College Football Playoff Invitational by ESPN

Are you in favor of Notre Dame getting a top four seed and a bye?


  • Total voters
    93

Notre Dame Joe

Well-known member
Messages
668
Reaction score
377
Correct. As Americans we all accept that more or less, the best teams often don't win the championships of their sports due to the nature of the playoffs. European domestic soccer leagues are the only leagues that actually reward the best teams with championships every single year.

I think the closest we could get in CFB would be the +1 model. Play the regular season, play the bowl season, at end of the last bowl release the final rankings (preferably BCS or something similar to avoid the obvious bias of the committee), and #1 plays #2 in a national championship game. It will not perfectly reward the best team, but it's better than this system.
The AP should vote after Thanksgiving and award the crystal football for having the best regular season. Then the conferences and ESPN can have a tournament for the lipstick trophy. The true fans of college football can treat the former as the real national champion.
 

Notre Dame Joe

Well-known member
Messages
668
Reaction score
377
The flip side is that SEC homers would turn that on it's head and say, "you proved my point, this is exactly why all those 6-4 SEC teams are in the bottom of the top 25, even Vegas agrees"
No problem. Just examine the records of those 6-4 teams to find all of the good OOC wins that prove that they really are the strongest conference.

We have
LSU: def La Tech (8-2) ya
OU: def UTEP (1-9) Lol
Ole Miss: Def Charlotte (1-9) nope
Florida: Def Florida Atlantic (6-4) not close.
 

NDMatt91

Well-known member
Messages
3,790
Reaction score
3,784
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)

O'Malley could even see us dropping to #9 if everything above happens but Texas Tech wins the B12 and finishes at 12-1. He could see Texas Tech and Utah both being ahead of ND in that scenario. I forget who said it, but one of them said that ND needs to root for USC when they play UCLA. If the B10 Championship Game is between 11-1 UCLA and 11-1 Indiana, the loser with a 2nd loss will not be ahead of ND.
 

arrowryan

Well-known member
Messages
15,865
Reaction score
11,449
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)

O'Malley could even see us dropping to #9 if everything above happens but Texas Tech wins the B12 and finishes at 12-1. He could see Texas Tech and Utah both being ahead of ND in that scenario.

I wouldn’t hold my breath for that one
 

317Irish

Grits are a$$
Messages
1,266
Reaction score
1,120
That would screw Georgia too though. They will figure out a way to keep UGA away from Miami and us.
After putting aside how wildly unjust it would be to “find reasons” to move ND down and potentially into a scenario where we have an away game in round 1, I realized how badly it could backfire on the committee. If Georgia remains as the #1 team and we get pushed down to #9, there’s a good possibility we eliminate the committee’s best chance at an SEC National Champ in round 2.
 

Irish#1

Livin' Your Dream!
Staff member
Messages
46,227
Reaction score
22,480
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)

O'Malley could even see us dropping to #9 if everything above happens but Texas Tech wins the B12 and finishes at 12-1. He could see Texas Tech and Utah both being ahead of ND in that scenario. I forget who said it, but one of them said that ND needs to root for USC when they play UCLA. If the B10 Championship Game is between 11-1 UCLA and 11-1 Indiana, the loser with a 2nd loss will not be ahead of ND.
That gives me the creepy willies.
 

NotKoon

Well-known member
Messages
646
Reaction score
1,362
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)

O'Malley could even see us dropping to #9 if everything above happens but Texas Tech wins the B12 and finishes at 12-1. He could see Texas Tech and Utah both being ahead of ND in that scenario. I forget who said it, but one of them said that ND needs to root for USC when they play UCLA. If the B10 Championship Game is between 11-1 UCLA and 11-1 Indiana, the loser with a 2nd loss will not be ahead of ND.

I don’t see them putting ND in the 8/9 spot. 7 or 10 I can see, they won’t want UGA’s first game to be the Irish
 

GTB

Active member
Messages
208
Reaction score
168
Agree w this. I think ND and Miami scare the shit out of the committee. If healthy they’ll be the 2 of the 3 toughest outs.
the majority of the committee want an all SEC Final so that is what they will work at
so to get what they see is the best possible result for them which is Alabama/Georgia
they have to account for the two teams that are most likely to beat them which is ND and Miami
obviously, they have to then schedule so that those two teams have the hardest route to the final without playing Alabama or Georgia until the semi's.
THAT what all the crude stupidity is about
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,958
Reaction score
11,255
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)
Why do we get punished for not playing a CCG but Alabama doesn't? (oh, wait, I know...)
I still think we stay ahead of Miami. Head-to-head matters most, we're told. I guess it's possible Wake would jump us if they beat Miami by more than we did, but I just don't think that's going to happen.
A UCLA loss before the Big 10 title game would definitely help us. Which means rooting for Michigan and USC. Barf.

