It was not the running backs, it was the plays and play calling.
The pro offense sucks in college. In the Nave game, with the ball on the one yard line, our quarterback takes the ball back five yards and hands it to our slowest running back, who attempts to go wide; no fullback to block, no pulling guard. Hughes makes a great run to only lose five yards.
Look at what Stanford did to us.
Play college football and forget about being a farm team for the pros.
That play you are talking about to Hughes didn't fail because of the pro-style offense, it failed because it was the wrong play call. You wanted a FB, a pulling guard, etc, that's still pro-style offense.
You even talk about what Stanford did to us. Guess what? That's a pro-style offense.
You know who else runs a pro-style offense? USC. And they pretty much are a farm team for the NFL as well as a perennial title contender.
Our struggles had nothing to do with the pro-style offense last year (in 2007, yes, because it was too complicated for a freshman QB and freshmen RBs and receivers), but it had everything to do with defensive scheme and possibly defensive talent, attitude, motivation, attention to detail, etc. Oh yeah, and Big Ten refs. You'll notice that most of those things can be fixed by the right coach. Hopefully we have that inKelly.
Oh, and btw, if you think that slow-developing play to Hughes frustrated you, wait until you see what ND does on 4th and the inch-line. We'll still stay in the shotgun and the QB will receive the ball at the 5 yard-line. That is going to kill me next year...