SMU Postgame

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
46,229
Reaction score
22,484
Fair critique but all things considered, he played a helluva game. Led the team in tackles and looked good in pass coverage despite SMU picking on him after Talich went out. Best of all…kid is a freshman. I think he shows up big in the future
We want anyone that steps onto the field to be perfect, but the fact of the matter is when a player who hasn’t seen a lot of playing time gets on the field there’s going to be something of a settling in period for some. Agree, the kid is going to be good.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
46,229
Reaction score
22,484
What does it take for Notre Dame to force a holding call? And how is ND among the least penalized teams but they always get penalized more at home (ACC refs?). I'm really done with ACC officiating, I think they are very, very bad at their jobs.

We had guys being thrown down, multiple times, way after the whistle and we didn't see a single flag. ND was most often on the receiving end. We had guys held and it was egregious and never called.

Meanwhile, Traore gets a horsecollar call that I think was an abuse of the rule. I don't care if a guy has a hold of the back, we've seen them say it's not a horsecollar if you don't pull down from the back of the shoulder pads. Traore just tossed this poor SOB into his sideline and they extend the drive.
Kept saying the same thing during the game. Irish are bringing heat with extra guys consistently and no calls.
 

NDFAN2008

Well-known member
Messages
8,434
Reaction score
6,584
Great game some hiccups and stuff we need to clean up. Offense looked stale in the second half. Loved the throw to Larson up the middle
where has that been all year. Carr has some things he needs to clean up. Defense Gray is a liability and so is Shuler. I know we are deep but Talich was balling out.
 

IrishFanForever23

Well-known member
Messages
1,352
Reaction score
768
Is JOB out for the first half next week? I’ve listened to two different ND podcasts and both said he’s out for the first half against Syracuse, but I thought they changed the rule this year.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,975
Reaction score
37,474
I thought two things were true on the Sanders INT with regard to Shuler.

- Shuler does get beat. He tries to get physical with Pittman at top of route and almost gets like a swim move which discards him.

- The thing with the play though is if ND is going to play man with 5 man pressures, that is where you talk about marrying the rush with the coverage. Shuler has JOB single high safety support. So Jennings does look at Pittman to start, but knows he’s got a bad OL, MOFC look, it is unlikely he’s going to wait out the route to see if he’s open and then try to throw him across JOBs face as well. He should have thrown it to the slot running a zig route, Blackledge was correct there at least.
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
7,203
Reaction score
8,915
Carr has flirted with throwing some bad picks. If he would’ve thrown it deeper and to the outside, I think Gilbert has a huge play. Instead, he didn’t get enough on it and left it inside.
To be fair, he was getting (or almost getting) hit when he threw it.

No excuses though. He was late and should've just ate it.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,615
Reaction score
3,105
Except that Bama's SoS actually stinks and they have zero quality wins + multiple losses.
How dare you speak of Bama that way. Chattanooga is a powerhouse.

The irony is we’ll see a blatant contradiction Tuesday when Bama stays at 3 after playing a FCS team and their SOS looking worse and worse each week. But week 2 rankings showed Indiana dropping a ton after a bye week and their SOS looking worse.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,615
Reaction score
3,105
Happy to win and cover regardless how frustrating the offense looked in the 2H.

Awful for Talich. What a blow to the D.

Nitpicking: Clock management continues to be such a cluster. What the hell was that to end the first half? I, too, wish Carr hit just a couple more shots for scores. This game had the makings of a 42-3 game. Second half offense was meh.
 

hungryhippo

Active member
Messages
324
Reaction score
179
How dare you speak of Bama that way. Chattanooga is a powerhouse.

The irony is we’ll see a blatant contradiction Tuesday when Bama stays at 3 after playing a FCS team and their SOS looking worse and worse each week. But week 2 rankings showed Indiana dropping a ton after a bye week and their SOS looking worse.
Dropping Bama makes more sense if you consider manufacturing a way to have ND and Miami play each other ASAP, while putting them on the opposite side of the bracket from UGA (1) and giving neither ND (3) nor Miami (6) the 5/12 home game freebie.

But of course, that’d be some real tin foil hat thinking about this committee. They’re reasonable, serious people after all.
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
7,203
Reaction score
8,915
How dare you speak of Bama that way. Chattanooga is a powerhouse.

The irony is we’ll see a blatant contradiction Tuesday when Bama stays at 3 after playing a FCS team and their SOS looking worse and worse each week. But week 2 rankings showed Indiana dropping a ton after a bye week and their SOS looking worse.

This is why I'm expecting the committee to finally bow to the pressure and drop Bama.
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
7,203
Reaction score
8,915
Dropping Bama makes more sense if you consider manufacturing a way to have ND and Miami play each other ASAP, while putting them on the opposite side of the bracket from UGA (1) and giving neither ND (3) nor Miami (6) the 5/12 home game freebie.

But of course, that’d be some real tin foil hat thinking about this committee. They’re reasonable, serious people after all.

They've always avoided the rematches early in the past.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
3,166
Reaction score
6,643
I guess I look at the whole 'package'... Not to say that there could have been another 7-17 more points scored... But the Irish won by 21. Held SMU to a FG. Beat the spread.

Posts a month ago from some were, 'a win is a win is a win'...

But now a win is different per se?

On to Syracuse boys!!!
At this stage, a win is a win. This wasn't even a "bad" win, either. But we're just in survive and advance mode. 4-0 in the playoffs.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
38,551
Reaction score
32,789
Damn so he's out for (likely) all of next year too and it's going to kill his potential draft stock in the upcoming draft. Just fucking tragic when stuff like this happens on a basic play. Seen so many of these types of random ass injuries like Dre Greenlander, etc.
 

NDFAN2008

Well-known member
Messages
8,434
Reaction score
6,584
Damn so he's out for (likely) all of next year too and it's going to kill his potential draft stock in the upcoming draft. Just fucking tragic when stuff like this happens on a basic play. Seen so many of these types of random ass injuries like Dre Greenlander, etc.
What’s the timeline on an achilles recovery?
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,735
Reaction score
6,821
It used to be a full year, but now it's 6-9 months. Unfortunately, the player doesn't get back to what they were for almost two years.
Do we know yet if it’s a partial tear or a complete rupture? Is timeline the same nonetheless?
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,983
Reaction score
11,275
11 months or so. I’d be shocked if we saw him next year
Recovery has gotten a little faster. It's certainly possible he gets back on the field next season. But if he is he'd still probably need some time to get back into full playing shape.
 

Jimmy3Putt

KooL
Messages
7,203
Reaction score
8,915
Do we know yet if it’s a partial tear or a complete rupture? Is timeline the same nonetheless?

I believe the new procedure is to implant a "speed bridge" into the heel regardless of the length of the tear.

Rodgers was back practicing with the Jets less than three months after his injury, but never played because they were eliminated.
 

GTB

Active member
Messages
223
Reaction score
172
With a few notorious exceptions, such injuries take two full years for a 100% recovery
and some never fully recover; not many anymore but it has happened.
 
Top