Question about this website

S

solo

Guest
What is "feedback"?

I had a guy last night post that the site wouldn't let him give me any more negative feedback. Are we supposed to be sitting here rating each other as posters? I simply interpreted his post as him not liking what I had to say. But I would like to understand a little better.
 

Junkhead

Community Mod
Messages
7,595
Reaction score
1,354
What is "feedback"?

I had a guy last night post that the site wouldn't let him give me any more negative feedback. Are we supposed to be sitting here rating each other as posters? I simply interpreted his post as him not liking what I had to say. But I would like to understand a little better.


I got a few negative feedbacks last night without flaming anyone. There are a few angry misguided people around. I try to save feedback for especially good posts or at least something that amuses me.
 

BigIrish

New member
Messages
771
Reaction score
48
i would assume that he was talking about the reputation feature - the star icon below your name. you can give positive or negative reputation to all posters, but you can't focus too much good or bad rep on any single poster without spreading it around first.

you can see in your user cp the good and bad rep points that you've been given. you can also see who's given it to you, so if you're concerned about that sort of thing, posters should take heed and do unto others as they'd like done unto them.
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
I got a bad feedback for asking when a recruit was going to choose.
 
S

solo

Guest
i would assume that he was talking about the reputation feature - the star icon below your name. you can give positive or negative reputation to all posters, but you can't focus too much good or bad rep on any single poster without spreading it around first.

you can see in your user cp the good and bad rep points that you've been given. you can also see who's given it to you, so if you're concerned about that sort of thing, posters should take heed and do unto others as they'd like done unto them.

Well...I have 496 points. Not sure what that means. However, I don't expect to be popular in these forums. I try to be objective. I am generally pseeimsitic, not optimistic about ND football. I call 'em like I see 'em even if the stance is unpopular.

So I would imagine that many people might not like this style.

What does 496 reputation points mean?
 

BigIrish

New member
Messages
771
Reaction score
48
some posters dole out reputation like it's candy. others don't. if you're concerned about the reputation points you receive, your best bet is to give reputation only when it's deserved, only post when you have something meaningful to say (adding to the chorus of 'i really hope we land such and such recruit' posts won't get you rep points), and avoid making petty/personal attacks on other posters.

the total reputation points that you have are determined based on the amount of positive and negative rep that you've received. the more reputation points you have, the greater the positive and negative reputation points you can give to others.

personally, i rarely give negative reputation, and i try to give positive reputation whenever it's deserved. IMO, negative reputation shouldn't be given for simple disagreements, or errors made by new posters.
 
Last edited:

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
some posters dole out reputation like it's candy. others don't. if you're concerned about the reputation points you receive, your best bet is to give reputation only when it's deserved, only post when you have something meaningful to say (adding to the chorus of 'i really hope we land such and such recruit' posts won't get you rep points), and avoid making petty/personal attacks on other posters.


well isn't a message board for you to express you think.how can you give bad rep pionts to someone that is expressing thier opinion. Do they do it because they don't agree with that person's opinion?
 

Vince Young

New member
Messages
1,296
Reaction score
64
I tend to save negative reps for people who stoop to over-the-top and pointless personal insults. And with the crowd we USED to have around here, that meant I was rarely handing out negs. More recently, I've been handing them out a bit more. Lotta newbies coming in here lately who think they can win name-calling contests with well-respected members who've been here for well over 2 years. Those clowns get negs from me, and their angry e-mails calling me a "fucktard" in response will go straight to my trash can with no reply.

Even had one guy try to retaliate by handing a neg right back to me. Just a quick note: the way the system on here works is that if you have a high reputation, it has more of an impact when you rep someone else. The opposite is also true: low rep = low impact. So, metaphorically speaking, I blasted him with a bazooka, and he fired back with a pea-shooter. Sound strategy, dude. If you really want to play that way, I'll trade negative reps with you all day, and we'll see who's left standing at sundown. Putz.

I try to give positive reps to any post that makes me nod in agreement, laugh out loud, or that I disagree with but that really gets me thinking. I used to hand those out a lot more. Lately? Not so much...

In the end it really doesn't matter. I like the fact that I happen to have a high rep, but I really don't feel any different than back when I only had one green square. But some people care about it a LOT, so there ya go.
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
I tend to save negative reps for people who stoop to over-the-top and pointless personal insults. And with the crowd we USED to have around here, that meant I was rarely handing out negs. More recently, I've been handing them out a bit more. Lotta newbies coming in here lately who think they can win name-calling contests with well-respected members who've been here for well over 2 years. Those clowns get negs from me, and their angry e-mails calling me a "fucktard" in response will go straight to my trash can with no reply.

Even had one guy try to retaliate by handing a neg right back to me. Just a quick note: the way the system on here works is that if you have a high reputation, it has more of an impact when you rep someone else. The opposite is also true: low rep = low impact. So, metaphorically speaking, I blasted him with a bazooka, and he fired back with a pea-shooter. Sound strategy, dude. If you really want to play that way, I'll trade negative reps with you all day, and we'll see who's left standing at sundown. Putz.

