Me2SouthBend
Well-known member
- Messages
- 2,636
- Reaction score
- 3,199
Joe? Thought for sure he’d be out of eligibility.
Joe? Thought for sure he’d be out of eligibility.
Not good. He needs to put on 25-ish pounds just to be in the rotation, IMO.
They got heights and weights updated on the roster page. A couple of guys appear down on weight, so it could be a kind of cutting portion of the offseason program, but loghan Thomas is at 207lb.
His inability to put on weight has been a mystery. I thought he'd be a factor in the rotation when he did. Reminder that is never a given.They got heights and weights updated on the roster page. A couple of guys appear down on weight, so it could be a kind of cutting portion of the offseason program, but loghan Thomas is at 207lbs.
It'll be interesting if Dunham surges to the top backup role at some point in the season. Or Hulak?IMO Traore’s backup is Keeley then the linebackers (Sneed, Faraimo and KVA) then Dunham
That's got to be a misprint, if he is indeed 207lbs after a couple years strength training, something could be going on medically, he was about 220 a couple months ago.They got heights and weights updated on the roster page. A couple of guys appear down on weight, so it could be a kind of cutting portion of the offseason program, but loghan Thomas is at 207lbs.
Looking at that roster breakdown even though it's missing a couple of guys who haven't reported yet (Premer, Jarrard, Nichols) how would you grade each position group?
Could be injury related for sure. Carries a lot of mass in his lower half, which would be hard to keep on while rehabbing an ACL.Kedren Young at 226; he had been listed 240+ prior right? Could be injury related.
Looking at that roster breakdown even though it's missing a couple of guys who haven't reported yet (Premer, Jarrard, Nichols) how would you grade each position group?
Trimming down after that type of injury is to be expected but should help with his speed as well.Could be injury related for sure. Carries a lot of mass in his lower half, which would be hard to keep on while rehabbing an ACL.
Could also be cutting down into better playing shape as well. Wouldn't mind seeing him at a completely rocked up 225-230lbs. Especially if it helps him add half a step.
Pretty damn close to mineIt’s the spring roster. Why McKinney is missing as well.
QB: A-
RB: B
WR: B+
TE: B
OL: B+
DE: B
DT: B+
LB: A-
CB: A
S: A+
Schmidt is listed as a kicker on the latest roster. That depth chart thing might have been an error.
McKinney isn’t listed because he hasn’t enrolled yet, has to complete some on line courses to get his degree from his previous school. He is in South Bend doing work outs
Pass the bong Cheech...I haven’t argued for Rudolph’s firing before because he’s dealt with numerous injuries and has, understandably, had to move guys around. However, Will Black practicing at Guard is coaching malpractice. He’s a tackle. Guerby’s natural position is at tackle and should be kicked outside. Jagusah has proven that he can be an incredibly effective tackle and even an all American guard but I hear people’s concerns about his injury history. Point is that Knapp has consistently struggled in big games, particularly in pass pro. When you have the talent of Guerby, Black, and Jagusah you should not be continuing to put Knapp on an island at tackle. His strength is run blocking and should be put inside and let one of the more natural tackles play there
Yeah, there are other strange changes as well. Ausberry has been listed at 6'0, then 6'2 and now back to 6'0.Going through the updated roster, there are a couple things that are either mistakes or need some explanation.
Jagusah lost two inches and gained an extra year of eligibility because he is listed as a sophomore.
Peter Jones also gained an extra year, being listed as a freshman. Maybe they both got medical redshirts approved already?
But then there also guys who seem to be wrong in the other direction.
Quincy Porter is listed as a sophomore even though he only played 4 games last year. (Edit: According to Jack Soble's recent article, Ohio State messed up and he actually played in 5 games, so he is a true sophomore.)
And Jayden Sanders is listed as a junior even though he has only been in college one year!
Plus, the walk ons are all messed up. Whitman, Garrity, Anderson, Wollan, Kros, Powlus do not have their redshirts credited, but Jeffery, Southall, Vinci do.
CB: A+. Maybe the best position group in the country.Looking at that roster breakdown even though it's missing a couple of guys who haven't reported yet (Premer, Jarrard, Nichols) how would you grade each position group?
Ya'll are some tough graders but I guess grades are subjective. I don't know how CB could be anything besides an A+? It has talent, returning AA and near-consensus best CB in the country, 3 year starter is Gray, we added 3 incredible CBs in the freshman class, we poached a true freshman from Michigan who logged over 200 snaps and we have ascending sophomores who played last year and got some experience. We also had a player who has logged over 2000 snaps from Colorado.
If anyone can find a team that has better top end talent and depth, I'd be very happy to see it.
What players did at other schools doesn't always translate for one (Madden, Stroman, Smith) and we know that better than most. Secondly we don't have a surefire nickel so it's an A instead of an A+. One player being an A+ doesn't make an entire room an A+(hence the QB grade), you have to have the depth and talent is great but GOOD experience is more valuable.Ya'll are some tough graders but I guess grades are subjective. I don't know how CB could be anything besides an A+? It has talent, returning AA and near-consensus best CB in the country, 3 year starter is Gray, we added 3 incredible CBs in the freshman class, we poached a true freshman from Michigan who logged over 200 snaps and we have ascending sophomores who played last year and got some experience. We also had a player who has logged over 2000 snaps from Colorado.
If anyone can find a team that has better top end talent and depth, I'd be very happy to see it.
PreciselyWho is starting at Nickel?
That’s why I did not give it an A+. If spring camp happens and everyone says McKinney looks great at Nickel or Gray moved to Nickel and looks like a fit I would give it an A+. But I can’t no matter how good Moore is say it’s an A+ unit when 1/3 starters is uncertain.
Cannot get here quick enough. I'd be happy with any reports at this time of year. Love the motto this year "Leave no doubt." Go Irish!“Notre Dame is expected to open spring camp on March 20 and is tentatively set to host its annual NFL Pro Day workout on March 24. The Fighting Irish will conclude spring camp April 25 with the annual Blue & Gold Game inside Notre Dame Stadium.”
Per Brice