A Letter to Brian Kelly

theclassickiller

old and improved
Messages
500
Reaction score
104
After a heartwrenching loss to a mediocre (at best) Michigan team who probably has the worst combination of offense and defense that we will face all year, this is what you come up with:

"We're not good enough, there's not one individual in that locker room — including all the coaches — who are good enough right now."

Seriously, Brian? We're not good enough? Not one individual? Michael Floyd isn't good enough? Manti Te'o isn't good enough? Cierre Wood, Theo Riddick, TJ Jones, Jonas Gray, Ethan Johnson, Kapron Lewis-Moore, Louis Nix, Tyler Eifert, Tommy Rees, RJ Blanton aren't good enough? I could go on Brian. And the common thread is that they are all good enough. I can point to a multitude of things that went wrong and a couple of players who were abused last night, but I can only think of one person right now who isn't good enough.

I think you know who I'm talking about.

I don't know when it's going to click for you. When are you going to get it? Are you that soft? Do you honestly think anyone will respect you more for running the clock out than for putting your foot on the opponent's throat and finishing it? Do you know what stage you are even on?

You're not good enough Brian. When you're good enough, we will win. But right now, you aren't good enough and no one is to blame but you. What did you see in the first half that you didn't like that would make you change your model? Moving up and down the field at will, that isn't good enough to win? What would make you think that a good option on third and short is to run the only play Michigan has been able to stop all night? Honestly, we could have thrown every down all night long and they couldn't have stopped it. I'm not sure putting up a sign that says "PUT 9 IN THE BOX, WE'RE GOING UP THE MIDDLE!" could have made you more predictable. And to think that this game should have been out of reach in the first half and your lack of coaching would have been a moot point.

Let's be honest here. You know how this game was lost. You are making excuses out of anger and the truth is that this is the best team we have fielded since Lou Holtz was on the sidelines. You don't know how to coach them. You're stubborn and you refuse to play to the size of this stage. You pull pages from the Charlie Weis book of mediocrity constantly and you don't get why we lose these games? We're not good enough yet?

Come on Brian. You've got 10 more games to figure this out. This team could make a BCS bowl at 10-2 and win it with this talent because of one thing. They are good enough.

I know you've been a winner everywhere you've gone. But that was somewhere else, and this is Notre Dame. No one could care less about beating Cincinatti. No one could care less about beating Central Michigan. This is Notre Dame, and beating Notre Dame is like winning a bowl game. You need to come to grips with where you are. If it's simply the learning curve for playing on this stage that you are adapting too then you could turn it around. If it's a lack of respect for the emblem on the jersey that causes your blindness then you aren't the right guy for this job.

There is no one to blame for this 0-2 start but you, Brian.

You aren't good enough right now. When you're good enough, we will win.
 

PJWhitfield

New member
Messages
267
Reaction score
20
You win as a team and you lose as a team. But I can't honestly say that Michigan's coach outcoached Kelly. It was inexplicable that Michigan did not run Denard more in the first half. That's what gave us the big lead.
 
K

koonja

Guest
Hoke made adjustments at halftime, BK did not. Hoke let Denard loose.
 

theclassickiller

old and improved
Messages
500
Reaction score
104
No, Brian Kelly made adjustments. He went from full speed ahead to cruise control. It's the same thing people said last year. He's got a small-time mentality. He doesn't get it.

Any coach can coach a win from behind. I could do that. It takes a big time coach who gets it to coach with the lead. That's why Saban, Meyer, Tressel, Carroll, and Stoops all succeed. They know that the key to coaching with the lead is to never take your foot off the gas. When a team is demoralized it's no time to take sympathy and show respect for them. He just doesn't get it.
 

tko

I am Legend
Messages
8,516
Reaction score
1,710
kelly is on watch imo. those play calls on 3rd and short with an opportunity to ice the game were so bad. he is a fraud til i see anything different.
 

Free Manera

Well-known member
Messages
2,949
Reaction score
3,547
I respectfully disagree with most of these sentiments. Brian Kelly wasn't good enough, this is true. However, players make plays. If the secondary was good enough, they would have turned around once or twice while a pass was in the air to make a play. Robinson was throwing the ball up for grabs because he had nothing to lose - worst case scenario it is incomplete. You can't intercept a pass you aren't looking at.

Tommy Rees, (who I support and wanted to start from the beginning because he gets results) wasn't good enough. He led a ballsy drive to give the Irish the lead, and that is commendable. But he committed three turnovers, none of which were caused by pressure in the pocket or great plays, but instead two poor decisions to throw into double coverage and one simply dropped ball. Good enough quarterbacks don't do this.

