Kurt “The Coward” Cignetti

Sea Turtle

Slow and steady wins the race
Messages
5,936
Reaction score
3,630
Here's the deal with Indiana -- they are like Notre Dame from a schedule standpoint, but worse. There is a legitimate situation where they end up 11-1 playing only one ranked team the whole year, it hinges on what happens with Northwestern and USC.

They should be evaluated like a G6 team but right now they sit in *comfortable* position to make it in... maybe even so comfortable that they would easily make it in with 2 losses.

Meanwhile no one in the media talks about their schedule, their poor on field showings, etc. and they just keep moving up up up over other 1-loss teams, while ND is almost certainly out of the playoffs if they don't win next week.
I think the media realizes that Indiana is one gaffe foot out of bounds from being undefeated with a win against Ohio State. Their starting QB is also injured.

Indiana clearly isn't as good as last year. No doubt. Notre Dame is very good but needs to tighten some things up. They really need to win it all this year. I think they can but there does come a time when you ask yourself 'if not this year, then when?'
 

MacIrish75

The New Logo is a Jinx
Messages
10,666
Reaction score
20,952
I think the media realizes that Indiana is one gaffe foot out of bounds from being undefeated with a win against Ohio State. Their starting QB is also injured.

Indiana clearly isn't as good as last year. No doubt. Notre Dame is very good but needs to tighten some things up. They really need to win it all this year. I think they can but there does come a time when you ask yourself 'if not this year, then when?'
Now do the one where IU is 2-3 plays away from being 4-3.
 

Old Man Mike

Fast as Lightning!
Messages
9,476
Reaction score
7,366
No mystery to me. They are the defending champs and get creds for that. They walloped Alabama and Oregon getting there. They get a pass for that (as long as they win.) We need to actually beat respected teams. I wish this was different but no one can talk certain things into existence. We need to beat Miami, or have one helluva game.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,643
Here's the deal with Indiana -- they are like Notre Dame from a schedule standpoint, but worse. There is a legitimate situation where they end up 11-1 playing only one ranked team the whole year, it hinges on what happens with Northwestern and USC.

They should be evaluated like a G6 team but right now they sit in *comfortable* position to make it in... maybe even so comfortable that they would easily make it in with 2 losses.

Meanwhile no one in the media talks about their schedule, their poor on field showings, etc. and they just keep moving up up up over other 1-loss teams, while ND is almost certainly out of the playoffs if they don't win next week.
It's because they're in a conference.
 

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
17,986
Reaction score
19,416
It's because they're in a conference.

That's really it. We all know it's objectively wrong but at the end of the day 99% of fans and pundits think we just get to set our schedule every year so if we have a weak schedule it's because we're chickenshit and if Indiana has a weak schedule they get some shit but its "What're they supposed to do? They are in one of the top two conferences." It's stupid because it doesn't reflect reality at all but it's how everyone thinks.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,643
That's really it. We all know it's objectively wrong but at the end of the day 99% of fans and pundits think we just get to set our schedule every year so if we have a weak schedule it's because we're chickenshit and if Indiana has a weak schedule they get some shit but its "What're they supposed to do? They are in one of the top two conferences." It's stupid because it doesn't reflect reality at all but it's how everyone thinks.
It's why I won't entertain any arguments about what a benefit our independence is for us. I actually sorta snapped on a buddy of mine who decided the day after the BYU game was a stellar time to trot out these inane ND points. We lose more than we gain in terms of paths to the playoffs being independent, it bit us hard last year. But, it is what it is.
 

Jiggafini19Deux

Minister of Delayed Gratification
Messages
14,980
Reaction score
16,323
Bryant Haines might be the guy. If he leaves for a college head coaching job and NFL DC job, I'll be curious to see how Cignetti does without him.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
46,229
Reaction score
22,484
That was one crazy fourth quarter and OT, but IU didn't win that as much as Minnesota blew it. There is no way IU should have completed a 35 yard pass with that little time left on the clock. If that play goes for 25 yards or less, the Gophers hang on. Credit both kickers for nailing 60yd FG's under pressure.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,615
Reaction score
3,105
That was one crazy fourth quarter and OT, but IU didn't win that as much as Minnesota blew it. There is no way IU should have completed a 35 yard pass with that little time left on the clock. If that play goes for 25 yards or less, the Gophers hang on. Credit both kickers for nailing 60yd FG's under pressure.

Better to be lucky than good I guess. And IU’s run of luck is unbelievable. Aside from Marsh’s OOB catch against OSU, they’re on the right side of every close game for the last 2 seasons.
 

Jiggafini19Deux

Minister of Delayed Gratification
Messages
14,980
Reaction score
16,323
Better to be lucky than good I guess. And IU’s run of luck is unbelievable. Aside from Marsh’s OOB catch against OSU, they’re on the right side of every close game for the last 2 seasons.
Considering their program's history prior to Cignetti, I know if it were me I would not be apologizing if I were an IU fan.

