Ask Merckxe525 aka Dear Abby

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
I guess he's back in the game, at Marshall, now. But it was pretty striking that Stuckey was...
A: Sent packing the day after Freeman talked about wanting all his coaches back next season
B: Not hired anywhere else for a year. Maybe someone like Harry Heistand can sit out a season but Stuckey's only been in coaching for a few years as it is.
Neither are a ringing endorsement of his coaching.
 

INLaw

Hardcore chooch
Messages
4,537
Reaction score
4,095
I guess he's back in the game, at Marshall, now. But it was pretty striking that Stuckey was...
A: Sent packing the day after Freeman talked about wanting all his coaches back next season
B: Not hired anywhere else for a year. Maybe someone like Harry Heistand can sit out a season but Stuckey's only been in coaching for a few years as it is.
Neither are a ringing endorsement of his coaching.
Possibly was just a very bad fit here. Also possible stuckey may learn and grow from it.
 

rtrn2glory

Well-known member
Messages
16,172
Reaction score
6,452
Gentlemen your response about Brown not being a skilled recruiter has me wondering...... What is important in your opinion to be a "skilled" recruiter and what is it that's holding him back?
 

NCIrish24

Member
Messages
17
Reaction score
34
Merck/Bua - I don’t think this question has been posed yet but could you give a high level summary of what the recruiting process looks like behind the scenes with Freeman and the assistants?

Do they discuss specific recruits everyday or do they have more of a weekly discussion to cover certain prospects? I know this was discussed on a podcast I recently listened to where they mentioned Urban Meyer would pull up the big board of prospects and hold each assistant accountable and even call the recruits himself to confirm they had spoken with the assistant.

Im just wondering if that’s how Freeman runs recruiting as well. Im sure he gives them plenty of autonomy. Sorry for this being so long winded.

Appreciate your contributions to the board!
 

BuaConstrictor

Well-known member
Messages
3,277
Reaction score
1,920
Merck/Bua - I don’t think this question has been posed yet but could you give a high level summary of what the recruiting process looks like behind the scenes with Freeman and the assistants?

Do they discuss specific recruits everyday or do they have more of a weekly discussion to cover certain prospects? I know this was discussed on a podcast I recently listened to where they mentioned Urban Meyer would pull up the big board of prospects and hold each assistant accountable and even call the recruits himself to confirm they had spoken with the assistant.

Im just wondering if that’s how Freeman runs recruiting as well. Im sure he gives them plenty of autonomy. Sorry for this being so long winded.

Appreciate your contributions to the board!
Long answer, but I'll touch on this tomorrow. TLDR preview, it depends a lot on the time of year, the coach, the recruit, etc. It can be hyper dependent.
 

NDMatt91

Well-known member
Messages
3,533
Reaction score
3,453
Gentlemen your response about Brown not being a skilled recruiter has me wondering...... What is important in your opinion to be a "skilled" recruiter and what is it that's holding him back?
The last part of your question would be good to ask the ISD folks. They say Brown puts in genuine effort with recruiting, but he just really, really sucks at it. I have no clue whether it's he can't relate to the kids, he can't read the room, or he's a bad evaluator.
 

ndfanatic78

I have unconditional love for every one of you.
Messages
1,559
Reaction score
1,782
He is saying ND will replace the USC game with Clemson when USC cancels its series with ND.

Which, of course, would be horrible. Replace an annual rivalry game lasting 100 years for a game with a team we've played 8 times, almost all of which as a result of our bizarre ACC alignment. The games with Clemson have been really good, and it is good if we replace some of the random ACC games against Virginia/NC State/Wake Forest with Miami/Florida State/Clemson.

But we need the annual USC game to continue. I really hope we can make that happen.
ND does not need it in any way.
 

BuaConstrictor

Well-known member
Messages
3,277
Reaction score
1,920
- An excellent recruiter knows when to discuss football; when to discuss academics; when to shoot the shit; and, when to simply be a friend a recruit can tell anything to.

- Quality recruiters are part psychiatrists; part psychologists; part friend; part parent; part grandparent; and, occasionally, a babysitter.
For context: Deland and Mickens were/are so damn good at this...like...SO damn good at this.
 

