if I want to get in on the hate towards Bama. I laughed and asked him to defend his team at #3. The ONLY thing he could come up with was "SOS is at the top. They're in the SEC. Joel Klatt is a tool!" (I didn't even mention Klatt. lol).

I asked if he realized that ND had an almost identical resume last season and got left out and wondered if he could explain why Bama this year is #3 with essentially the same resume. He just stared at me.

I asked if he followed any sort of advanced analytics. He said, "Oh yea! We should go back to the BCS. Everyone hated that system! Remember?! Besides, Alabama is probably #1 if the BCS is still around."

I said BCSKnowHow posts weekly BCS standings. Bama is #7. Notre Dame is #3.

He mentioned pods...

I said, did you know that the advanced metrics lump Bama, Texas, and Tennessee together? And do you remember who won those head-to-head matchups? Texas > Tenn > Bama if H2H is what truly matters.

So please, spare your Bama pitty party. SEC blowhards are just a bunch of mouth breathers.
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,719
Reaction score
6,754
Louisville beating Kentucky and Clemson beating South Carolina would be hilarious. It would completely kill the narrative and the committee would be forced to think of a different lie. If by some miracle Georgia Tech beat Georgia and Auburn beat Alabama, I think their heads might explode.
I think Chattanooga will give Bama a better game than Auburn but no way Bama is losing those two. Had Auburn not upset UGA, I’d give them a shot.

GT used their miracle in 2024 when they had a decent team & they still lost. This GT team will be facing the Dawgs’ second/third teamers by the 3Q
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,967
Reaction score
11,256
ACC should be fighting for a chance to upset the SEC circular reference that limits them to one team in the CFP. SMU WAS RANKED btw - why isn't that a quality win for Wake Forest? South Carolina loses BAD to dogshit Arkansas and stays ranked but SMU is viewed as not a quality win b/c Wake made it look EASY.

Stop carrying water for the committee.
It's not carrying water for the committee to acknowledge that the ACC is a second-tier conference, compared with the SEC or Big 10.

We see enough of them to know why. There's a reason we're like 55-5 or whatever it is against ACC teams over the last decade. They just don't have the depth of talent, the line play, the top-end athletes. Miami aside, what ACC team might scare anyone who is legitimately good? Or could realistically win multiple playoff games?

Sure there's always some ACC team that goes 11-1 or 10-2 and slide into the back end of the playoffs. It was SMU, then Virginia, now Wake. But the fact that it's a different team every year tells you no one in that conference is building a program that can compete consistently. Whereas Bama, Texas and Tennessee are competitive pretty much every year. That buys them a lot of benefit of the doubt.

I have nothing against Wake but I don't really understand the argument for an ACC runner-up, whose best win is... Louisville?... into the playoff over any of those teams. If the goal is to build a tournament of the best teams in the sport.
 

T-Boone

Well-known member
Messages
8,827
Reaction score
5,217
After hearing them talk about it I can definitely see it. I can definitely see the committee wanting to screw ND and put them on the same side of the bracket as Georgia if Georgia wins the SEC.
Georgia should be pissed at that.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,194
It's not carrying water for the committee to acknowledge that the ACC is a second-tier conference, compared with the SEC or Big 10.

We see enough of them to know why. There's a reason we're like 55-5 or whatever it is against ACC teams over the last decade. They just don't have the depth of talent, the line play, the top-end athletes. Miami aside, what ACC team might scare anyone who is legitimately good? Or could realistically win multiple playoff games?

Sure there's always some ACC team that goes 11-1 or 10-2 and slide into the back end of the playoffs. It was SMU, then Virginia, now Wake. But the fact that it's a different team every year tells you no one in that conference is building a program that can compete consistently. Whereas Bama, Texas and Tennessee are competitive pretty much every year. That buys them a lot of benefit of the doubt.

I have nothing against Wake but I don't really understand the argument for an ACC runner-up, whose best win is... Louisville?... into the playoff over any of those teams. If the goal is to build a tournament of the best teams in the sport.

