You’re naive. This makes ND look bad, even less aggressive posters think so.
The things Notre Dame "fans" say make the school look bad versus national perception are very different.
The reality is they were never recruited by ND. According to the ISD and II guys they never had their academics in order for Notre Dame. This has nothing to do with them being stupid, their dad hating or leaving ND, or any other ridiculous conspiracy you guys come up with. It is as simple as they were not a fit for ND.
Not a bad thing, not a good thing, just reality. When you look at things through what actually happened, it doesn't make ND look bad. It makes you look pretty silly though.