Davis might have been known as a disciplinarian while Coker had The Brawl but Coker had a better record than Davis, ,59-15 0.797 to 51-20 0.718. And Davis had the only losing season '97, Miami's had since Schnellenberger's first year, '79.
Under Davis Miami won the Big East once '00, and was Co-Champ twice, '95,'96.
Under Coker Miami won the the NC once, '01, lost another in OT '02, won the Big East twice, '01, '02, and was Co-Champ once, '03.
The difference that Coker had to contend with that Erickson and Davis before him didn't have to contend with was
after '03 Miami was no longer THE BEAST in The Big East.
In '04 Miami moved to the ACC.
Big East Record
'01 12-0
'02 12-1
'03 11-2
ACC Record
'04 9-3
'05 9-3
'06 6-6
The schedule got tougher after '03
In '02 season Miami lost to OSU by 7 points in the Fiesta Bowl for the NC.
In '03 lost to VT by 24, and the SEC's UTN by 4
In '04 (ACC) UNC by 3, Clem by 7, VT by 6
In '05 FSU by 3, GT by 4, LSU by 37 in a bowl blowout
In '06 FSU by 3, LOU by 24, GT by 7, VT by 7, UMD by 4, UVA by 10.
UVA is the only '06 loss that wasn't to a bowl eligible team. IF UVA beats VT Saturday then all Miami's losses are to '06 bowl teams. Their schedule has gotten much tougher in the ACC than it was under Jimmy Johnson (Independent), or Erickson and Davis (Big East).
And his successor will have to deal with that.
I suspect Miami also suffered this year with due to the sweeping coaching changes made last January after the Peach Bowl disaster when he fired 4 assistants to appease the angry alums: OC Dan Werner, OLine Art Kehoe, RB Don Soldinger, LB Vernon Hargreaves. Kehoe had been an assistant at Miami for 25 years (Schnellenberger hired him), Werner for 8.
Despite the execution of assistants Miami fared 89 points worsein Offense in '06 scoring 234 points against '05's 325 points. Defense gave up 10 more points 181 v 171.
Here's the trend - Point Differential (Offense minus Defense) for '00 to '06:
Offensive Production dropped from a high of 527 in '01 to a low 234 in '06