2025 College Football Playoffs

jprue24

Well-known member
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
3,245
Big 12 is a ponzi scheme - have no one to compare them to bc all of their OOC schedules suck, so they get the benefit of the doubt that they are actually good. They should be punished for their shit scheduling accordingly because it’s all planned by Yormack to pump out high win loss records.

IU also played 2 FCS schools and ODU. Embarrassing. Should be behind A&M for that alone.
This info is more than a month old, but the Big 12 has beat up the ACC

Big 1210-6Opponent
DateBig 1210-6OpponentBig 12Opponent
2025-09-26Houston27-24Oregon StatePac 12awaymiddle
2025-09-20TCU35-24SMUACChomemiddletop
2025-09-20UCF34-9North CarolinaACChomebottombottom
2025-09-13Texas Tech45-14Oregon StatePac 12hometop
2025-09-13West Virginia31-24PittsburghACChomebottomtop
2025-09-06Baylor48-45SMUACCawaybottomtop
2025-09-06Iowa State16-13IowaBig Tenhomemiddlemiddle
2025-09-06Kansas31-42MissouriSECawaybottommiddle
2025-09-06Oklahoma State3-69OregonBig Tenawaybottomtop
2025-09-06Arizona State20-24Mississippi StateSECawaytopbottom
2025-09-06BYU27-3StanfordACChometopmiddle
2025-09-01TCU48-14North CarolinaACCawaymiddlebottom
2025-08-30Utah43-10UCLABig Tenawaytopbottom
2025-08-29Baylor24-38AuburnSEChomebottombottom
2025-08-29Colorado20-27Georgia TechACChomebottomtop
2025-08-28Cincinnati17-20NebraskaBig Tenhomemiddlemiddle

 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,305
Reaction score
4,849
Big 12 is a ponzi scheme - have no one to compare them to bc all of their OOC schedules suck, so they get the benefit of the doubt that they are actually good. They should be punished for their shit scheduling accordingly because it’s all planned by Yormack to pump out high win loss records.

IU also played 2 FCS schools and ODU. Embarrassing. Should be behind A&M for that alone.
This is where Texas fans who are (unjustly) lamenting their CFP odds should be directing their ire, not at us. The Mid12 all collective schedule ass OOC like you said and it is purposely to drive up the number of "bowl eligible teams" they have. BYU fans have been flexing this for weeks now. But if you really take a look at what it takes to get to say 8 wins in the Mid12 it's really not that impressive. Beat 1-2 FCS schools, then a shitty G5 school, then beat some combination of Kansas, Colorado, Okie State, Baylor, etc. and maybe one or two of the "good teams" like Houston, UCF, and Iowa State and before you know it you're at 8 or 9 wins. A perfect "tough conference win" for TT or BYU.

I'm willing to extend the benefit of the doubt to TT because they've been demolishing teams and pass the "eye test" to some degree. BYU though, second straight year of fraudulent football from them. They're obviously good because they handle their schedules but they've had 2024 Kansas City Chiefs levels of luck two years in a row. Several of their games last year came down to the wire and required a lot of luck to win and they've had the same rabbit's foot shoved up their ass this year too. They're just a bad team and I only hope they get in if we get them, other than that I hope they're out.
 

jprue24

Well-known member
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
3,245
So many bad teams are going to get in, but it may spread talent out even more

'With no decision in sight, the 10 FBS commissioners and Notre Dame athletic director Pete Bevacqua now have more time to see if Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti and SEC commissioner Greg Sankey can reach an agreement on the future format.

If not -- and they have been at a stalemate for months -- they have both said publicly the current 12-team format can remain in place for another season.

Under the new six-year agreement, which begins in 2026, the Big Ten and SEC have the bulk of control over the future format -- something the other commissioners and Notre Dame agreed to during those negotiations. Earlier this month, the Power 4 commissioners met in Charlotte, North Carolina, where Petitti explained the reasoning behind the Big Ten's push for a 24-team format that would include automatic qualifiers.

