'24 MI QB CJ Carr (Notre Dame Signee)

Chino Cherokee · Oct 14, 2026

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/25509567-br-nfl-scouting-depts-2027-nfl-mock-draft-1-month-trade-deadline

CJ Carr NOT in the first round?

What kind of foolishness is this???

NDMD · Oct 14, 2026

Chino Cherokee said:
https://bleacherreport.com/articles/25509567-br-nfl-scouting-depts-2027-nfl-mock-draft-1-month-trade-deadline

Don't even waste time giving this garbage attention, they're just trying to be inflammatory for engagement

BeatSC · Oct 14, 2026

If Carr has a bad game this weekend is he will be back for another year. If he has a Heisman performance he’s gone and all the ND haters will begrudgingly need to own up to his rightful position near the top of the class.

2013Irish · Oct 14, 2026

Maybe it's possible the Bleacher Report writer assumed Carr would be back and didn't include him. The "hater" narratives people manufacture around a one-off post on a website in decline are kind of astounding.

CANONIZEFATHERSORIN · Oct 14, 2026

BeatSC said:
If Carr has a bad game this weekend is he will be back for another year. If he has a Heisman performance he’s gone and all the ND haters will begrudgingly need to own up to his rightful position near the top of the class.

Saturday will be a very big day for his draft status, that's for sure. I don't think he's had a 300+ yard game yet.

RDU Irish · Oct 14, 2026

CANONIZEFATHERSORIN said:
Saturday will be a very big day for his draft status, that's for sure. I don't think he's had a 300+ yard game yet.

CJ +409 to throw for 300+

So let is be said, so let it be done.

BeatSC · Oct 14, 2026

So Danny Kannel has Carr in his top 5?

OrlaNDomer · Oct 14, 2026

Tough to throw for 300 when you’re icing out games in the 2nd half every week.

Chino Cherokee · Oct 14, 2026

OrlaNDomer said:
Tough to throw for 300 when you’re icing out games in the 2nd half every week.

That's the whole thing right there!

Do people want him to put up 'video-game-like-numbers'? Or just be a pro, dissect the opponents, and just fucking keep winning.

Bane · Oct 14, 2026

CJ's "lack of production" of bulk stats and counting numbers may end up costing him a trip to NYC, but I don't think it will hurt his draft stock. And you know, as much as I would love for him to be a top 3 pick, if he slides a bit to the 10 range and gets to go to a more stable franchise, so be it. Ask Patrick Mahomes if he would really trade being drafted by the Chiefs to go #1 overall.

bpob55 · Oct 14, 2026

Irish#1 · Oct 14, 2026

BeatSC · Oct 14, 2026

Our Favorite site Bleacher Report has a mock draft with 4 ND players in there. Moore at #2, Knapp at #10 them Tae and later on Traore but no CJ. Dante Moore at 30. First QB taken was Ok St QB. They must think we lose all 3 big games and miss the playoffs. I didn’t see that the douche ND hater Danny Kannell was involved.

ulukinatme · Oct 14, 2026

Yeah, a lot of teams that throw for 300 do it because they have to. We've had strong run games and defense, no need to air it out.

ulukinatme · Oct 14, 2026

BeatSC said:
Our Favorite site Bleacher Report has a mock draft with 4 ND players in there. Moore at #2, Knapp at #10 them Tae and later on Traore but no CJ. Dante Moore at 30. First QB taken was Ok St QB. They must think we lose all 3 big games and miss the playoffs. I didn’t see that the douche ND hater Danny Kannell was involved.

Yeah, Kannell is an ass.

RDU Irish · Oct 15, 2026

OrlaNDomer said:
Tough to throw for 300 when you’re icing out games in the 2nd half every week.

Not to mention perpetual short fields thanks to the defense.

I know this but still want it sooooo badly.

bobbyok1 · Oct 15, 2026

Chino Cherokee · Oct 15, 2026

bobbyok1 said:

Poetry in motion.

Would have liked to see the Aneyas reception included. That was freakin SWEET!!!

NDPhilly · Oct 15, 2026

McShay has come around

Jimmy3Putt · Oct 15, 2026

irishff1014 · Saturday at 11:38 PM

He was a complete failure tonight. He himself cost this team 17 points. Missed 2 wide open guys in the end zone then the fumble at half. He should hide his face.

NDPhilly · Saturday at 11:45 PM

unless he shows something different against Miami and the (maybe) CFP, he’s not going to be a top 10 pick. He hasn’t had a “good” performance against a top team yet. Shocking how obviously rattled he was who comes off as ultimately confident.

calvegas04 · Saturday at 11:46 PM

Everytime he changes a play it's clearly a run

yankeehater · Saturday at 11:52 PM

Guessing Chipotle and Vuori are going to want their millions back they gave to Carr and Manning.

Riddickulous · Saturday at 11:55 PM

NDPhilly said:
unless he shows something different against Miami and the (maybe) CFP, he’s not going to be a top 10 pick. He hasn’t had a “good” performance against a top team yet. Shocking how obviously rattled he was who comes off as ultimately confident.

The upside is clearly there but he still needs some work. Think he'll end up coming back.

CanadalovesND · Saturday at 11:56 PM

irishff1014 said:
He was a complete failure tonight. He himself cost this team 17 points. Missed 2 wide open guys in the end zone then the fumble at half. He should hide his face.

Yeah he should own it. I’m not going to flamethrower the man, but he needed to be better tonight… and he just wasn’t.

lcaps20 · Saturday at 11:59 PM

irishff1014 said:
He was a complete failure tonight. He himself cost this team 17 points. Missed 2 wide open guys in the end zone then the fumble at half. He should hide his face.

Hide his face is so fucking stupid, get a grip and grow up

Jimmy3Putt · Sunday at 12:05 AM

Over rated, but he still has a lot of time to improve.
He's definitely not ready for the league and that's good for the program in the long run. Time to get Grubbs or Teddy ready.

calvegas04 · Sunday at 12:57 AM

His passes were so bad tonight. Over shooting WRs, throwing into coverage..ect.

MacIrish75 · Sunday at 12:57 AM

Here’s my thing with his end zone misses:

They repped all week with 87 Flanagan at TE. He gets hurt. Gameplan stays the same. They try the same concepts based on their prep
With Flanigan and Larsen. Dudes are two steps slower. Carr puts the ball where he expects Flanagan to be based on reps. Overthrows each time.

Is that on CJ? A bit. Is it on Denbrock for not adjusting gameplan? Yep.

There’s some nuance there I’m not inclined to put all on “CJ had a bad night.”

'24 MI QB CJ Carr (Notre Dame Signee)

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Catholics vs. Cousins

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Active member

Livin' Your Dream!

Well-known member

Carr for QB 2026!

Carr for QB 2026!

Catholics vs. Cousins

Dominates Wiffle Ball

Active member

Philly Torqued

KooL

Well-known member

Philly Torqued

Well-known member

Well-known member

"That" Guy

Well-known member

Well-known member

KooL

Well-known member

The New Logo is a Jinx