College Football Playoff Invitational by ESPN

Are you in favor of Notre Dame getting a top four seed and a bye?


  • Total voters
    93

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
So Bama looks mid at best, loses, and stays put in the poll?

So the ND/BYU loser must stay ranked right where they are now next week, right?

They have wins over two one loss teams and lost by 3 to the consensus #1. Might be other battles to find there

When BYU loses Saturday, they will have a…..Arizona win to fall back on?
 

ShamrockOnHelmet

Refreshman
Messages
3,066
Reaction score
2,120
They have wins over two one loss teams and lost by 3 to the consensus #1. Might be other battles to find there

When BYU loses Saturday, they will have a…..Arizona win to fall back on?
Lemme guess, SEC teams?

GTFO with bama defense.
 

jerseyborn1971

Well-known member
Messages
1,073
Reaction score
1,855
Let all the mid and bad teams get and stay ranked. All that means is they are more likely to make the playoff, which is good news for actually good teams.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,958
Reaction score
11,255

This is why an eight-team playoff would be just fine, and 24 is bullshit.
The top seven teams on that list are the only ones capable of winning the championship, and even that feels generous to Texas and Indiana.
8-20 feels like completely interchangeable good-but-not-great teams.
After that, whatever. (though I suppose Oregon has enough talent they could do some damage if they got their shit together).
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,698
Reaction score
1,576
This is why an eight-team playoff would be just fine, and 24 is bullshit.
The top seven teams on that list are the only ones capable of winning the championship, and even that feels generous to Texas and Indiana.
8-20 feels like completely interchangeable good-but-not-great teams.
After that, whatever. (though I suppose Oregon has enough talent they could do some damage if they got their shit together).
There's a team that was left out of the 12-team CFP last year that very easily could've won it.

Miami nearly got left out and wound up in the championship.
 
Last edited:

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,125
Reaction score
6,559
There's a team that was left out of the 12-team CFP last year that very easily could've won it.

Miami nearly got left out and wound up in the championship.
Yeah, I used to agree that 8 was enough but I’ve learned that 8 and 12 do not capture every team that could win it all which should be the point of a playoff. 16 to me is the sweet spot, 24 is too many.
 

Huntr

24 Karat Shamrock
Messages
9,010
Reaction score
12,836
The concept was good, but the BCS blew, too.

It included shit-tastic models created by wholly unqualified people. They could re-do it nowadays and include good models and have something worthwhile
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
7,129
Reaction score
8,840
The concept was good, but the BCS blew, too.

It included shit-tastic models created by wholly unqualified people. They could re-do it nowadays and include good models and have something worthwhile

The BSC was tough/flawed because it was only two teams. With 8, it would've been near perfect. The computer didn't have an SEC or Big 10 bias.


Of course there would still be the number 9 team crying. Just like the 25th team will cry when they miss the eventual 24 team playoff.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
The issue is the CFP rankings have basically mirrored the BCS with slight adjustments. In theory that is good, use proven data plus human discernment. In practice, it’s been suspect at best, manipulation at worst instead.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,958
Reaction score
11,255
The issue is the CFP rankings have basically mirrored the BCS with slight adjustments. In theory that is good, use proven data plus human discernment. In practice, it’s been suspect at best, manipulation at worst instead.
I think given the huge sums of money involved in making the CFP now, having this decided by human beings with vested interest in certain outcomes (like a sitting SEC athletic director voting on whether the last at-large team is Alabama or Notre Dame) is inviting trouble.
 

NDdomer2

Local Sports vBookie
Messages
17,172
Reaction score
3,993
There's a team that was left out of the 12-team CFP last year that very easily could've won it.

Miami nearly got left out and wound up in the championship.
Left out of the 12 team CFP last year and the best 12 teams last year aren't the same.
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,698
Reaction score
1,576
Left out of the 12 team CFP last year and the best 12 teams last year aren't the same.
Yeah, and left out and Depends undergarments aren't the same. You're bringing shit out of left field that nobody's talking about. Want a cookie?
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,698
Reaction score
1,576
Lanning's a piece of shit.

Not sure where this belongs, so I'm posting it here for UCLA's sake.

 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,192
Three FCS opponents and 8 home games? Is that the SEC "expectation" Suckey is referencing? Part of me wants a 24 team playoff just to watch the 12 SEC teams that inevitably get shoved into it lose.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
I think we get a Big Ten/SEC challenge. They already do this for basketball. It won’t be every team, but like 8 games one weekend. Just enough to plaster on Fox, FS1, ESPN, ABC in most time slots.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,192
I think we get a Big Ten/SEC challenge. They already do this for basketball. It won’t be every team, but like 8 games one weekend. Just enough to plaster on Fox, FS1, ESPN, ABC in most time slots.

And box out other conferences to maintain the circular reference. "oh Purdue lost to OSU so Arkansas losing to Purdue just proves how amazing they both are for showing up."
 
Top