'26 MI QB Tommy Carr

[NDFAN2008]

Am i crazy for thinking it is worth going someplace like Miami for a couple years to get playing time?

Am I crazy for thinking he ends up having a better college career than Grubbs?

 

[dublinirish]

Carr’s Record-Breaking Night Leads Saline to Rout of Dexter - The Sun Times News

It was one for the history books for Saline quarterback Tommy Carr Friday night. Carr set numerous school records and put himself in the MHSAA record books with over 500 yards passing and eight TD passes in the Hornets 61-34 SEC Red showdown rout of Dexter. The eight touchdown passes in a game...

thesuntimesnews.com

Having an elite senior season. Not the same mensurables to project as well as CJ but swoop in here as it’s only a matter of time before a major P4 flops him

just got way more weapons/OL strength than CJ had.

Lincoln Keyes the TE is committed to UGA.

 

[Dale]

 

[notredomer23]

Allen Triue’s player comp for him is Riley Leonard

 

[NDFAN2008]

Not saying he is as good as CJ but he reminds me alot like him. I'd offer him take a second QB, let him and Grubbs battle it out after next season.

 

[Dale]

Allen Triue’s player comp for him is Riley Leonard

No offense to Tommy but has Allen seen Leonard run?

 

[dublinirish]

 

[NDFAN2008]

I don't see why you wouldn't offer him anyone else thinking the same?

 

[GowerND11]

I think you let him go to Miami, let him develop there, then get him as a transfer if he performs well.

 

[dublinirish]

if you kind a scholly for Ron Powlus then you can find one for Tommy surely

 

[DomeFieldAdvantage]

if you kind a scholly for Ron Powlus then you can find one for Tommy surely

We're living in a whole different roster management era than we were then.

 

[dublinirish]

We're living in a whole different roster management era than we were then.

exactly it should be an easier decision nowadays

 

[Dale]

If he has the talent to play college football but likely not at Notre Dame there is no use of him riding the pine and taking reps from others. And I’m sure he has higher aspirations than that. Still talking about a MAC QB commit right now.

The portal exists if proven wrong.

 

[SoIll]

Not going to lie, I had not paid much attention nor watched any of his film. I know he plays in a smaller league and still only has MAC offers, but he moves different, balls comes out of his hands different. Tommy > Grubbs


.....they can also do better than both.

 

[NDVirginia19]

Not going to lie, I had not paid much attention nor watched any of his film. I know he plays in a smaller league and still only has MAC offers, but he moves different, balls comes out of his hands different. Tommy > Grubbs

Pretty sure he's gotten some offers from lower tier P4 schools like Wake and Rutgers. Think he even has an Iowa State offer too

 

[NDpendent]

I don't see why you wouldn't offer him anyone else thinking the same?

Nope

 

[Dale]

His throwing motion is a bit long

 

[arndtjc]

I don't see why you wouldn't offer him anyone else thinking the same?

Not sure he's big enough to play DT unfortunately

 

[NDPhilly]

If he can’t get CJ to stick around through his senior year (or longer) then he’s worth a scholarship.

 

[TorontoGold]

If he has the talent to play college football but likely not at Notre Dame there is no use of him riding the pine and taking reps from others. And I’m sure he has higher aspirations than that. Still talking about a MAC QB commit right now.

The portal exists if proven wrong.

I don’t know why the consensus isn’t what you posted.

Why not let him go to a school for two years and see if he develops, at which point you NIL him if Herbert/Grubbs aren’t cutting it. This isn’t 2014 and ND is a “have” school not a “have not”.

Most blue blood schools are going to be in tough having three promising QB’s.

 

[Riddickulous]

Flipped to Michigan

 

[NDFAN2008]

Honestly shocked we didn’t offer him I like Grubbs but I think Michigan is banking he ends up as good as CJ which he can

 

[Dale]

Michigan has flipped two Miami (OH) commits in the last week.

Shopping down a different aisle.

 

[NDPhilly]

They have to be seeing something in Noah I’m not lol.

 

[Dale]

Michigan is banking he ends up as good as CJ which he can

Michigan has a 6 million dollar QB a class ahead of him and another commit, but he tore his ACL just a few weeks ago. This is Michigan signing a legacy QB to fill a depth chart spot. Good for Tommy Carr, he grew up a Michigan fan.

 

[SoIll]

Michigan has a 6 million dollar QB a class ahead of him and another commit, but he tore his ACL just a few weeks ago. This is Michigan signing a legacy QB to fill a depth chart spot. Good for Tommy Carr, he grew up a Michigan fan.

And he’s going to be a good player somewhere. Maybe not at a Michigan when it’s all said and done, but imo he’s going to be good. More athletic than CJ. Maybe not as good of intangibles, but I personally like him more than Grubbs. This is more than just “signing a legacy”

 

[Dale]

And he’s going to be a good player somewhere. Maybe not at a Michigan when it’s all said and done, but imo he’s going to be good. More athletic than CJ. Maybe not as good of as intangibles, but I personally like him more than Grubbs. This is more than just “signing a legacy”

I think Grubbs is a far superior prospect, and it’s not really close. The arm talents aren’t in the same realm.

 

[irishff1014]

Flipped to Michigan

Booooo

 

[ColinKSU]

Michigan has a 6 million dollar QB a class ahead of him and another commit, but he tore his ACL just a few weeks ago. This is Michigan signing a legacy QB to fill a depth chart spot. Good for Tommy Carr, he grew up a Michigan fan.

Speaking of legacy QBs, he'll be sharing a QB room with Kirk Herbstreit's kid.

 

[FightingIrishLover7]

Bump