Who'saWildManNow
Bald Prick
- Messages
- 3,863
- Reaction score
- 485
Awesome. Just awesome.
Awesome. Just awesome.
Hopefully that same battle will take place in practice next year.
Mark Harrel, Colin Mcgovern, John Montelus..
And Byrne, Mustipher...but the ones I listed are our best and it's not really that close, IMO.
The staff does like to play the best 5 lineman but as of right now there is no way Bars play guard. Montelus was brought in for a reason and highly thought of by the staff. And I love Nelson as well but these are Olinemen, experience means as much as talent so let's not forget that. Elmer is a better lineman than Hanratty, why isn't he playing RG?
I wasn't insinuating that Elmer should play guard. I was pointing out that just because a guy is good means they are going to put out there at a different position. Elmer is better than hanratty but Elmer is a T and Hanratty is a G. So, Elmer has to wait his turn. Just like Montelus is a G/C and Bars is a T, Bars may just have to wait his turn.
Do you guys realize that between the OLine depth and the addition of Byrant and Hood that we are basically following the blueprint of success on the offensive side?
FIFY
Some things while we're on the subject:
1) Alabama didn't invent terrific smash-mouth football.
2) Brian Kelly will not switch his offense to a pro-style or i-formation style. Notre Dame will remain in the spread.
3) Great OL can be great OL in the spread or not, it doesn't matter at all. Alabama doesn't do what they do because they dominate the trenches, that's a separate issue. They win because they are perfectly balanced. There are a million ways to run an offense, that's what they do and they do it verrrrry well. Brian Kelly runs a spread, and an OL advantage is arguably even more potent because of the fewer guys in the box. There is no superior style of football. Pro, spread, multiple, etc...it's just who is better at what they do.
Does everyone understand what Buster is saying here? Because this is and incredibly smart and insightful post. The only bad thing is if everybody understood this post it would cut half of the silly/fun conversations that are posted . . .
FIFY
Some things while we're on the subject:
1) Alabama didn't invent terrific smash-mouth football.
2) Brian Kelly will not switch his offense to a pro-style or i-formation style. Notre Dame will remain in the spread.
3) Great OL can be great OL in the spread or not, it doesn't matter at all. Alabama doesn't do what they do because they dominate the trenches, that's a separate issue. They win because they are perfectly balanced. There are a million ways to run an offense, that's what they do and they do it verrrrry well. Brian Kelly runs a spread, and an OL advantage is arguably even more potent because of the fewer guys in the box. There is no superior style of football. Pro, spread, multiple, etc...it's just who is better at what they do.
Alabama's success has less to do with X's and O's, or the system of offense or defense they run, and more to do with a.) talent and b.) how Saban and staff manifest that talent to succeed consistently (i.e. "The Process").
When I hear someone say we are following Alabama's blueprint, my mind goes to the two points above rather than think we are going to start running a pro-style offense. As you alluded to, Kelly's spread can have the same desired balance and potentially be even more productive.
As it pertains to talent and "The Process" and ND football...a.) ND is bringing in Alabama type talent, we just need to do it on a more consistent basis. b.) Brian Kelly is the only coach I have heard talk about "The Process" the same way Nick Saban does. I could be wrong on this, and please, someone, give me an example(s) of another coach that preaches "The Process" because I have been wondering lately, but Kelly is about the closest thing to Nick Saban as there is in college football today.
p.s. What does FIFY mean?
https://vine.co/v/bLdDJPEUFDZ
I couldn't get the embedding to work but the link is the one on one with Bars and Carter.
<iframe class="vine-embed" src="https://vine.co/v/bLdDJPEUFDZ/embed/simple" width="600" height="600" frameborder="0"></iframe><script async src="//platform.vine.co/static/scripts/embed.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Carter looked very frustrated. Be dominated must be something strange for him. Anyway his explosiveness off the snap is insane.
OL Alex Bars, Nashville (Tenn.) Montgomery Bell Academy: Bars is a huge kid with a great frame, and he looks like a pure right tackle. He has a nasty demeanor and is a terrific competitor. He had one of the best moments of the camp when he went against five-star Lorenzo Carter three straight times. On the first two reps, which Bars won, Carter ripped his jersey each time until it was practically torn off. Bars simply took it off, took the next rep shirtless and still bested one of the most athletic ends at the event. Bars struggled on Sunday, especially when he lost a few reps badly, but he has plenty of upside and the attitude you want in an offensive lineman.