2025 WATCH PARTY: WEEK TWO

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Hes a Massachusetts Jewish guy who went to Michigan, built his company in Boston/NYC, and lives in Miami. Nothing wrong with any of that, but it doesn't scream fitting the vibe of Ames, Iowa. By the way, great place to catch a game if your alma mater is playing there or something.

If you were gonna give me a bro-dude to head down to Ames and be on a pregame show, give me Will Compton.
There is a subset of people here in Boston who don't know jack shit about college football but went to Michigan (often, though not in Portnoy's case, for grad school) and act like they do. He's just one of those - with a sports media company at his disposal.
 

Irish du Nord

Well-known member
Messages
3,416
Reaction score
3,065
Portnoy's the obnoxious class clown who's now 50 and hasn't found his personality beyond that. Will wear offensive hats and be the loudest one in the room to compensate for lack of depth.
Hey hey hey, no personality?

He also likes pizza
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Eh, KSU is coming off 10-4, 9-4 and 9-4 seasons, and won the Big XII in 2022, when the Big XII was still quasi-decent.

I'd say it would take a bad year in '25 and a bad start in '26 for them to axe Klieman.
Big 12 feels like it's going to be an annual crapshoot. A bunch of programs with similar resources and recruiting turfs. No true traditional powers, not a lot of doormats either. Kansas State is as well-positioned to thrive as anyone, but there's no particular guarantee that they will. I guess that's where the coaching comes in.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
16,113
Reaction score
27,371
Kleiman is nowhere close to a hot seat but I do think for the post-OU/Texas departure, this has been a disappointment. Not like NIL is an issue either. You expected probably to go from 8 - 9 wins to 9 - 10 annually and there is no sign of that happening yet.

5 - 4 in conference last year was a step back from the prior two seasons.
 
Last edited:

NorthDakota

Grandson of Loomis
Messages
15,701
Reaction score
6,002
Kleiman is nowhere close to a hot seat but I do think for the post-OU/Texas departure, this has been a disappointment. Not like NIL is an issue either. You expected probably to go from 8 - 9 wins to 9 - 10 annually and there is no sign of that happening yet.

5 - 4 in conference last year was a step back from the prior two seasons.
Things would have to get bad for 2-3 years before they'd make a change i think. Kansas State has basically zero history of success in football lol
 

Jiggafini19Deux

Minister of Delayed Gratification
Messages
13,483
Reaction score
14,206
Illinois needs to take care of business against WMU and then piss pound Cignetti back to wherever he came from.

Then it's SC a week later.

I hope they get it done x 2.
 

Irish du Nord

Well-known member
Messages
3,416
Reaction score
3,065
Illinois needs to take care of business against WMU and then piss pound Cignetti back to wherever he came from.

Then it's SC a week later.

I hope they get it done x 2.
I can’t cheer for SC, and I’d love to see IU punished on the field for their scheduling philosophy. Don’t think I’ll cheer for the Illini outside of that, though. Go Broncos!
 

Jiggafini19Deux

Minister of Delayed Gratification
Messages
13,483
Reaction score
14,206
Big 12 feels like it's going to be an annual crapshoot. A bunch of programs with similar resources and recruiting turfs. No true traditional powers, not a lot of doormats either. Kansas State is as well-positioned to thrive as anyone, but there's no particular guarantee that they will. I guess that's where the coaching comes in.
You're spot on. Everyone is talking about all of the money Texas Tech is going to spend, but the two in state SEC counterparts are also going to be able to inject cash into NIL and The Portal as they choose to. It is also the one conference that probably makes the most regional sense in terms of where all of the member are located. Which isn't saying much.

There really isn't what you'd call a "blue blood" among them when you look at their standings. Could actually be intriguing year in and year out in terms of the regular season race.
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,262
Reaction score
1,113
Things would have to get bad for 2-3 years before they'd make a change i think. Kansas State has basically zero history of success in football lol
1993Bill Snyder9–2–14–2–13rdW Copper1820
1994Bill Snyder9–35–23rdL Aloha1619
1995Bill Snyder10–25–2T–2ndW Holiday67
1996Bill Snyder9–36–23rd (North)L Cotton1717
1997Bill Snyder11–17–12nd (North)W Fiesta78
1998Bill Snyder11–28–01st (North)L Alamo910
1999Bill Snyder11–17–1T–1st (North)W Holiday66
2000Bill Snyder11–36–2T–1st (North)W Cotton89
2001Bill Snyder6–63–5T–4th (North)L Insight.com
2002Bill Snyder11–26–22nd (North)W Holiday67
2003Bill Snyder11–46–21st (North)L Fiesta1314
 

sfk324

Well-known member
Messages
1,711
Reaction score
2,276
Things would have to get bad for 2-3 years before they'd make a change i think. Kansas State has basically zero history of success in football lol
They've had 2 years of 8-4 teams in a Big 12 conference that isn't exactly setting the world on fire. They have also won two straight Nobody Cares Bowls presented by Who Gives a Shit, to bring the record to 9-4 both seasons. That might be enough combined with the 2022 season to keep th seat from being too warm in the near term for a guy who has a history of success at NDSU....but the way college fans work, there has to be a not insignificant portion of their fanbase who think bringing their golden boy back as head coach will up their level.
 

