College Football Playoff Invitational by ESPN

Are you in favor of Notre Dame getting a top four seed and a bye?


  • Total voters
    89

phillyirish

................
Messages
1,979
Reaction score
952
they absolutely LOVED FPI for YEARS and now its seemingly barely considered. "Strength of Record" is an incredibly flawed (although authoritative sounding) statistic, doesnt measure dominance whatsoever, just attempts to count SOS and wins / losses. Everytime they cite it without referencing a FPI / Game Control type metric i lose my mind.

If we arent getting a bye, I really dont care about playing Wake, TT, BYU, or Boise in the first round - i just want to be on the other side of the bracket from UGA.

You get the sense they'd love to sneak Oregon into a 11 seed to play us at the 6, but seems unlikely they can move up that much at this point.
I mean forget moving Oregon up to 11, I could potentially see the committee moving us to 8 (or even 9). Like what is anyone going to do about it? We basically have no way to move up the rankings going forward, and can only drop lower each week.
 

MPClinton22

Well-known member
Messages
1,281
Reaction score
1,858
I mean forget moving Oregon up to 11, I could potentially see the committee moving us to 8 (or even 9). Like what is anyone going to do about it? We basically have no way to move up the rankings going forward, and can only drop lower each week.
Miami does sort of protect us, as long as we’re in the same “pod” - but that could change if they beat Wake in the ACCCG. No other SEC teams right behind us that’ll have the opportunity to jump us either. I see things stabilizing a bit here unless some upsets happen.
 

DCK_1981

Well-known member
Messages
385
Reaction score
548
For all the hate Driskell gets on here he is absolutely on a heater tonight about Bama. Basically saying Bama has the same resume as ND did last year and we didn’t make it and they are getting a bye. They’re 2-2 vs ranked teams, wins are against 15 & 21 much like us vs USC and Pitt last year but lost by 16 to Tennessee. Also brought up how they got destroyed last year in the SEC title game and still moved up.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,777
Reaction score
1,601
That Bama - Chattanooga game will be epic this weekend.

Hope the Tide can heroically survive
They should drop after that just like Indiana did with a bye. Others schools will lose this week. Some teams will be dropping out of the top 25. It sucks that our opponents manage to lose close games and make our SOS look like shit.
 

greyhammer90

the drunk piano player
Messages
17,981
Reaction score
19,413
My theory is that they will eventually move Bama down behind Tennessee but they are doing it this way because then people will talk about Bama moving down and not the Committee having a likely 10-3 loss Texas in the top 4. Sort of like how last year they purposely made the debate about us vs. Miami as a smokescreen to get Bama in.
 

bcole2

Well-known member
Messages
312
Reaction score
466
Ready for the committee's orgasm scenario? Texas, Bama and Georgia all win out. Texas beats Georgia close in the SECCG. Utah loses in B12CG, UCLA loses in B10CG. Texas 1, Georgia 2, Bama 3, Indiana 4. There won't be any rhyme or reason to 5-12, it will just be set up to give the best matchups to the SEC teams.
 

SportsingHard

Well-known member
Messages
1,693
Reaction score
1,573
The committee's biggest mistake is being so overwhelmingly blatant in their corruption. There's zero chance of this shit standing the test of time. Instead of a superleague, the remainder of the FBS might just boycott the SEC, ESPN/Disney, and the current CFP in favor of their own thing.
 
Last edited:

ulukinatme

Carr for QB 2026!
Messages
32,758
Reaction score
19,639
Take ESPN outta this shit, along with moron Gus Malzahn. Let’s just leave this shit up to the computers already, not human bias
Texas playing like ass for 3 1/2 quarters means nothing, Arch pulling his head out of his ass in the final minutes was just so impressive against a now 4 loss LSU!

Less than 300 yards of offense, needed late heroics to beat a less impressive LSU team. I hope we get Texas.
 

NDRock

Well-known member
Messages
7,583
Reaction score
5,669
My theory is that they will eventually move Bama down behind Tennessee but they are doing it this way because then people will talk about Bama moving down and not the Committee having a likely 10-3 loss Texas in the top 4. Sort of like how last year they purposely made the debate about us vs. Miami as a smokescreen to get Bama in.
Or they’re prepping for UCLA’s inevitable loss, allowing them to move Texas to 4. The loser of the Bama/Georgia SEC CCG drops, but stays in the top 4, giving them 3 SEC teams in the top 4. While we end up 6 or 7.
 

thekid33

President of the Kevin McDougal Fan Club
Messages
3,171
Reaction score
5,317
Confetti falls on jubilant Notre Dame players and coaches as they have just defeated Alabama in the CFP Championship game. Notre Dame fans worldwide bask in the glory of the programs first national championship since 1989.

The next morning, the final CFP Rankings still place Alabama at #1.

Hunter Yurachek, "It was a gutsy loss by Alabama. We felt like that, combined with the fact that all of the SEC schools are ranked in our final Top 25 merited keeping Alabama at #1."
 