JamIrish

Well-known member
Messages
535
Reaction score
807
Can you guys speak on Jaylen Sneed a little bit? He's my favorite player on defense and would like to know about his progression last year: from the rumors he wasn't happy, to being a big contributor come playoff time. Does he start at Will or is KVA slotted there? Who's the fifth linebacker that may see playing time or are we set with 4? Thanks in advance.
 

NDWarrior

Well-known member
Messages
3,011
Reaction score
2,422
Brown is the type of man who takes time to get to know. He doesn’t come across impressively, immediately. He’s not the type of person to own the room; or, have people gravitating toward him.

Unfortunately, all of the above often doesn’t translate well with teenagers - especially teenagers who’ve often had their asses kissed for several years.

Skilled recruiter:

- Needs to make an immediate impression.

- Needs to be able to build trust immediately.

- Needs to be in constant contact with recruits, but also needs to be able to time that constant contact properly. (Consistent, frequent communication, that continues to show interest, and builds trust, without sounding inauthentic, or allowing communication to drag on)

- The best recruiters will constantly create a sense of urgency.

- A quality recruiter always shows a recruit that he/she always has that recruits back, and he/she is willing to always make that recruit a priority.

- An excellent recruiter knows when to discuss football; when to discuss academics; when to shoot the shit; and, when to simply be a friend a recruit can tell anything to.

- Quality recruiters are part psychiatrists; part psychologists; part friend; part parent; part grandparent; and, occasionally, a babysitter.

- The best recruiters quickly create a picture of what a recruit’s potential fit is within the program, and why that fit is superior to the fit of any other program.

- At the same time, if the recruiter is a coach, that coach had better be able to quickly demonstrate to any recruit why his/her coaching style is best for that recruit, and superior to any other coach at any other program.

Of the above, Brown is skilled at no more than 40%.
I would say you left out that it's also very much a sales role... which I know seems obvious. But I mean a true value-building salesperson; one who paints a very positive future for the recruit and his role on the team and conversely, the "pain" he will feel if he doesn't commit to ND and what he'll not be getting at any other school. And then closing the deal with awesome stories about his coaching strengths and successes and what he's done with other receivers currently on the team and those who have moved on to the NFL (hopefully) and that he'll do this with the recruit at ND as well. And lastly, seal it up with the ND difference (4 for 40, campus/gameday experience, MMFF, etc).
 

BuaConstrictor

Well-known member
Messages
3,277
Reaction score
1,920
- He's always been a bit homesick.

- He's always felt that he should have been seeing more time.
Not to jinx it, but I was somewhat surprised Sneed wasn't in the portal after the season. Glad he stuck around so far.

He's a guy where if it "clicks"...he has near All-American upside. I'm a big believer in him...and I know many in the program still are.
 

JamIrish

Well-known member
Messages
535
Reaction score
807
- He's always been a bit homesick.

- He's always felt that he should have been seeing more time.

- Sneed has an amazing motor, but that motor needs to be under control; at times, he's struggled with that. However, Sneed is really starting to understand that to be at his best, he can't regularly allow himself to wash out of plays.

- It's up in the air whether he will start this coming season. Sneed has certainly made huge strides, but his game can be somewhat limited in comparison to those he's competing with for playing time.

- KVA is supremely talented, and it will be very hard to keep him off the field. His measurables, motor, feel for the game, and ability to understand his assignments, is well above where it should be.

- It will be shocking if Faraimo isn't in the rotation, quick, fast, and in a hurry.

Awesome! Thanks for the info.
 

rtrn2glory

Well-known member
Messages
16,172
Reaction score
6,452
Brown is the type of man who takes time to get to know. He doesn’t come across impressively, immediately. He’s not the type of person to own the room; or, have people gravitating toward him.

Unfortunately, all of the above often doesn’t translate well with teenagers - especially teenagers who’ve often had their asses kissed for several years.

Skilled recruiter:

- Needs to make an immediate impression.

- Needs to be able to build trust immediately.

- Needs to be in constant contact with recruits, but also needs to be able to time that constant contact properly. (Consistent, frequent communication, that continues to show interest, and builds trust, without sounding inauthentic, or allowing communication to drag on)

- The best recruiters will constantly create a sense of urgency.

- A quality recruiter always shows a recruit that he/she always has that recruits back, and he/she is willing to always make that recruit a priority.

- An excellent recruiter knows when to discuss football; when to discuss academics; when to shoot the shit; and, when to simply be a friend a recruit can tell anything to.

