One of the most talented pocket passers I have seen in a while (personally think better than rosen) I just dont think that is the perfect fit for our offense. I want Henry or Pass.
Us taking Eason would be sort of like Alabama taking Barnett. Can work but is not the best fit for either party.
I would challenge this notion. I'm really excited by the idea of dual threat QBs but the problem is often the level of commitment to the pass. If Everett was more committed to going through progressions, we'd put up 40-50+ every game. We have the weapons, we have the line but we don't have consistency (yet) at QB.
Kelly's offense is not geared to a dual-threat QB, it's more power spread. As long as we are able to control the line and rush for 4+ yards per play and we have a QB who can take advantage of play action, and who can throw the long ball as well as the short ball, then Kelly's offense works.
Kelly hardly ever calls a play predicated on the success of a QB run/scramble. Maybe 2-3 a game, the rest of the time it's improvisation when the pocket collapses. Yes, I think it's great to have a QB who can make those plays 2-3, maybe even 4 times a game but what about the times when the pocket was simply suppressed a touch and instead of going through progressions, the QB breaks from the pocket to scramble and either throws it away or takes a sack?
There is no magic bullet, when you gain in one area, you lose in another. Personally, I think Kelly's perfect offense involves a pocket QB with enough athleticism to scramble as a last ditch effort or to run the read option, on occasion but we don't need a hyper-athletic QB.
When a QB takes a snap and in the back of his mind, he's waiting for his chance to jailbreak, their is no commitment to the pass and full progression. He's paying more attention to the front 4-5 than the routes unfolding before him.
I admit, the perfect QB is a Vick/Manning hybrid. One with ultra athletic ability to scramble when needed and able to commit to the passing game with precision and strength of arm. But we haven't seen a single person yet who is capable of doing that. We see hybrid players with some success but we see plenty of pocket QBs who have that level of success as well.
Kelly is a match-up person, we have the receivers, TEs and RBs to play the match-up game on every possession. If a QB is able to recognize the mismatch, I like our chances whether he can scramble or not.