One possible model
that has been considered is four guaranteed spots for each of the Power 4 conferences, two for what will become the Group of 6 when the new-look Pac-12 begins, and six at-large bids for the selection committee to determine.'

 

notredamermotherpray4us

Active member
Messages
123
Reaction score
188
Yes I think that is one of the only ways we can be left out at this point. Especially if it is a close game, it would be very similar to SMU last year where they didn't kick them out altogether, just gave them the last at-large spot.
Are you really comparing this ND team to SMU. Can't believe these conversations are still going on. ND on a 10 game winning streak gets in over the 10-2 loser of the big 12 CCG. Either team will have lost twice in the last 5 weeks (byu)-7 weeks (ttu). Also the nightmare scenarios I've seen have Alabama winning the SEC but one of O$U or IU will also have a loss. That would give us the 2nd longest winning streak in the country. Not getting left out of the field of 12 because of that alone.
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
15,114
Reaction score
12,949
What’s more soulless than the pre season polling and the self fulfilling prophecies of the same teams being ranked with out playing games and then all the worthless and meaningless weekly rankings and polls only to have a corporatized committee be the final gatekeepers.lol. I’ll take the play the games and see who wins.
It seems like you just don't like CFB lol. All of the debate and theorizing is half the fun. Besides there are too many teams to operate in a straight up W/L record style format. Even just by conference at this point.
 

GATTACA!

It's about to get gross
Messages
15,114
Reaction score
12,949
Here's a fun tool someone on reddit made to play around with different results.

 

Te'o4Heisman

Well-known member
Messages
2,510
Reaction score
2,616
This is why I like the 4 bye set up - those teams are typically top tier that will curb stomp the bottom 4 teams. Give the bottom four a chance to win one and keep the next four honest (5-8) and opportunity to celebrate a great season with a home playoff win.

16 is too many - keep it competitive and reward success.
Last year all the bye teams were reqarded with a first round loss. Maybe an anomaly, maybe not.
 

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2026!
Messages
31,523
Reaction score
17,410
Big 12 is a ponzi scheme - have no one to compare them to bc all of their OOC schedules suck, so they get the benefit of the doubt that they are actually good. They should be punished for their shit scheduling accordingly because it’s all planned by Yormack to pump out high win loss records.

IU also played 2 FCS schools and ODU. Embarrassing. Should be behind A&M for that alone.

Kennesaw State is technically FBS now, but they've also only been a member for like 3 years...and they've only been playing football as a program for 10, so they might as well be FCS still. Really, ODU, Kennesaw, and Indiana St is like playing 3 FCS in a row really. You're not wrong, IU should be behind A&M. Cig knew what he was doing when he jumped to Indiana.
 

Notre Dame Joe

Active member
Messages
300
Reaction score
180
What is interesting to me is Bama's prospects. They are currently -200 to make the playoff on DK. Obviously they have to win this week. However, what happens if they lose to TAMU/Georgia in the SECCG and then fall to 3 losses? They would be up against BYU/TTU and dare I say Miami.
I don't think Bama can play A&M. UGA has tiebreaks against both.
 

Notre Dame Joe

Active member
Messages
300
Reaction score
180
The nightmare is UM beating anOSU because then all 4 BUG teams have to go to the CFP. Only way out would be upsets by Washington or Purdue.
 

IrishLax

Something Witty
Staff member
Messages
37,545
Reaction score
28,995
So many bad teams are going to get in, but it may spread talent out even more

'With no decision in sight, the 10 FBS commissioners and Notre Dame athletic director Pete Bevacqua now have more time to see if Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti and SEC commissioner Greg Sankey can reach an agreement on the future format.

If not -- and they have been at a stalemate for months -- they have both said publicly the current 12-team format can remain in place for another season.

Under the new six-year agreement, which begins in 2026, the Big Ten and SEC have the bulk of control over the future format -- something the other commissioners and Notre Dame agreed to during those negotiations. Earlier this month, the Power 4 commissioners met in Charlotte, North Carolina, where Petitti explained the reasoning behind the Big Ten's push for a 24-team format that would include automatic qualifiers.