- Quality recruiters are part psychiatrists; part psychologists; part friend; part parent; part grandparent; and, occasionally, a babysitter.

- The best recruiters quickly create a picture of what a recruit’s potential fit is within the program, and why that fit is superior to the fit of any other program.

- At the same time, if the recruiter is a coach, that coach had better be able to quickly demonstrate to any recruit why his/her coaching style is best for that recruit, and superior to any other coach at any other program.

Of the above, Brown is skilled at no more than 40%.

Appreciate the input and insight despite it being quite discouraging and disappointing. To your point about getting to know him I heard him speak a few years ago at a clinic and thought he had some good drills and at the time seemed like a bright young upcoming coach. I'm not sure if his time in the league just made him more inclined to talk to old guys like me and he maybe has had trouble adjusting to the role of talking recruiting and coaching high school kids. Sometimes guys need to start at a little lower level maybe before they move up. Seems like from your responses he's good on the practice field but maybe outside of that he lacks the talent to be an elite overall college coach. Hopefully he gets it figured out soon
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,591
Reaction score
20,040
I would say you left out that it's also very much a sales role... which I know seems obvious. But I mean a true value-building salesperson; one who paints a very positive future for the recruit and his role on the team and conversely, the "pain" he will feel if he doesn't commit to ND and what he'll not be getting at any other school. And then closing the deal with awesome stories about his coaching strengths and successes and what he's done with other receivers currently on the team and those who have moved on to the NFL (hopefully) and that he'll do this with the recruit at ND as well. And lastly, seal it up with the ND difference (4 for 40, campus/gameday experience, MMFF, etc).
Agree, but what Merck described is a lot of selling. ABC baby!
 

NDohio

Well-known member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
3,060
- He's always been a bit homesick.

- He's always felt that he should have been seeing more time.

- Sneed has an amazing motor, but that motor needs to be under control; at times, he's struggled with that. However, Sneed is really starting to understand that to be at his best, he can't regularly allow himself to wash out of plays.

- It's up in the air whether he will start this coming season. Sneed has certainly made huge strides, but his game can be somewhat limited in comparison to those he's competing with for playing time.

- KVA is supremely talented, and it will be very hard to keep him off the field. His measurables, motor, feel for the game, and ability to understand his assignments, are well above where they should be.

- It will be shocking if Faraimo isn't in the rotation, quick, fast, and in a hurry.
With the addition of Faraimo, it kind of seems like Nolan Z is the odd man out. That’s too bad, kid seems like a good player but he has been recruited over - which is good for the program. Do you seen him transferring?
 

SoIll

Licensed to Ill
Messages
2,830
Reaction score
2,924
Brown is the type of man who takes time to get to know. He doesn’t come across impressively, immediately. He’s not the type of person to own the room; or, have people gravitating toward him.

Unfortunately, all of the above often doesn’t translate well with teenagers - especially teenagers who’ve often had their asses kissed for several years.

Skilled recruiter:

- Needs to make an immediate impression.

- Needs to be able to build trust immediately.

- Needs to be in constant contact with recruits, but also needs to be able to time that constant contact properly. (Consistent, frequent communication, that continues to show interest, and builds trust, without sounding inauthentic, or allowing communication to drag on)

- The best recruiters will constantly create a sense of urgency.

- A quality recruiter always shows a recruit that he/she always has that recruits back, and he/she is willing to always make that recruit a priority.

- An excellent recruiter knows when to discuss football; when to discuss academics; when to shoot the shit; and, when to simply be a friend a recruit can tell anything to.

- Quality recruiters are part psychiatrists; part psychologists; part friend; part parent; part grandparent; and, occasionally, a babysitter.

- The best recruiters quickly create a picture of what a recruit’s potential fit is within the program, and why that fit is superior to the fit of any other program.

- At the same time, if the recruiter is a coach, that coach had better be able to quickly demonstrate to any recruit why his/her coaching style is best for that recruit, and superior to any other coach at any other program.

