Which is better because the stakes are lower. If Michigan or USC got left out this year, who cares? Neither team is winning a national title. My problem with the current set up is it doesn't ensure that every team with a conceivable possibility to win a title gets in and imo that should be the sole purpose of a playoff in college football. 16 would ensure that. There will always be debate, but I'm less sympathetic to teams 15-18 sitting there with 3 losses (or two really bad losses) pounding the table. This year has taught me that a team with a real championship potential could be left out and I'd rather have too many teams in than not enough.