2025 College Football Playoffs

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,044
Reaction score
6,109
We need the committee to have conviction, basically. The easy move is to put Miami, or whoever else, in. Cave and get celebrated. That team gets bounced early because they are not championship caliber, and that’s that.

But if they put in ND, this team can very much make another run (as ND proved a year ago). ND makes a run, and nobody can ever say shit about letting us in again. The committee is then vindicated for being right.

At the end of the day, it does not make sense to award a team with a spot that has absolutely 0 chance (BYU, Miami, OU) over a team that has a very realistic chance like ND.
Cave and they also set a bad precedent IMO. The perception will be that they can be influenced by media members & conferences who lobby, politic & whine about their team being left out.
 

1776

Active member
Messages
65
Reaction score
145
Cave and they also set a bad precedent IMO. The perception will be that they can be influenced by media members & conferences who lobby, politic & whine about their team being left out.

You’re right, but you’d by naive to think it doesn’t affect decision makers. It’s easy to have conviction about something until you start getting destroyed for it daily, and it reaches a crescendo and you have to make the choice once and for all.

I work for a major sports league. I’ve been around big decisions like this. It 100% has an impact… no matter what is said publicly
 

thekid33

President of the Kevin McDougal Fan Club
Messages
2,463
Reaction score
4,140
Yesterday morning I woke up as calm as I have been since Tuesday night and felt confident that we were going to end up in.

Last night I dreamt that we were down 3 at halftime in the title game to OSU in a driving rainstorm.

Should be an omen that we are in, right?

Yet, all of my optimism from yesterday is gone and I am filled with the heavy weight of existential dread.
 

BleedingGold

Yelp Reviewer
Messages
589
Reaction score
606
Let me ask a question. If Georgia absolutely destroys Bama, Tech once again destroys BYU, and Duke wins, is the committee forced to take Bama out?
 

Rudy89

Well-known member
Messages
2,520
Reaction score
669
Man to be honest, the last month has taken what should be an incredible season and made it totally miserable. I try to keep the perspective that 10 straight wins with an average margin of victory around 30ppg and an incredible Heisman worthy season from a generational player like Love make the season worth it, but this shit has been a grind. Honestly, if BYU pulls the rabbit out of the hat tomorrow I will be disappointed but then breathe a sigh of relief knowing that it's over and at least Miami isn't getting in either.
I’ve made peace with both. Even tho whatever bowl we go to is prettt meaningless in the grand scheme of things if we don’t go to the playoffs I still hope we win. I went from kindergarten to my freshman year of college without seeing a bowl win so I will never NOT be excited about winning bowl games regardless of how useless they may seem to be in this day and age.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,303
Reaction score
4,844
Nah, Miami can GTFO.

Bama jumping ND was more of an indictment on Miami's chance of reaching the CFP. They didnt want to figure out what to do with Miami, BYU, Bama if BYU and Bama both lose. Or Miami and Bama if Bama loses and BYU wins.

Ok, if you say so. I know Miami is the traditional enemy, but I see the SEC as a much bigger problem. They act like is is unthinkable for the SEC to have less than 5 teams and I'm sure a lot of people think Texas and Vandy are deserving as well. I'd much rather see the SEC get screwed.
I agree with Mac on the one hand, fuck Miami. On the other hand, the SEC is a bigger threat to the sport and is the main problem. I also just happen to think Miami is a better team than Alabama.

I agree the most with InKellyWeTrust though, the swap of Bama and ND was to protect Bama and barring a BYU win it also still keeps us in which I happen to think the committee wants to do. Now, if BYU and Bama lose and somehow we still end up out, well I mean it's a piece of shit political committee and nothing surprises me, but I happen to believe from everything they've said the last 5 weeks that they really like us and view us as one of the best teams in the country.
 

Huntr

24 Karat Shamrock
Messages
7,500
Reaction score
10,423
ESPN Bet kicking the hornet's nest.

Those mofos have made BANK off ND's ass the past few weeks.

Even fuckin F tier announce team Mark Jones and Roddy Jones were shitting on ND in the CFP over Miami during last night's Tulane game

1765034642825.png
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,303
Reaction score
4,844
ESPN Bet kicking the hornet's nest.

Those mofos have made BANK off ND's ass the past few weeks.

Even fuckin F tier announce team Mark Jones and Roddy Jones were shitting on ND in the CFP over Miami during last night's Tulane game

View attachment 3061513
This has been what's been draining. ND cannot be discussed anywhere on any channel, without some failed former coach or washed up former player sitting there just repeating "head to head" ad nauseum over and over again. The Fox Pregame show before the Boise-UNLV game last night had their closing segment on how Miami should be in over ND, even though BOTH of the assclowns there said ND is one the best teams in the country and could win a national title, but Miami "deserved" to go.