What a system we have devised...
 

stlnd01

Was away. Now returned.
Messages
13,958
Reaction score
11,255
Why do we get punished for not playing a CCG but Alabama doesn't? (oh, wait, I know...)
I still think we stay ahead of Miami. Head-to-head matters most, we're told. I guess it's possible Wake would jump us if they beat Miami by more than we did, but I just don't think that's going to happen.
A UCLA loss before the Big 10 title game would definitely help us. Which means rooting for Michigan and USC. Barf.

What a system we have devised...
Also damn. You can get tickets to the Michigan-UCLA game tomorrow for $12. Michigan's in a rough spot right now.

That said, a trip to Michigan is probably one of the tougher games UCLA will play this year. Maybe Tommy Carr can do his big brother a solid and put some points on the board. Maybe.
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,705
Reaction score
6,746
I posted this in another thread, but O'Malley and Sampson think there's a pretty good chance that ND finishes at 8 if they win out. O'Malley even said that is his prediction. They believe that the following teams will be ahead of ND:

Georgia (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Texas (SEC Champ or runner-up)
Alabama
UCLA (12-1 B10 runner-up)
Indiana (12-1 B10 Champ)
Utah (B12 Champ)
ACC Champ (Miami or Wake)

O'Malley could even see us dropping to #9 if everything above happens but Texas Tech wins the B12 and finishes at 12-1. He could see Texas Tech and Utah both being ahead of ND in that scenario. I forget who said it, but one of them said that ND needs to root for USC when they play UCLA. If the B10 Championship Game is between 11-1 UCLA and 11-1 Indiana, the loser with a 2nd loss will not be ahead of ND.
It was Brice. If it plays out like O’Malley & Sampson predicts, it’ll be a clear message from the Committee & all who influence them that ND is being punished for not being in a conference. If that’s the case, there needs to be a counter argument against counting wins over FCS teams b/c it’s clearly a buffer for P4 teams that ND eschews
 

IRISHDODGER

Blue Chip Recruit
Messages
8,705
Reaction score
6,746
The AP should vote after Thanksgiving and award the crystal football for having the best regular season. Then the conferences and ESPN can have a tournament for the lipstick trophy. The true fans of college football can treat the former as the real national champion.
The AP poll is farcical and just below the committee as being lazy & bias. If you put it to a poll, ND will have to go undefeated just to be considered #1.
 

spoonidentity

Well-known member
Messages
388
Reaction score
499
Agree w this. I think ND and Miami scare the shit out of the committee. If healthy they’ll be the 2 of the 3 toughest outs.

I 100% agree with you and I think the actual teams/coaches do as well. The committee doesn't seem to operate with any sense of logic though.

Ever since Hunter took over mid season due to the Baylor scandal, I think the most consistent lens is the ridiculous and simplistic notion that ND is "always overrated."

Before that it was all about, "look at ND's metrics" but ever since Yuracheck the ONLY thing that makes sense is imagining a mouth breathing trashy sports fan screaming "ND sucks, join a conference." Then the rankings make sense.

However, if ND is 8 and UGA is #1, Georgia coaches, admin, and fans will throw a hissy fit because the ones who watch film will know that they don't want to play ND.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,610
Reaction score
3,095
Thank God the CCG argument is going away after this season. I'm sick of hearing it. 9 of the 12 teams play for one (assuming chalk). Last year, the ACC screwed that up. But typically, 9 play, 9 get in the CFP regardless of outcome (won't punish losers...so they say). That's still 3 teams who did not play in a CCG who get a spot in the playoffs, yes? Why is ND singled out? If 4 SEC teams get into the CFP, 2 of them did not play for a CCG. It's the dumbest thing I've heard from anyone who parrots that talking point.

As far as the "punishment" goes, that is equally as dumb because last year set the precedent that Non-SEC losers will drop 1 or 2 spots. SEC losers will not drop. Assume the same this year.

ND will land where they land. 11-1 ND can be ranked 11th for all I care and they'll still be a Vegas favorite to win the whole damn thing.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,192
If Wake loses to a Toney-less Miami they shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a CFP

Disagree if it's close. They will have only lost to one top 5 team twice while destroying everyone else. Why shouldn't they get a shot before 3 loss that will be in the tier 2 SEC crowd of Tenn/Tex/Bama? Or three loss Oregon. Its an indictment on the SEC that UGA is assumed to win out and it doesn't matter who they get in the CCG.

