‘21 AL QB Riley Leonard (Duke Transfer - Notre Dame Verbal)

DillonHall

Tommy 12-2
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
1,737
Bullshit. I'm not saying he needs to be Trevor Lawrence. But they should be able to hit 10 yards routes routinely. Should be able to hit receivers in stride. Should be able to throw guys open. Angeli is MORE than enough.
I think Leonard gives us a better chance to win than Angeli. I didn't think that through the first quarter of the Miami game, but this offense has continued to improve. There's no bigger pain in the ass for opposing defenses than a mobile QB. If we can keep progressing getting WRs involved, we're gonna be really hard to stop on offense

I don't know who told you Leonard was an amazing passer. Every single beat reporter in the offseason said he was a "work in progress" as a passer. Even when they talked about him looking good in fall practice, they always included the caveat that they barely got to watch practice and a lot of what they saw was against air
 

DillonHall

Tommy 12-2
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
1,737
Leonard went 16/22 for 229 yards and accounted for 4 TDs and no turnovers. Clearly the best game of his ND career.

Anyone whining about Leonard tonight looks really really dumb. Take a break for the week and root against him next week so that you can actually have some evidence on your side
 

CanadalovesND

Well-known member
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
5,946
Also worth noting that Stanford had one of the worst, something like bottom 20% passing defense, leading up to the game.

But Riley made the throws, and that’s all you can hope for regardless of the foe and their ranking defensively.
 

mrmcgrail

Well-known member
Messages
804
Reaction score
1,175
He had a good game against a bad pass defense but I am still worried with his ability to hit consistently. Hopefully this is a turning point for him and he gains some confidence from it
 

SDIrishFan

Well-known member
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
2,570
He had a good game against a bad pass defense but I am still worried with his ability to hit consistently. Hopefully this is a turning point for him and he gains some confidence from it
He hit throws into tight windows today. Better than I’ve seen all year. He missed a cpl throws but this is the Leonard we were promised. If he keeps it up, we’ll be in the playoffs.
 
Last edited:

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
44,619
Reaction score
20,104
The extra time for Denbrock to work with him paid dividends. This is three games in a row where his passing improved from the previous game. This was a bigger leap and RL looked comfortable regardless of how good the defense was or wasn’t.
 

FWIrish4

Well-known member
Messages
1,408
Reaction score
2,833
He's simply not what was promised. People are over here with raging hard-ons because he's "looking better". Dude can't make routine throws you expect from a D1 P4 QB. Full stop. All at the expense of at least one of Angeli, Minchey, or Carr. He's mobile. Cool. So is our RB stable. Give me a QB who can make all the throws.
Talk about being hyperbolic man. Relax a bit.

Here’s his stat lines in the last two P4 WINS:
- 33/45 (73% - yeah he can’t make any throws)
- 5 TD’s (pretty sweet)
- 0 turnovers (idk I think this is important for QBs)
- Sacked just 2 times (with our banged up OL this is a miracle, but he has elite sack avoidance, which he has his entire career)
- 83 rushing yards (his best attribute we didn’t even have to use today)
- 2 rushing TDs (opposing D coordinator’s worst nightmare in the red zone)

THIS is what was expected from Leonard and is definitely getting it done if it continues.
 

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2026!
Messages
31,523
Reaction score
17,410
Passed for over 200 yards for the first time this year, and we're halfway through the season. That's kinda wild. He only did it twice last year in a shortened season due to injury, never hitting 300+. 2022 he managed to top 200 yards 4 times, and 300+ 3 times.
 

irishff1014

Well-known member
Messages
26,514
Reaction score
9,289
Anyone could see that Riley looked better today but that’s expected when you play a defense that bad.

You can see him going though his reads now as opposed to the going to the line and saying I am throwing to Collins, if he isn’t open I am running.

Hope he keeps improving for ND’s sake.
 

ThePiombino

The OG "TP"
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
6,245
I'm simply not going to be impressed with a P4 SENIOR "work in progress" QB. Was he better today? Best game at ND? Fuck yeah! Great, in a vacuum. Embarrassing in context. Is his current version good enough to get us to the playoffs? Most likely. But it's also equally likely that we lose to anyone left on our schedule (see: NIU).

What happens if/when we make it to the playoffs? Maybe we host a 1st round game, and maybe we win. What happens when we inevitably play a team with a solid defense that includes a secondary with a pulse? Can RL make the throws required to keep those defenses honest? Or will they just play a better version of stack the box. Watch how quickly our offense gets shut down because RL can't make the big boy reads or the gimme throws consistently.