I try to give positive reps to any post that makes me nod in agreement, laugh out loud, or that I disagree with but that really gets me thinking. I used to hand those out a lot more. Lately? Not so much...

In the end it really doesn't matter. I like the fact that I happen to have a high rep, but I really don't feel any different than back when I only had one green square. But some people care about it a LOT, so there ya go.



I agree with your system but some of these people on here take it to the extreme. I really don't care about the rep thing I was just asking some questions. I seen where one person turn his rep off. I really don't know how all this reps and other stuff work. I gave a few rep pionts on some good posts but didn't really know how it worked. thanks
 
S

solo

Guest
I tend to save negative reps for people who stoop to over-the-top and pointless personal insults. And with the crowd we USED to have around here, that meant I was rarely handing out negs. More recently, I've been handing them out a bit more. Lotta newbies coming in here lately who think they can win name-calling contests with well-respected members who've been here for well over 2 years. Those clowns get negs from me, and their angry e-mails calling me a "fucktard" in response will go straight to my trash can with no reply.

Even had one guy try to retaliate by handing a neg right back to me. Just a quick note: the way the system on here works is that if you have a high reputation, it has more of an impact when you rep someone else. The opposite is also true: low rep = low impact. So, metaphorically speaking, I blasted him with a bazooka, and he fired back with a pea-shooter. Sound strategy, dude. If you really want to play that way, I'll trade negative reps with you all day, and we'll see who's left standing at sundown. Putz.

I try to give positive reps to any post that makes me nod in agreement, laugh out loud, or that I disagree with but that really gets me thinking. I used to hand those out a lot more. Lately? Not so much...

In the end it really doesn't matter. I like the fact that I happen to have a high rep, but I really don't feel any different than back when I only had one green square. But some people care about it a LOT, so there ya go.

You know, I'm not here to be popular. I'm just here to discuss ND football.

I have my opinions and often state them strongly. But I don't personally attack or insult anyone. I like good debates. If someone disagrees with me, I kind of like it. I enjoy debating them and seeing if I can sway their opinion or if they can alter my perceptions.

What I don't enjoy is when people take it personally and spew insults.

The biggest thing I think I need tolean is how to statement my opinions in a way that doesn't sound like a "know it all". I often state my opinions strongly. I think others view this as me thinking I am always right, which I know is not the case.
 
G

goldenechoes

Guest
What is "feedback"?

I had a guy last night post that the site wouldn't let him give me any more negative feedback. Are we supposed to be sitting here rating each other as posters? I simply interpreted his post as him not liking what I had to say. But I would like to understand a little better.

I was just kidding. I should have used my sarcastic font.
 

Vince Young

New member
Messages
1,296
Reaction score
64
You know, I'm not here to be popular. I'm just here to discuss ND football.

I have my opinions and often state them strongly. But I don't personally attack or insult anyone. I like good debates. If someone disagrees with me, I kind of like it. I enjoy debating them and seeing if I can sway their opinion or if they can alter my perceptions.

What I don't enjoy is when people take it personally and spew insults.

The biggest thing I think I need tolean is how to statement my opinions in a way that doesn't sound like a "know it all". I often state my opinions strongly. I think others view this as me thinking I am always right, which I know is not the case.

I disagree with a lot of your posts, Solo, but I can't recall ever giving you negative reps. You're usually pretty good about backing up your arguments, and you provide great fodder for discussion around here. You get down on this team not because you want to complain, like some of the sourpusses on here, but because you love this team and want them to be the absolute best. And I have to respect that.
 
S

solo

Guest
I disagree with a lot of your posts, Solo, but I can't recall ever giving you negative reps. You're usually pretty good about backing up your arguments, and you provide great fodder for discussion around here. You get down on this team not because you want to complain, like some of the sourpusses on here, but because you love this team and want them to be the absolute best. And I have to respect that.

That's good to hear. Thanks. I never know quite how people will read me. I think yo nailed it.
 

LOVEMYIRISH

old timer
Messages
5,125
Reaction score
409
I disagree with a lot of your posts, Solo, but I can't recall ever giving you negative reps. You're usually pretty good about backing up your arguments, and you provide great fodder for discussion around here. You get down on this team not because you want to complain, like some of the sourpusses on here, but because you love this team and want them to be the absolute best. And I have to respect that.

Yup...

I have only given one guy negative reps: Clotho/RalphWaldoEmerson
 

Easton Pa ND Fan

New member
Messages
700
Reaction score
48
You got a positive from me...

You got a positive from me...

nd1,

1. You not only made a contribution ("Combined..."),
you included the link for easy reference.

2. The contribution was one of the best posts
of this season, it contained summary data that
answered many recruiting questions.

3. It is a sad fact about our culture, we are 10x
more likely to criticize than praise or contribute,
it has something to do with how we are raised.

- Perhaps IrishEnvy can eliminate this bias by only
giving 1/10 the value to negative ratings. Even
better, give 10x the value to contribution or
positive ratings.

4. Your posts are worthwhile, keep up the good work...Tom
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
thanks for kind words. Yea I had few postive but I was asking about the negative pionts I had. I was just curious how it all worked.
 
Top