ND fields very good teams, enough to put us in the conversation of top 5-10.
2 things that keep ND from being elite and/or upsetting elite programs (w frequency):
1. The fans are deeply loyal and the admin. exploits this loyalty. They slow play the progress in terms of more flexible recruiting practices and speed-track superficials well enough to promote the brand. The money has to be affected for systemic changes to occur. (ND fans would never boycott, even though we need better and more elite recruits..)
2. We don’t have a true underdog mentality. Case in point was this game versus Clemson. The smoke was blowing everywhere including Kelly listing demands of the playoff committee and Book addressing Heisman talk. That ain’t Rocky. ND entitlement is difficult to avoid when everything seems gold.
Bama addresses the first one easily so the second never arises. When was the last time you thought Alabama was an underdog? It’s almost disturbingly laughable how dominant Alabama has been when we keep rehashing the theme that we are back.
This isn’t pessimism. I like this team and I respect that we recruit players who are real student athletes. But we also need a ton more Zoriches and Jerome Buses to ever bring a chip home again.
Bama was an underdog for a good twenty years, on the regular. There is a reason that you really never heard of Bama outside of the early 90s teams under Stallings until the arrival of Saban in 2007. Hell, I would venture to say it was closer to 30 years because the early 80s teams were not all that great under Bear. His last game was at the Liberty Bowl, which I attended when Bama won, maybe seven games?
Sure they played in several SEC title games but they were never the favorite, Florida was. It was always an upset when Bama won in the Nineties. Football has always been cyclical. But yes, there is definitely a nostalgia factor that gets exploited by the ND administration, and frankly any administration worth their salt.
I think that the fans certainly feel like the underdog more than the players might, but I do not subscribe to the idea that there is absolutely no underdog mentality on the team.
However I do think it needs to be permeating the team and the student body, not to be pessimistic level, but on a level of we need to prove something each and every time we play.