One possible model
that has been considered is four guaranteed spots for each of the Power 4 conferences, two for what will become the Group of 6 when the new-look Pac-12 begins, and six at-large bids for the selection committee to determine.'

Like in what universe is anyone asking for 4 automatic qualifiers from the ACC and Big 12 lmao
 

pumpdog20

Well-known member
Messages
4,743
Reaction score
3,155
I'm starting to think of a possibility that TT could throw the Big 12 championship game.
1) they may have comfortable that they are in regardless
2) working with the big 12 to get two teams in
 

CTIDANDREW

Well-known member
Messages
1,134
Reaction score
620
I'm starting to think of a possibility that TT could throw the Big 12 championship game.
1) they may have comfortable that they are in regardless
2) working with the big 12 to get two teams in
Why would they throw a game versus an inferior opponent like BYU, to greatly decrease thier chances of winning a national title by taking themselves out of the running for a bye?

That doesn't make any sense.
They don't need anymore money, they have a Billionaire Oil tycoon financing everything with no end in sight.

Also, they have never won the Big 12 title.
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,047
Reaction score
6,121
The nightmare is UM beating anOSU because then all 4 BUG teams have to go to the CFP. Only way out would be upsets by Washington or Purdue.
The nightmare is UM beating OSU period b/c not only would the skunkbears likely get into CFP, Day could quit or get fired & they go after MF. I realize they just one the natty last season & have the best roster in the sport but losing to their hated rival three times in a row has to be inexcusable for that rabid fanbase.
 

OrlaNDomer

Well-known member
Messages
580
Reaction score
362
TTU would truly have to throw the game to lose to BYU. I don't see that happening.

Gotta be rooting against the "O" schools this week: Oklahoma, Oregon, Ole Miss.
 

bcole2

Well-known member
Messages
223
Reaction score
305
I don't think Bama can play A&M. UGA has tiebreaks against both.
No, Bama will be in the conference championship if they beat Auburn. They beat Georgia head to head and would win the tiebreaker if them and Ole Miss are all tied as well. A&M would be undefeated so would go to the championship if they beat Texas.
 

bcole2

Well-known member
Messages
223
Reaction score
305
Are you really comparing this ND team to SMU. Can't believe these conversations are still going on. ND on a 10 game winning streak gets in over the 10-2 loser of the big 12 CCG. Either team will have lost twice in the last 5 weeks (byu)-7 weeks (ttu). Also the nightmare scenarios I've seen have Alabama winning the SEC but one of O$U or IU will also have a loss. That would give us the 2nd longest winning streak in the country. Not getting left out of the field of 12 because of that alone.
No I was comparing TTU to SMU. I agree that their loss to ASU should come up big in the committee room should they lose the B12CG. But the resumes will be very similar. I think ND wins out because of the 10 game win streak, eye test, brand, and ability to make a run to a championship.
 

pumpdog20

Well-known member
Messages
4,743
Reaction score
3,155
Why would they throw a game versus an inferior opponent like BYU, to greatly decrease thier chances of winning a national title by taking themselves out of the running for a bye?

That doesn't make any sense.
They don't need anymore money, they have a Billionaire Oil tycoon financing everything with no end in sight.

Also, they have never won the Big 12 title.
I gave you two reasons and you still needed more apparently.

Never had won a big 12 title is a great point I'll concede to.
Byes don't greatly decrease your chances of winning a national title, but you should know this already.
 

dankgesang

Troll Tide
Messages
449
Reaction score
683
No, Bama will be in the conference championship if they beat Auburn. They beat Georgia head to head and would win the tiebreaker if them and Ole Miss are all tied as well. A&M would be undefeated so would go to the championship if they beat Texas.
It's convoluted as hell (but yeah as you mention if Aggie and Alabama win this week they'll play each other.)

 
Top