The offensive line opened up great holes for most of the game, springing both Wood and Gray for several big gains. However, on third and short they failed to get a push. An offensive line that cannot move the pile on third and short at least one out of two times is not good enough.

I believe everyone who is lambasting Kelly right now is failing to realize he is building a program. These, for the most part, aren't his players. These players, for the most part, aren't good enough. Coaches can't block, can't break up passes, can't hold onto the football, and can't run backwards nine yards on punt returns. Players make plays, and too often our players did not.
 

GoldenDomer87

New member
Messages
165
Reaction score
9
Geez, we have horrible fans. Two games and everyone is jumping ship. I'm confused by the loses as much as anyone, but I'm not ready to start comparing him to Weis and call for his job.
 
K

koonja

Guest
Geez, we have horrible fans. Two games and everyone is jumping ship. I'm confused by the loses as much as anyone, but I'm not ready to start comparing him to Weis and call for his job.

I didn't compare him to Weis. I said this feels like the Weis days all over, where we have superior talent but can't still win games. Can you honestly refute that?
 

Blaise

Well-known member
Messages
2,233
Reaction score
88
Kelly didn't a terrible job coaching, but to say our players played well enough is a joke.... 30 Seconds and you let them march down.... the o line stop dominating in second half, and we needed one big stop and couldn't get it... to me, Floyd is living up to his billing, everyone else has work to do this week
 

Blaise

Well-known member
Messages
2,233
Reaction score
88
Good coaches have more than one play that they can run on 3rd and 1.

3 and 1 with an running game that was averaging 5 yards a carry??? no brainer... those battles are won by who wants it more... our guys didn't want it
 

anarin

They call me Chuck.
Messages
3,284
Reaction score
809
Geez, we have horrible fans. Two games and everyone is jumping ship. I'm confused by the loses as much as anyone, but I'm not ready to start comparing him to Weis and call for his job.

Couldn't have nailed it better..

I stopped reading your "hate letter" halfway through. This was a team loss, it was not all pinned on BK.

I guess you blame BK for throwing into heavy coverage twice, running into a lineman and fumbling the ball, losing the ball backwards on a pass or being unable to locate a jump ball pass.

I guess it's BK's fault that Motta and Harrison couldn't knock a pass down that floated from the heavens or BK's fault when Gray forgot every single fundamental taught to him his entire LIFE! As I'm sure it was BK's fault that Motta blew the coverage at the end of the game that enabled them to get the huge gain. I'm sure you blame him for the bonehead penalties that we've gotten early in this season, because I'm sure you think he doesn't practice them enough on these things or focus on getting it done.

Yes you can blame him for a few conservative calls at the end of the game, but it was a string of terrible plays by the ENTIRE TEAM that lost them this game.

Since I've joined this site I've noticed that there are different levels of Notre Dame fans, and the level that sticks with their team through thick and thin, and supports them no matter what seems to be the minority.
 

MeanGreen

New member
Messages
178
Reaction score
34
You can teach them and coach them up all you want but you cannot keep them from making mistakes. No coach can or did. Not Knute, not Frank, not Ara, not Dan, not Lou. Could Kelly have done things better these two games. Yes! Could the players have played better? Yes!! Fumbles, Interceptions, drops, not covering your guy is on the players. Pretty sure they do not practice making mistakes at key points in the game. To blame just the coaches or certain players in ridiculous. They all contribute to wins and losses. We have not been pushed around or blown out these two games. Should have won both, eliminate the mistakes and we will be ok. Keep self destructing and it will be a long year.
 

Bmac020211

New member
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
After a heartwrenching loss to a mediocre (at best) Michigan team who probably has the worst combination of offense and defense that we will face all year, this is what you come up with:

"We're not good enough, there's not one individual in that locker room — including all the coaches — who are good enough right now."

Seriously, Brian? We're not good enough? Not one individual? Michael Floyd isn't good enough? Manti Te'o isn't good enough? Cierre Wood, Theo Riddick, TJ Jones, Jonas Gray, Ethan Johnson, Kapron Lewis-Moore, Louis Nix, Tyler Eifert, Tommy Rees, RJ Blanton aren't good enough? I could go on Brian. And the common thread is that they are all good enough. I can point to a multitude of things that went wrong and a couple of players who were abused last night, but I can only think of one person right now who isn't good enough.