However, IDGAF b/c the ACC fought the wrong fight and deserves to be stuck at the kiddie table indefinitely.
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,610
Reaction score
3,095
Disagree if it's close. They will have only lost to one top 5 team twice while destroying everyone else. Why shouldn't they get a shot before 3 loss that will be in the tier 2 SEC crowd of Tenn/Tex/Bama? Or three loss Oregon. Its an indictment on the SEC that UGA is assumed to win out and it doesn't matter who they get in the CCG.

However, IDGAF b/c the ACC fought the wrong fight and deserves to be stuck at the kiddie table indefinitely.

The bolded is essentially the 2025 ND argument and it fell flat. But with a conference affiliation, WF, may just get lucky. Although, it didn't work out for the loser of the Big12 CCG game last year either.

Depending on who it is, I can see the committee dogging ACC and Big12 CCG losers to make room for a 4th or 5th SEC/B1G team respectively. I hate it, but I can see it.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
Disagree if it's close. They will have only lost to one top 5 team twice while destroying everyone else. Why shouldn't they get a shot before 3 loss that will be in the tier 2 SEC crowd of Tenn/Tex/Bama? Or three loss Oregon. Its an indictment on the SEC that UGA is assumed to win out and it doesn't matter who they get in the CCG.

However, IDGAF b/c the ACC fought the wrong fight and deserves to be stuck at the kiddie table indefinitely.

Wake has exactly one good win. I would take any team that is 3 - 2, 4 - 3 etc against quality competition over a team that would be 1 - 2.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,192
The bolded is essentially the 2025 ND argument and it fell flat. But with a conference affiliation, WF, may just get lucky. Although, it didn't work out for the loser of the Big12 CCG game last year either.

Depending on who it is, I can see the committee dogging ACC and Big12 CCG losers to make room for a 4th or 5th SEC/B1G team respectively. I hate it, but I can see it.

It was a well accepted argument by everyone outside of the biased committee thus the gambling odds leading to the Hose ND Show finale. It is why Wake deserves a shot in a 12 team field. I agree 100% they will get hosed too for political reasons. Don't conflate the issue of deserving versus receiving.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
9,084
Reaction score
3,192
Wake has exactly one good win. I would take any team that is 3 - 2, 4 - 3 etc against quality competition over a team that would be 1 - 2.

They can only play the guys on the schedule. Why doesn't losing to a top 5 team benefit Wake like it benefits the entire SEC? Line them up against Texas/Tennessee and decide it on the field. SEC deserves zero respect for their performance the last two playoffs which should allow more openings for teams like Wake Forest to put up or shut up. Going 11-1 is hard AF in any conference - give them credit for no "let downs" and showing up every week.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
They can only play the guys on the schedule. Why doesn't losing to a top 5 team benefit Wake like it benefits the entire SEC? Line them up against Texas/Tennessee and decide it on the field. SEC deserves zero respect for their performance the last two playoffs which should allow more openings for teams like Wake Forest to put up or shut up. Going 11-1 is hard AF in any conference - give them credit for no "let downs" and showing up every week.

so 11 - 2 Wake should be in because they can’t control their schedule, what about 11 - 2 UTSA/Memphis? 12 - 1 Liberty? 11 - 2 New Mexico? We just hand out playoff berths because they did the best they could?

Their 2nd best win per FEI right now is Purdue! In OT! ND at least had USC with Pitt.

IMG_1732.jpeg
 

MNIrishman

Well-known member
Messages
2,540
Reaction score
492
I’ve officially switched my stance on all this.

Was firmly in the “who gives a shit, spot the ball. Anyone, anywhere” camp.

That mindset is simply not feasible in a 12 team playoff.

Even the very best team will need a favorable matchup, a lucky break and such, to go all the way.

Absolutely nobody is built to be a buzzsaw that doesn’t stop cutting until there is no more wood.

Injuries happen, shit happens, etc.

IF we win out, anything less than the 7 seed and hosting a first round game is simply unacceptable and a true miscarriage to this sport, and a testament to the committees unchallenged and unlimited power.
That bridge was crossed last year.
 

bcole2

Well-known member
Messages
317
Reaction score
475
My prediction is: Wake is out if they lose the ACCCG, Miami will still be in if they lose. Couple reasons: Miami is a bigger name and brings more eyeballs, and they won the first matchup with Toney, so they will give them a pass in a game without him.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,334
If Louisville beats Kentucky and they beat Duke in impressive fashion I could be swayed on Wake. I didn’t realize they played Duke the last week do the season. That Louisville - Kentucky game will be used as a debate point heavily in this circumstance.
 
Top