Last edited:

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,607
Reaction score
3,086
The committee's biggest mistake is being so overwhelmingly blatant in their corruption. There's zero chance of this shit standing the test of time. Instead of a superleague, the remainder of the FBS might just boycott the SEC, ESPN/Disney, and the current CFP in favor of their own thing.
I’d love this. What’s to stop Fox, NBC, Amazon, or Netflix from getting something like that going if the top non-SEC teams joined together?

Let espn and the sec go down in flames like LIV.
 

MacIrish75

The New Logo is a Jinx
Messages
10,606
Reaction score
20,835
I’d love this. What’s to stop Fox, NBC, Amazon, or Netflix from getting something like that going if the top non-SEC teams joined together?

Let espn and the sec go down in flames like LIV.
It’s almost like you could potentially have 3-4 different big matchups against teams from different conferences and regions of the country on different networks. The games could be played in different regions of the country and could even have fun and festive names. Heck, maybe even a parade? Then you’d need some sort of body to vote on or determine a champion. This is America, after all, so maybe voting would work? You’d want people who know and study football. Maybe people like coaches and sportswriters? Idk just spitballing.

Tbh, I’m not sure why nobody has thought of a system like that before.
 

tko

I am Legend
Messages
8,654
Reaction score
1,899
This is exhausting watching these clowns make stuff up as they go. Hopefully, we hammer SMU and Syracuse, and we get a chance to host a home playoff game. The IU game a few years ago was so electric. Obviously, a bye isn't happening.
 

Irish Norseman

Well-known member
Messages
337
Reaction score
656
It’s a joke. It’s clear that they are ranking teams by resume instead of the best teams which goes against their written selection protocol criteria. You can’t be watching these games and think TX is the 5th best team and Alabama is the 3rd best. It’s sad that the coaches in the room have no say and it’s all the commissioners and ADs that hold the weight. Fuck this whole thing and there’s only one thing left to do…
1795005152647.gif
 

thekid33

President of the Kevin McDougal Fan Club
Messages
3,171
Reaction score
5,317
The blatant corruption of the committee in favor of the $EC + the expansion to 24 teams might not kill the golden goose of college football, but it's certainly going to take the shine off of it.

What's happening with the corruption is so obvious and it's only going to get worse once the field expands. All of the other major conferences and ND know it's happening but are going along with it due to some combination of being happy that the money keeps rolling in and/or lack of ability to put aside other differences and unite against it.

I don't know how you put the toothpaste back in the tube at this point. At a minimum, I hope the fans vote but not watching some of the first and second round games moving forward. I'm watching ND, but I don't need to spend 3.5 hours of my time watching two 4 loss SEC teams playing each other in round 1 of a 24 team playoff.
 

NDFAN2008

Well-known member
Messages
8,371
Reaction score
6,540
Ohio State moves up 6 spots after beating NW yet Texas will struggle against ARK this week and we will beat SMU by 21 and they'll keep Texas where they are at.
 

rtrn2glory

Well-known member
Messages
17,002
Reaction score
7,525
They are proving more and more every week how they are simply just money grabbers and controlled by mouse. seriously if we want it to be fair just use the old BCS system and take away the human element. It's seriously getting out of control.

They flat out were told to give Ohio St a chance these last few weeks b/c they know that they bring money. Just absolutely ridiculous.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,869
Reaction score
37,267
Guys Houston, South Carolina, Kentucky, USC, Ole Miss all lost. They beat Iowa.

Would you have rather had some of the SEC teams even higher? I suppose USC could have been above them, that’s about it. There is a lot of hate to have on the rankings. OSU isn’t really one of them
 

BleedBlueGold

Well-known member
Messages
6,607
Reaction score
3,086
It’s almost like you could potentially have 3-4 different big matchups against teams from different conferences and regions of the country on different networks. The games could be played in different regions of the country and could even have fun and festive names. Heck, maybe even a parade? Then you’d need some sort of body to vote on or determine a champion. This is America, after all, so maybe voting would work? You’d want people who know and study football. Maybe people like coaches and sportswriters? Idk just spitballing.

Tbh, I’m not sure why nobody has thought of a system like that before.

I pick up the sarcasm, but the point is that world you described hasn't existed in 12 years and there is absolutely zero chance the current powers that be go back to it.

College football as we have known it is over. And so the question needs to be, is it right for the sport and the consumers to have to deal with this sort of monopoly?

You can't tell me you wouldn't find a massive amount of support to go back to a league of Four Regional divisions of 10 to 12 teams each (ACC, B1G, Big 12, and Pac 12). Teams don't have to travel across country during the regular season as much and you can resume almost every traditional rivalry game. Do a 8-team or 16-team playoff at the end of the season.

Use the other major TV networks to stand up against ESPN and the SEC. That's the only way this gets fixed.
 
Last edited:
Top