NorthDakota

Grandson of Loomis
Messages
15,701
Reaction score
6,002
1993Bill Snyder9–2–14–2–13rdW Copper1820
1994Bill Snyder9–35–23rdL Aloha1619
1995Bill Snyder10–25–2T–2ndW Holiday67
1996Bill Snyder9–36–23rd (North)L Cotton1717
1997Bill Snyder11–17–12nd (North)W Fiesta78
1998Bill Snyder11–28–01st (North)L Alamo910
1999Bill Snyder11–17–1T–1st (North)W Holiday66
2000Bill Snyder11–36–2T–1st (North)W Cotton89
2001Bill Snyder6–63–5T–4th (North)L Insight.com
2002Bill Snyder11–26–22nd (North)W Holiday67
2003Bill Snyder11–46–21st (North)L Fiesta1314
Yes. Bill Snyder had a nice run there. Forgot to include that.

But we are talking about a program with an all time losing record, and losing records against nearly every conference opponent they've had. Just not a very good program through the years. They should be significantly better in the new Big 12 though as others have mentioned.

klieman is fortunate too that the athletic director hired him at North Dakota State and Kansas State. Guessing he'll get more rope than one normally would expect
 

ColoradoIrish

Well-known member
Messages
900
Reaction score
1,288
Yes. Bill Snyder had a nice run there. Forgot to include that.

But we are talking about a program with an all time losing record, and losing records against nearly every conference opponent they've had. Just not a very good program through the years. They should be significantly better in the new Big 12 though as others have mentioned.

klieman is fortunate too that the athletic director hired him at North Dakota State and Kansas State. Guessing he'll get more rope than one normally would expect
KSU's decline since Coach Snyder was fully expected. His success was largely due to how they recruited JUCO and because of the Kansas JUCO system. I coached at Dodge City Community college and had the pleasure of meeting Coach Snyder and he has had a total different philosophy than any other coach there and fully understood the limitations and difficulty of being in Manhattan. I don't people fully understand how many grown men they had under Coach Snyder because of his they recruited JUCO under him
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,262
Reaction score
1,113
Yes. Bill Snyder had a nice run there. Forgot to include that.

But we are talking about a program with an all time losing record, and losing records against nearly every conference opponent they've had. Just not a very good program through the years. They should be significantly better in the new Big 12 though as others have mentioned.

klieman is fortunate too that the athletic director hired him at North Dakota State and Kansas State. Guessing he'll get more rope than one normally would expect
Yeah, I get all that. Still, outside of a 4-win Covid season, Klieman has two 8-win seasons, two 9-win seasons, and a 10-win season. All of this following a 5-win season by KSU's legendary HC. If we're adopting the perspective that KSU is historical shitty (and rightfully so based on natural disadvantages like location), one could argue Klieman's done a fantastic job.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Yeah, I get all that. Still, outside of a 4-win Covid season, Klieman has two 8-win seasons, two 9-win seasons, and a 10-win season. All of this following a 5-win season by KSU's legendary HC. If we're adopting the perspective that KSU is historical shitty (and rightfully so based on natural disadvantages like location), one could argue Klieman's done a fantastic job.
End of the day, it's Kansas State. Only so good they're ever going to be. Kleiman's been fine, basically. If they think Colin Klein can do better, OK. But maybe they should see how A&M does for a year or two first?
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,262
Reaction score
1,113
End of the day, it's Kansas State. Only so good they're ever going to be. Kleiman's been fine, basically. If they think Colin Klein can do better, OK. But maybe they should see how A&M does for a year or two first?
Yeah, they can do as they please, but he might prove to be their Frank Solich in the long run. I still find it hilarious that Nebraska (another school with location issues, and a program built on steroids, advanced weight training, and training tables before anybody else realized muscle mass could be helpful in football) fired a guy who finished in the top 7 in three of his six years and in the top 20 on two other occasions.

Of course, I also thought Georgia firing their all-time greatest HC (Mark Richt) was about the dumbest thing ever, but sometimes rolling the dice pays off.
 

NorthDakota

Grandson of Loomis
Messages
15,701
Reaction score
6,002
Yeah, they can do as they please, but he might prove to be their Frank Solich in the long run. I still find it hilarious that Nebraska (another school with location issues, and a program built on steroids, advanced weight training, and training tables before anybody else realized muscle mass could be helpful in football) fired a guy who finished in the top 7 in three of his six years and in the top 20 on two other occasions.

Of course, I also thought Georgia firing their all-time greatest HC (Mark Richt) was about the dumbest thing ever, but sometimes rolling the dice pays off.
Nebraska crashing out the way they did will never not be funny.
 
Top