You all can be happy we made it that far in one of the more winnable seasons in recent history. I'll be over here looking forward to next season when we (hopefully) put a QB behind center instead of a glorified RB.

EDIT: I want to be wrong. I want nothing more than to see ND win a national championship and to unanimously be considered among football's elite. I just think that requires WAY more from the QB position than this.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,387
Reaction score
10,249
I'm simply not going to be impressed with a P4 SENIOR "work in progress" QB. Was he better today? Best game at ND? Fuck yeah! Great, in a vacuum. Embarrassing in context. Is his current version good enough to get us to the playoffs? Most likely. But it's also equally likely that we lose to anyone left on our schedule (see: NIU).

What happens if/when we make it to the playoffs? Maybe we host a 1st round game, and maybe we win. What happens when we inevitably play a team with a solid defense that includes a secondary with a pulse? Can RL make the throws required to keep those defenses honest? Or will they just play a better version of stack the box. Watch how quickly our offense gets shut down because RL can't make the big boy reads or the gimme throws consistently.

You all can be happy we made it that far in one of the more winnable seasons in recent history. I'll be over here looking forward to next season when we (hopefully) put a QB behind center instead of a glorified RB.

EDIT: I want to be wrong. I want nothing more than to see ND win a national championship and to unanimously be considered among football's elite. I just think that requires WAY more from the QB position than this.
I think we all want Riley Leonard to a be better passer than he is.
But going through a whole season being like "Oh no we might lose in the second round of the playoffs. What a disappointment." seems like a miserable way to be a college football fan. Enjoy yourself out there.
 

ThePiombino

The OG "TP"
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
6,245
I think we all want Riley Leonard to a be better passer than he is.
But going through a whole season being like "Oh no we might lose in the second round of the playoffs. What a disappointment." seems like a miserable way to be a college football fan. Enjoy yourself out there.
I'm not watching each game thinking it ends in the second round of the playoff. That's best case. Much more likely is we stumble before then because of our severe limitations at the QB position. All because we couldn't properly evaluate the position yet again. This is arguably the second (if not third) time in Freeman's 3 years that we got it wrong. That's frustrating. Everything was lining up for ND to make a serious run for a title this year. I just don't see that as even remotely possible with what RL is out there offering. Again, I want nothing more than to be wrong.

But I'm not blindly negative, I do acknowledge there have been improvements in this game. For example, even though he throws an absolute garbage deep ball, at least he's attempting that now. And that alone will force most defenses we face to play honestly. He also has apparently finally discovered the slant pattern, which we saw him hit for a couple of TDs yesterday. There were also a few plays where he seemingly read the field which was very encouraging considering he was a single read quarterback just a couple of weeks ago. These are all great improvements, again - in a vacuum. And maybe if this was a freshman quarterback I'd be really excited. But he's not and so I'm not. He's a one-year senior rental with multiple years experience in FBS. We deserve better than to be told to get excited because our senior quarterback read the field or hit a 10-yard slant.
 

irishff1014

Well-known member
Messages
26,514
Reaction score
9,289
I'm not watching each game thinking it ends in the second round of the playoff. That's best case. Much more likely is we stumble before then because of our severe limitations at the QB position. All because we couldn't properly evaluate the position yet again. This is arguably the second (if not third) time in Freeman's 3 years that we got it wrong. That's frustrating. Everything was lining up for ND to make a serious run for a title this year. I just don't see that as even remotely possible with what RL is out there offering. Again, I want nothing more than to be wrong.

But I'm not blindly negative, I do acknowledge there have been improvements in this game. For example, even though he throws an absolute garbage deep ball, at least he's attempting that now. And that alone will force most defenses we face to play honestly. He also has apparently finally discovered the slant pattern, which we saw him hit for a couple of TDs yesterday. There were also a few plays where he seemingly read the field which was very encouraging considering he was a single read quarterback just a couple of weeks ago. These are all great improvements, again - in a vacuum. And maybe if this was a freshman quarterback I'd be really excited. But he's not and so I'm not. He's a one-year senior rental with multiple years experience in FBS. We deserve better than to be told to get excited because our senior quarterback read the field or hit a 10-yard slant.

I 100% understand what you are saying but this isn’t all on him. Some of it is in the ones the recruited him. Issue #1 was his ankle injury 🚩 and second was his abilities. That’s 100% on freeman, Denbrock and Gino.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,387
Reaction score
10,249
I'm not watching each game thinking it ends in the second round of the playoff. That's best case. Much more likely is we stumble before then because of our severe limitations at the QB position. All because we couldn't properly evaluate the position yet again. This is arguably the second (if not third) time in Freeman's 3 years that we got it wrong. That's frustrating. Everything was lining up for ND to make a serious run for a title this year. I just don't see that as even remotely possible with what RL is out there offering. Again, I want nothing more than to be wrong.