5-7 Florida State beat the shit out of Alabama in 2025. The point of a playoff is to sort that stuff out. If some conference show up two years in a row beating zero P4+ND teams then maybe they aren't all the slobbering pundits claim they are.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,194
lol I’ll say for a how many-th time. I don’t care to replace Wake with a SEC team.

I and everyone else think Bama should be lower, you’ve never seen me once say otherwise. What about a semi realistic one at this point? If Tennessee goes 10 - 2 you want to boot them no matter what for 11 - 2 Wake just out of some DEI representation thing? What if again Louisville loses to Kentucky? That just doesn’t matter? An almost direct H2H end of season comparison. If any of Texas, Tennessee or Alabama take a third regular season loss that changes things. But again I can fill that with Oregon or a Big 12 team too. I don’t have to stump for the SEC to not wanna see Wake. The ACC is already effectively getting a second bid, it’s called Notre Dame.

Why do you want Wake Forest in the playoff? Can you explain WITHOUT mentioning the SEC? You’re just firing off a bunch of anti SEC takes, can I hear why you actually want Wake? Wake better hope to God Louisville wins next week, that’s what I would wish for them.

I'm just poking fun.

Flip your KY script though - let's say Louisville destroys them by three TDs or even wins a close one. FFS its a coin flip at the sportsbook so we aren't talking some major upset here. That says Louisville should be valued just as much as Kentucky in quality win metrics but it is nowhere close in how they are treated.

I want Wake in for the same reason I want Boise State - give a shot to people putting up a good season to see if they can play with the big boys. If they can be competitive on the big stage it makes ND's SoS look a lot better. Why wouldn't ND fans want the ACC to have more street cred?

Tournament of champions - each conference sends their best. I don't see a whole lot of delta between #10 and #30 at this point of a season.
 

Wild Bill

Well-known member
Messages
5,626
Reaction score
3,521
After hearing them talk about it I can definitely see it. I can definitely see the committee wanting to screw ND and put them on the same side of the bracket as Georgia if Georgia wins the SEC.
No chance a 1 seed Georgia draws a 8 or 9 seed ND and I'd be shocked if they gave ND the 5 seed with a chance to win against a cupcake 12 seed.

ND and MIami will be on the other side of the brackets adn will play as early as humanly possible. Could be first round if Miami loses ACC title game or in the quarters if Miami wins ACC.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,939
Reaction score
37,378
I want Wake in for the same reason I want Boise State - give a shot to people putting up a good season to see if they can play with the big boys.

Boise State will have won the PAC 12. I’m not advocating for the ACC Champion to be left out
 

317Irish

Grits are a$$
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,120
Does Tennessee jump us if they beat LSU? That’s a huge win. LSU is only 29 points from being undefeated and the #1 team in the nation, possibly the world.
Same scenario if South Carolina beats Georgia. Gotta go with both of them over ND.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,967
Reaction score
11,256
It seems like the coaches poll is the best each year, the least likely to be corrupt.
Which is kind of wild, because of the groups of people who vote in the various polls, the coaches are the ones with most direct interest in the results.
 

Jeffwantpoppers

Well-known member
Messages
969
Reaction score
1,196
I just want to say that I think it’s bad the chair is also an AD at a SEC that directly benefits from more SEC teams in the tournament. How is this not talked about more?
 

NDMatt91

Well-known member
Messages
3,791
Reaction score
3,785
I just want to say that I think it’s bad the chair is also an AD at a SEC that directly benefits from more SEC teams in the tournament. How is this not talked about more?
Because ESPN is in bed with the SEC. If the Chair of the committee was a Big 10 AD and propped up teams in his Conference, the Finebaum's of the world would be screaming about it 24/7.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,939
Reaction score
37,378
Wards Manuel was a sitting Big Ten AD when the Big Ten got 4 of the top 8 teams in 2024, also a complete gift of a path for Penn State

People think corruption doesn’t touch the Big Ten 😂
 
Top