I think you know who I'm talking about.

I don't know when it's going to click for you. When are you going to get it? Are you that soft? Do you honestly think anyone will respect you more for running the clock out than for putting your foot on the opponent's throat and finishing it? Do you know what stage you are even on?

You're not good enough Brian. When you're good enough, we will win. But right now, you aren't good enough and no one is to blame but you. What did you see in the first half that you didn't like that would make you change your model? Moving up and down the field at will, that isn't good enough to win? What would make you think that a good option on third and short is to run the only play Michigan has been able to stop all night? Honestly, we could have thrown every down all night long and they couldn't have stopped it. I'm not sure putting up a sign that says "PUT 9 IN THE BOX, WE'RE GOING UP THE MIDDLE!" could have made you more predictable. And to think that this game should have been out of reach in the first half and your lack of coaching would have been a moot point.

Let's be honest here. You know how this game was lost. You are making excuses out of anger and the truth is that this is the best team we have fielded since Lou Holtz was on the sidelines. You don't know how to coach them. You're stubborn and you refuse to play to the size of this stage. You pull pages from the Charlie Weis book of mediocrity constantly and you don't get why we lose these games? We're not good enough yet?

Come on Brian. You've got 10 more games to figure this out. This team could make a BCS bowl at 10-2 and win it with this talent because of one thing. They are good enough.

I know you've been a winner everywhere you've gone. But that was somewhere else, and this is Notre Dame. No one could care less about beating Cincinatti. No one could care less about beating Central Michigan. This is Notre Dame, and beating Notre Dame is like winning a bowl game. You need to come to grips with where you are. If it's simply the learning curve for playing on this stage that you are adapting too then you could turn it around. If it's a lack of respect for the emblem on the jersey that causes your blindness then you aren't the right guy for this job.

There is no one to blame for this 0-2 start but you, Brian.

You aren't good enough right now. When you're good enough, we will win.

+1. Well said.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,443
Reaction score
1,375
Enough blame to go around

Enough blame to go around

Some good comments were made that ND has not learned how to play with a lead for many years now. Probably bothered most by our predictable 3rd & 1 run plays. We lost 2-3 yards on every attempt. Yes we gained 500+ yards and still scored 31 points in spite of 5 TO's but I still think what we ask this offense to do is vanilla and we asked more from DC. What happed to the Lerpacat or getting the ball into Theo's hand to run more often? End around to Floyd?! Just lacking in total imagination especialy the run ame despite the 200 yards. Very ineffective pass rushing and blitzing and guys who were frozen in the headlights when Denard would get near them. Tackling was embarrassing. Not giving up on Kelly tough as I think he has te fire to motivate and win. We did look tired on D in the 4the quarter.
 

irishff1014

Well-known member
Messages
26,511
Reaction score
9,285
After the first 2 scores he quit be aggressive. I want to see us put 50 or 60 points on someone. This is college football not pop warner there is no slaughter rule.
 

jjsccer2

Member
Messages
193
Reaction score
13
Terrible game for Irish fans last night. Where is your letter to Tommy Rees for letting the ball fall out of his hand on his throw? What about Cierre Wood for simply dropping the ball? Or Bob Diaco for that poor defense with 22 seconds left? Everyone is to blame for that loss. Especially fans like you who have zero patience and are hurting the progression of ND football program. How do we get back to where we want to be? Belief! Rocket gave a speech about unbelief last year I think it was. He was talking to you! Please do not post on this board when ND wins the next 5 games. I have forgiven the team realizing that there are far more serious things to worry about especially on a day like today.
 
K

koonja

Guest
hansensouthbend Eric Hansen
#NotreDame averaging 5.0 turnovers a game. If that held up over the entire 12-game season, Irish would fall 1 short of the NCAA record (61).
 

TDHeysus

FLOOR(RAND()*(N-D+1))+D;
Messages
3,315
Reaction score
355
cant you see over the last 20 years that hiring and firing coaches isnt going to fix this? I cant believe some ppl fall into the same trap time after time. Fire the coach! yea, its worked so well for ND before why not continue the practice a firing coaches....
 
Last edited:

ShamrockOnHelmet

Refreshman
Messages
2,745
Reaction score
1,750
Since I've joined this site I've noticed that there are different levels of Notre Dame fans, and the level that sticks with their team through thick and thin, and supports them no matter what seems to be the minority.

I love this equation:

I don't criticize the team = I'm a better fan than you.

Brilliant.
 
Top