I've never watched sports media for glowing reviews of ND but damn I just want to see my team discussed for something other than being shit on and told they don't deserve a playoff spot.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
Regardless of a bad or good (by only 3-7 points) loss by Bama, a 3 loss Bama team should be left out.

If not a 2 loss BYU team than who? ND- 100% yes, Miami??
Yeah, Miami. Annoying as they have been over the last few weeks, I think Miami is a lot better and more talented than BYU. And unlike BYU their resume would include a win over a playoff team.
I don't know what would be the argument for a 10-2 BYU team that lost twice to the only playoff-caliber team it played, over Miami.
 

notredamermotherpray4us

Active member
Messages
123
Reaction score
188
Really hoping Navy is in the top 25 tomorrow. Since they absolutely deserve to be there. No disrespect to Navy but then I hope they lose to Army. If those 2 things happen it helps our resume but it also in a roundabout way fucks Miami over a little more.
 

Irishdawg

Well-known member
Messages
1,397
Reaction score
1,080
As the conversation just went on gameday, a BYU win leaves one spot for three teams. ND,Bama & Miami. I don’t like those odds. So, we’ll know early today if we have a shot.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,303
Reaction score
4,844
I don't think Navy has any effect on ND's resume at this point.
One of the few things Yurachek said this morning, which echoed what he said Tuesday, is that things that can affect an idle team's ranking is SOS and SOR, common opponents, etc. Boise winning gives us a boost over Miami and while he didn't mention beating ranked teams, it stands to reason if the committee ranks one of our opponents that can't hurt us.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,303
Reaction score
4,844
That Boise win certainly didn’t hurt.

Miami didn’t play either of Virginia or Duke correct? Does it matter who wins that game (from a ND perspective)?
If you want to totally hedge against any conference politics, it's probably cleaner if UVA wins. That locks in the ACC with a spot and the committee wouldn't feel potentially compelled to bump Miami up over us to give the ACC team. I personally don't think the committee gives a shit about the ACC, but that said, it doesn't matter to me who wins that glorified G5 conference so I suppose I'm pulling for UVA.
 

Bane

Well-known member
Messages
2,303
Reaction score
4,844
Also, what is it with the mythologizing of that ND-Miami game? Yes, Miami won and they looked better in the trenches, but Saban is gonna sit up there and say they kicked our ass, they won by 3. If you didn't watch the game and didn't know the result and only watched Miami fans and Nick Saban talk about it you would think it went like that 2017 disaster. They had to kick a go ahead field goal with a little over a minute left. We had the ball with a chance to tie or win the game with a first time starter.
 

irishfan

Irish Hoops Mod
Messages
7,205
Reaction score
607
I don't think Navy has any effect on ND's resume at this point.
It really shouldn’t but I’ve always thought the committee historically likes to sneak a team into the Top 25 if it will help them justify a playoff team’s ranking. I could absolutely see Navy at #25 tomorrow and the chair talking about how we played 10 P4 programs, a ranked Navy, and the MWC champ as justification for why we are ahead of BYU, Miami, and potentially Bama if they lose.
 

TracyGraham

Well-known member
Messages
511
Reaction score
556
Nah, Miami can GTFO.


This is where I was coming from. No matter what Miami may have said or done, after seeing this, I hope the SEC gets completely effed. I know the chances are slim but just saying in a perfect world Miami gets in and Bama gets shut out again....
BTW, I could be completely missing context here but seems pretty straight forward.
 
Last edited:

Kingbish01

Well-known member
Messages
3,414
Reaction score
2,375


This is where I was coming from. No matter what Miami may have said or done, after seeing this, I hope the SEC gets completely effed. I know the chances are slim but just saying in a perfect world Miami gets in and Bama gets shut out again....
BTW, I could be completely missing context here....

I was going to ask what the context is. I don't click on anything of his I can't stand him, but I did a few seconds ago to see what this video is has it keeps floating around and I really don't know what he's talking about.
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,386
Reaction score
10,247
I was going to ask what the context is. I don't click on anything of his I can't stand him, but I did a few seconds ago to see what this video is has it keeps floating around and I really don't know what he's talking about.
Even watching it, I'm not really clear what he's talking about (or when he was saying this. He kept talking about what the SEC did on this particular night. I assume it wasn't Bama narrowly beating Auburn.).

But honestly, having Ole Miss lined up to host despite losing their coach, and a deeply-unimpressive Oklahoma team as a stone cold lock, and anyone even humoring Texas as a playoff team, the SEC is already getting special treatment here.

I think the special treatment at this point would be going specifically to Bama, protecting the SEC's king shit program from being the first team out for the second year in a row. If it were any other SEC team sitting in that spot right now, I'd feel a lot more confident the committee would make the right decision in the end.
 
Top