I think many people and probably coaches are giving him a much longer leash because he's a captain and a 3 year starter despite how bad his play has been since MSU. Same thing with Bowen. It's not surprising to myself and others that our LBs looked remarkably better when a player that hasn't been playing great gets replaced by a future first rounder. Same thing with Shuler, he's never been good in coverage, but I think the staff has asked Shuler to take on more of both safeties roles and he's struggled. Also, the film is clearly out there on how to attack him.
I was listening to ISD and they were somewhat ripping him on how lazy his coverage was on the lofton TD, and how he didn't even try to finish the play like talich did. Then they quickly pivoted to he's a good leader. It's the football equivalent of saying "She's really nice". I had high hopes for shuler this year, he's probably injured, he's dealt with some awful stuff off the field, but the end of the day, your play on the field when talking about football is what matters, and it hasn't been good. I don't know how when Bruantae gets back, and works off the rust and how he isn't in with talich. Shuler can have a 3rd safety role, especially in run situations.
But Brauntae isn't back looking like himself yet, so that isn't even an option at this point.