The point is that neither side is serious about addressing the problem. Political theater. Way to wave your hands about something tangential to the topic to ignore the key point.
I’m not hand waving but I’ll have the conversation if you are serious about it.
IMO The point is that we need immigrants to do jobs no one else will. They aren’t taking black jobs. They aren’t taking white jobs. They primarily take jobs no one else wants to do and they keep this country moving. They also pay billions in taxes via sales tax and federal wage taxes. H1B1 visas aren’t picking fruit or building track homes and asylum is a real legal issue that could be reformed. I’m ok with that but this is a country built on the refuse of the world landing here and allowing them to choose their own path. It’s kind of our thing you know. Along with nativists being butt hurt about it.
I’m all form the border being secure and immigrants coming through legal means. The point is the borders of this country is too big to be fully secure. It just is. Deal with it. Whatever you think would be big enough is not. And to do it would cost more than the defense budget to build and maintain and staff. I’ll have a conversation on this point alone as long as you want…. There is nothing we could build, staff and maintain, that would completely stop crossings that would not cost trillions and become yet another beaurocratic quagmire you conservatives would complain incessantly about. I care even less. About your personal outrage over one specific crime out of the hundreds of thousands of crimes committed by natural born citizens daily.
The point is that a small number will commit crimes relative to the population just like any other society and their crime rates are lower than natural born citizens.
The point is that this Haitian immigrant (which are legal immigrants) issue is a made up bullshit story started by right wing propagandists and trolls to gin up red meat for the MAGA base to stoke hate and fear. And it has done it’s job resulting in threats to the city hall and closing of schools in he area along with harassment of the Haitian people themselves. So predictable and you know that nothing is gonna get done because there isn’t anything to do with something doesn’t exist. Trump and Vance continuing to push this bullshit gonna get someone hurt. It’s GOP election strategy. Racist Demagoguery. Ok we get it. You are scared of other races. We know.
And yet again the right gets consumed with hating on people that aren’t white males in an election year. That’s why they do it. Because Brawndo has what you crave. It’s tiresome and predictable. No one cares you are butt hurt yet again by made up bullshit. Illegal immigration is like item number 10 on my list things I care about.
Illegal immigrantion neds to be managed better. For sure but it can’t and will never be completely stopped and the fact is we need immigrants in this country. We need them. You aren’t really interested in having a conversation if you say otherwise. This country would fall apart if mass deportations and civil roundups were conducted as Trump says he will do. Talk about some Polish Ghetyo level shit happening there going door to door trying to identify who is legal and who isn’t and natural born anchor babies ( legal US citizens) versus their border crossing parents ( illegal), loss of tax revenue and consumers, loss of food production, meat packing, construction, garbage collection, manual labor, etc. Good lord. There is no way this happens without violence and rioting leading to massive upheaval in our countries day to day stability.
If you don’t want any handwaving and let’s have a discussion. It’s easy to stand there and complain. What do you propose? Paint me a picture of your ideal border protection. What does it look like? Who manages it? Who builds it. Who staffs it. How much of our contiguous borders do we fully secure versus partially secure? Do we fully secure our coastlines? Is it a thick 2000 mile long concrete megalith that can’t be drilled through, tunneled under, climbed over? Who pays for it and with what money? Who actually constructs it (lmao). Do we use federal or state Taxes? What taxes would you approve to do so? What about Canada? Do we have the same thing? Something less? Why? What about drug crossings at ports of entry ? 90% of all fentanyl comes through legal border crossings. Even with all the current top technology and infrastructure present at border crossings 90% of all fentanyl crossing the border still makes it through these fortifications. Let’s go. I’ll have this discussion if you want. I’ll even drill down on the economic impacts related to fully closing the borders and even environmental impacts lol. I’ll wait for your response to these questions.