But I'm not blindly negative, I do acknowledge there have been improvements in this game. For example, even though he throws an absolute garbage deep ball, at least he's attempting that now. And that alone will force most defenses we face to play honestly. He also has apparently finally discovered the slant pattern, which we saw him hit for a couple of TDs yesterday. There were also a few plays where he seemingly read the field which was very encouraging considering he was a single read quarterback just a couple of weeks ago. These are all great improvements, again - in a vacuum. And maybe if this was a freshman quarterback I'd be really excited. But he's not and so I'm not. He's a one-year senior rental with multiple years experience in FBS. We deserve better than to be told to get excited because our senior quarterback read the field or hit a 10-yard slant.
Again, I don't think anyone on this board is "excited" about our quarterback play. Clearly Leonard is limited as a passer, and that probably puts a ceiling on our season. You're absolutely right to expect more of a guy who is in his third year as a P4 starting quarterback. Yet this is what we've got. You can blame whoever you want for that.

But Leonard has improved this season - he and Denbrock deserve some credit for that - and if he and the rest of our offense play the rest of the year like they did yesterday, we could well host a playoff game, and who knows from there. I'm not going to be pissy about that. Sorry.
 

ThePiombino

The OG "TP"
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
6,245
I 100% understand what you are saying but this isn’t all on him. Some of it is in the ones the recruited him. Issue #1 was his ankle injury 🚩 and second was his abilities. That’s 100% on freeman, Denbrock and Gino.
Agreed. I'm not blaming RL for the limitations. He didn't put a gun to anyone's head and force them to not only accept his transfer in, but also pay him handsomely to do so. A LOT of people got this one wrong...
Again, I don't think anyone on this board is "excited" about our quarterback play. Clearly Leonard is limited as a passer, and that probably puts a ceiling on our season. You're absolutely right to expect more of a guy who is in his third year as a P4 starting quarterback. Yet this is what we've got. You can blame whoever you want for that.

But Leonard has improved this season - he and Denbrock deserve some credit for that - and if he and the rest of our offense play the rest of the year like they did yesterday, we could well host a playoff game, and who knows from there. I'm not going to be pissy about that. Sorry.
I think there are several people here (not necessarily you) who are so relieved that RL has, in fact, showed improvement (which I agree he has) that they think all is well and we are on our way. I simply don't agree on the latter part and I believe those folks are simply unable (unwilling?) to see the forest for the trees? I agree Denbrock deserves a ton of credit. RL didn't JUST learn how to become a decent passer. It's clear that Denbrock is scheming to his abilities better. That is great! Wish it was this way since week 1/2, but better late than never I suppose. Bottom line is, IMO, it won't be remotely enough to compete for what ultimately matters -- a natty. Would love to be wrong, but I don't think I am. And I don't think anyone who's actually paying attention would think so either.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,546
Reaction score
29,005
I posted in the fall camp thread before the season that someone said “think Josh Allen at Wyoming” and that comp has basically been spot on. He’s a poor man’s Josh Allen. Super dynamic in the run game, but inaccurate to the point of missing some “layups” in the passing game. The bigger issue for me is that … unlike Allen … he doesn’t have the arm strength to make you pay with big vertical throws when he escapes pressure and can extend.

So he’s going to kill about 2 drives a game by missing throws he should make, but then how much does he help your run game because of his legs? Because anything that helps our RBs get quality opportunities might be worth the trade off… they are absolutely dynamic.
 

CoachB

Well-known member
Messages
1,282
Reaction score
1,825
Sorry guys, but Riley easily gives our offense the best chance out there. Our running backs are as explosive as they are in part because of Riley's running ability. It is a threat every play. Steve is a solid backup, but he would take many more sacks and the defense wouldn't have to respect his running as much. The absolute best case for us is what is happening. Riley's passing game improves and we continue to thrive offensively. Give me a running QB who is completing 73% of his passes the past two games and I will show you a super dangerous offense. I know backup QB is the most popular guy for some, but there is a reason he is backup. That being said, I am grateful we have Steve. I think he is very solid and does a nice job when called upon.
 