Of the above, Brown is skilled at no more than 40%.
Why was he hired then?
 

dublinirish

Everestt Gholstonson
Messages
27,323
Reaction score
13,091
tbf fellas all my questions are original and insightful

E7ABmE4WEAMqFL7.jpg
 

BuaConstrictor

Well-known member
Messages
3,277
Reaction score
1,920
Do we see any of the LBs being bulked up and moved to edge full time?
Full time? No. KVA and Sneed will be used in packages (as they have been) to supplement pass rushing..especially until Traore is back to 100%..but..as of now..full time? I don't see anyone doing that. ND is really high on Bryce Young(duh) and Loghan Thomas..and Burgess can/will crack the rotation IMO...kid might be a monster.
 

BuaConstrictor

Well-known member
Messages
3,277
Reaction score
1,920
Merck/Bua - I don’t think this question has been posed yet but could you give a high level summary of what the recruiting process looks like behind the scenes with Freeman and the assistants?

Do they discuss specific recruits everyday or do they have more of a weekly discussion to cover certain prospects? I know this was discussed on a podcast I recently listened to where they mentioned Urban Meyer would pull up the big board of prospects and hold each assistant accountable and even call the recruits himself to confirm they had spoken with the assistant.

Im just wondering if that’s how Freeman runs recruiting as well. Im sure he gives them plenty of autonomy. Sorry for this being so long winded.

Appreciate your contributions to the board!
Happy Friday and good morning!



Two things in advance

-I apologize in advance if Big Merckxe already covered some or all of this. I started typing this last night in a Word doc after my last post because I knew it was going to be a long post and I haven’t checked the board

-Some of this information may be so general as to be not useful but short of writing a 2,500 word essay on the topic it would be impossible to cover all the small ins and outs of how any recruiting department runs. So much can change day to day and week to week that it’s nearly impossible to cover. So this will be a VERY high level overview and I’ll try to tie it to ND and the way things currently run..or will run with these new GM positions as best I can. A lot of the below won’t be specific to ND in general, a lot of programs have similar systems and set-ups for recruiting.



First and foremost, recruiting never sleeps. Figuratively and somewhat literally. It might be the only department in a football program that works every single day of the year in much the same way. Are there daily meetings? Yes. Are there weekly meetings? Yes. It’s also always evolving. The department is going to look much different this year with Bowden gone. Merckxe and I covered this but it will be a bit more professional in it’s look and feel and organization. Bowden ran a loose ship. It felt very “college”. Martin will have the department feeling much more like an NFL front office..but trying to meld together the college “fun”/feel.

In regards to meetings, there is always at least one weekly meeting with the coaching staff. During bye weeks or non-game weeks in the offseason there can and will be more, but there is always at least one. There also is and can be weekly meetings with position groups. Freeman is at around..maybe…75-90% of these depending on his schedule. If he’s not there he’s getting updates from them and follows up later. Freeman is always involved. He’s meeting with the recruiting coordinator(s) and the individual coaches to know what is needed from him in respect to a player, a group, or an event. Daily meetings are more common this time of year and heading into signing day depending on how the class is closing out and who/if ND is still chasing.

Most schools (ND included) typically has a “2.5” year board at all times. So right now the boards are ’26, ’27, and kids they are intently watching early in the 2028 class. A kid like Vernon would have been one of those on the “early” board back when he was a recruit. Early boards also usually contain a lot of QBs and RBs. Part of how/why every team gets on QBs so early now.

Recruiting is also working with current commits on messaging they want out, taking the temperature of the class, and having them reach out to recruits. Under Martin my impression is this will be much more organized and the messaging the recruiting office will be putting out will be more targeted, cohesively “branded”, and messaged.

The portal has obviously changed things quite a bit so you have teams of people in recruiting reviewing film every week from around the country, taking and making notes of players, and aligning those players with the board in the office of where ND feels they do or will need help as they watch the recruiting board morph and shift over the cycles. Obviously right now, lots of film of WRs being looked at as opposed to scouting of OL. It wouldn’t surprise me if within….two years?...that ND expands the department and hires a small team/group of professional scouts or talent evaluators simply for this this purpose and that filters down to HS recruiting as well. You may also see ND pulling from NFL personnel scouting departments and getting interns or lower level scouts to come to the college level for a “promotion” in title under Matt Jansen. Jansen has a small staff now..but I’d look for it to expand/grow/evolve with Martin in charge.

I’m trying to think of anything else but…recruiting is A LOT….I can’t stress that enough. At this point I’ve forgotten parts of the question so feel free to follow up on anything I’ll do the best I can to answer but some of it I may not be able to as it’s highly internal.
 
Top