I don't apologize for ND whipping up on ACC teams now considering how Brian Kelly often spared the rod.
 

jerseyborn1971

Well-known member
Messages
1,073
Reaction score
1,855
I think they lose to USC. The big 10 is a mess. It is entirely possible that the Big 10 reps in the playoff are UCLA and USC.
 

PutuporShutup

Well-known member
Messages
5,173
Reaction score
2,162
I think they lose to USC. The big 10 is a mess. It is entirely possible that the Big 10 reps in the playoff are UCLA and USC.
For USC to get into the playoff they have to run the table. They still play at Indiana and at UCLA. I think they lose one of them. UCLA has a clear path to the CFP with Indiana having the next beth path. OSU and USC have a shot but they can't lose again. Unless OSU gets into the big ten championship at 9-3 with only 2 big ten losses and then wins that game.
 

jerseyborn1971

Well-known member
Messages
1,073
Reaction score
1,855
I can absolutely see USC beating IU and UCLA. That would mean a UCLA v USC Big 10 title game. Doesn't matter who wins at that point. They are both in.
 

jerseyborn1971

Well-known member
Messages
1,073
Reaction score
1,855
UCLA still has to play Minnesota, Michigan and USC. Minnesota can beat them. USC can beat them. Michigan is a ? now with Carr at QB.
 

HouseofPain

Well-known member
Messages
703
Reaction score
641
No mystery to me. They are the defending champs and get creds for that. They walloped Alabama and Oregon getting there. They get a pass for that (as long as they win.) We need to actually beat respected teams. I wish this was different but no one can talk certain things into existence. We need to beat Miami, or have one helluva game.
Yet ND Did not get the same consideration for beating GA and IU
 

FWIrish4

Well-known member
Messages
1,587
Reaction score
3,270
It should be a playoff elimination game, but for whatever reason IU is getting a free pass.

We’ve heard all year how ND has a “2 game schedule” and they can’t lose both.

Well, so does IU and both their games are at home this year. If they lose Saturday, they should be out. No resume to stand on. 0-2 against ranked teams, barely beating mid-B1G teams and only 9 P4 games because of their deliberate OOC scheduling.

Unfortunately, I don’t see anyone mentioning this and have zero faith in the CFP committee.

I may be getting my wish here…

At 9 already and a second loss puts them probably back to ~13-15 with no ranked wins, no ranked opponents left and no B1G title game.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,643
I just don’t think it’ll matter and USC beats them. This IU team is extremely mid
IU is mid and USC is the better team to me in a vacuum, but IU’s defense is fundamentally sound and USC doesn’t travel well. I think IU will pull them down to their level and make it a rock fight. USC will have to march their physicality which I’m not sure if they can.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
38,551
Reaction score
32,789
If they lose to USC and finish with ZERO quality wins + they intentionally water down their OOC schedule to not play P4 teams then you absolutely have to leave them out. Add onto that they needed a miracle to beat Minnesota and went to OT with trash bag Michigan.

People can complain about Bama's ranking but they are a legitimately talented team. IU is just bad. They have a good defense and two elite WRs but their offense is overall dysfunctional. They are like a throwback Iowa team.
 

US_Highway14

Well-known member
Messages
425
Reaction score
811
If they lose to USC and finish with ZERO quality wins + they intentionally water down their OOC schedule to not play P4 teams then you absolutely have to leave them out. Add onto that they needed a miracle to beat Minnesota and went to OT with trash bag Michigan.

People can complain about Bama's ranking but they are a legitimately talented team. IU is just bad. They have a good defense and two elite WRs but their offense is overall dysfunctional. They are like a throwback Iowa team.
Hot take: I can live with Alabama being at #3. At least they beat Mississippi State when they looked like a top 15 team at full strength, before they became decimated with injuries. The Tennessee thing though confuses me. But I'm not offended with Alabama being #3, probably because Notre Dame is more properly ranked in my opinion.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,643
If they lose to USC and finish with ZERO quality wins + they intentionally water down their OOC schedule to not play P4 teams then you absolutely have to leave them out. Add onto that they needed a miracle to beat Minnesota and went to OT with trash bag Michigan.

People can complain about Bama's ranking but they are a legitimately talented team. IU is just bad. They have a good defense and two elite WRs but their offense is overall dysfunctional. They are like a throwback Iowa team.
Yeah, while I think we can beat Alabama, I wouldn’t feel super comfortable about the game per se. Whereas I would love to play IU.
 

NorthDakota

Grandson of Loomis
Messages
16,493
Reaction score
6,817
If they lose to USC and finish with ZERO quality wins + they intentionally water down their OOC schedule to not play P4 teams then you absolutely have to leave them out. Add onto that they needed a miracle to beat Minnesota and went to OT with trash bag Michigan.

People can complain about Bama's ranking but they are a legitimately talented team. IU is just bad. They have a good defense and two elite WRs but their offense is overall dysfunctional. They are like a throwback Iowa team.

If Indiana loses to USC its over for them. I think they'll beat USC but supposing they dont....they dont have anything to hang on.
 
Top