DillonHall

Tommy 12-2
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
1,737
Like I said after the Louisville game, I like the trajectory of the offense. Our OL continues to get experience, Leonard simply looks much more confident throwing the ball, the WRs are finally getting involved, and we still have another bye week to continue to progress

It's not often that you see this much in-season progress (granted, we started at a pretty pathetic level). I'm proud of the players and coaches for working hard to get better. Enjoy each game and each season because we don't get that many. There's no sense in worrying about the end of the year or next year when we have a Top 10 team right now
 

DillonHall

Tommy 12-2
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
1,737
I think there are several people here (not necessarily you) who are so relieved that RL has, in fact, showed improvement (which I agree he has) that they think all is well and we are on our way. I simply don't agree on the latter part and I believe those folks are simply unable (unwilling?) to see the forest for the trees? I agree Denbrock deserves a ton of credit. RL didn't JUST learn how to become a decent passer. It's clear that Denbrock is scheming to his abilities better. That is great! Wish it was this way since week 1/2, but better late than never I suppose. Bottom line is, IMO, it won't be remotely enough to compete for what ultimately matters -- a natty. Would love to be wrong, but I don't think I am. And I don't think anyone who's actually paying attention would think so either.

So what's your solution? Give up on the season and play Carr instead?
 

OhioIrish

Well-known member
Messages
469
Reaction score
494
Sorry guys, but Riley easily gives our offense the best chance out there. Our running backs are as explosive as they are in part because of Riley's running ability. It is a threat every play. Steve is a solid backup, but he would take many more sacks and the defense wouldn't have to respect his running as much. The absolute best case for us is what is happening. Riley's passing game improves and we continue to thrive offensively. Give me a running QB who is completing 73% of his passes the past two games and I will show you a super dangerous offense. I know backup QB is the most popular guy for some, but there is a reason he is backup. That being said, I am grateful we have Steve. I think he is very solid and does a nice job when called upon.
Lot of good points here and I hope RL continues to progress into a true dual threat, but I still disagree on the whole. At the moment, Riley Leonard gives us a better chance only because the coaching staff has spent half the the season getting him to the point where he can perform like a Power 5 QB — which he is, although he is by no means elite at this point. In the meantime, this approach has cost us loss to lowly NIU, cost us development at the WR & RB positions, and has likely damaged our recruiting efforts. Had Angeli been the starter from game one we are likely 6-0, with a developed passing game and RBs attacking down hill against defenses who have to respect both the ground and air attacks. Right now, RLs running prowess hurts the RB production as a competent defense can just stack the box. I do think a well protected RL, fully developed, and performing at his peak potentially gives us a great unique advantage against playoff opponents. The problem is, it is a near certainty that all three of these conditions will never be met.
 

MacIrish75

The New Logo is a Jinx
Messages
9,198
Reaction score
17,761
I’m just past the point of gnashing teeth about who he is as a QB. A bit unfortunate he won’t ever quite live up to the hype…but a lot of us are to blame for that hype.
 

DillonHall

Tommy 12-2
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
1,737
It's too late to do anything other than let it ride with RL now. But that doesn't change the fact that it was a poor evaluation and our season ceiling is severely limited.
Yeah he's not the passer we were hoping for. But I'd rather have this trajectory than what happened last year when Hartman looked great at the start and was eventually exposed as being mediocre. Leonard looks much more comfortable throwing the ball compared to NIU and even Purdue. I don't think our ceiling is drastically limited by him anymore. Call me crazy, but I think this team is good enough to make the semifinal
 

ThePiombino

The OG "TP"
Messages
16,476
Reaction score
6,245
Yeah he's not the passer we were hoping for. But I'd rather have this trajectory than what happened last year when Hartman looked great at the start and was eventually exposed as being mediocre. Leonard looks much more comfortable throwing the ball compared to NIU and even Purdue. I don't think our ceiling is drastically limited by him anymore. Call me crazy, but I think this team is good enough to make the semifinal
I want nothing more than for you to be right. I just don't think that you are.
 

bkess8

Us vs. Them
Staff member
Messages
7,626
Reaction score
1,419
I wish I drank the cool aid that most of you on this board have, but I've been burned too many times by just getting in there by ND. RL is leading us to another let down IMO. Yes, can we make the playoffs with RL at QB? Is it highly likely that we make the first round of the playoffs and get our butts kicked with RL at QB? Yes. Who cares if he is improving every week? He is a glorified RB with a crappy QB arm. He can't make routine throws and under throws wide, open downfield routes, or simply short arms throws that 75% of P4 QBs would make. Many are high on his running ability but who cares? We have one great back in Love and one highly productive solid back in Price. Great that RL had a productive day against a horrible Stanford defense but what happens when we get down against USC like Penn St did, can we make a comeback through the air when the D expects it? RL cannot lead us to a comeback victory through the air.

Sorry for the long rant but while it was a good win yesterday, it was also another frustrating or boring win against a team that many are praising our poor QB instead of holding him accountable and realizing what reality is with him at the QB position.
 
Top