'24 IN S Brauntae Johnson (Notre Dame Signee)

NumbersGuy0520

Well-known member
Messages
1,134
Reaction score
1,637
Any new word here? Strange that things seem so consistently quiet. Saw the Berardino tweet about being close to return for Miami and not sure what to think.

SMU? Playoffs?
 

FWIrish4

Well-known member
Messages
1,587
Reaction score
3,270
Any new word here? Strange that things seem so consistently quiet. Saw the Berardino tweet about being close to return for Miami and not sure what to think.

SMU? Playoffs?
My FW birds told me two weeks ago that this week would be the true ramp up week.

Sampson stated that he was close to making it for the Miami game.

Greg (ISD) said he thinks there’s a good possibility of Brewu, Onye and Tae returning for SMU.

With all 3 of those nuggets, I’m going to guess he’ll be available for the SMU game.
 

BeauBenken

Shut up, Richard
Staff member
Messages
16,186
Reaction score
5,799
What position is he going to play? Serious question. There's no way you take Talich off the field and Shuler is a captain. Tae at nickel?
I think they want Luke in the box and Tae over top, but they can both do it so it really opens up some possibilities.
 

rtrn2glory

Well-known member
Messages
17,013
Reaction score
7,538
Adon is the odd man out imo as much as I hate to say it. IDK if Tae is able to guard man like a true nickel. Not saying he can't just haven't seen it enough to know for sure. He is an excellent tackler, but that's been coming from depth much like Talich has the last few months. This is also predicated on if they view Gray as needing to be off the field. Honestly so far knock on wood he's been very good at nickel, much to my surprise. This goes back to Shuler not playing well right now and possibly could be playing his way off the field. A lot of things that they need to think about as well with the corner room banged up. I could see a scenario where Gray is moved to corner if one of Moore/Sanders goes down and they bring in Tae to play nickel. I like that better than bringing in a backup like Zachary.
 

pumpdog20

Well-known member
Messages
5,611
Reaction score
4,563
Yeah, based on hit and hustle opinion, it kinda seems like Shuler moved over to Tae's position as Talich has been killing it closer to the box. It may be explaining some of the struggles Shuler is having. But end of the day, Talich needs to stay on the field.
 

rtrn2glory

Well-known member
Messages
17,013
Reaction score
7,538
If you play all 3 who comes off the field though? Gray? It will probably boil down to does the staff think Gray is better at nickel right now than Shuler is at safety, which is definitely something you can make an argument for. Granted you have to factor in that one of Talich/Tae will be learning a different spot (boundary safety). I don't think it would be super hard for them, but still it's a different role with different responsibilities. Tae would have to learn nickel as well which I'm betting is much more difficult than learning boundary safety.
 

The Backer

Well-known member
Messages
295
Reaction score
612
Shuler is currently the weakest DB and seems injured. I think you'd wind up with Tae and Talich out there.
 

Rocketman84

Well-known member
Messages
3,281
Reaction score
1,614
If Brauntae doesn't play for ND again this year and goes pro despite playing less than a season, that will say a lot about him. For now, I'll stick to the facts or what we know. He has an injury, has been injury prone, and has a child. They will all play into the decision making. I just can't imagine an NFL team using a 1-2 round pick on a player that has played so little in college and has so many injuries at a position that hardly takes players in the first round.

To get close to maximizing his draft potential he either needs to return this season and blow up in the playoffs or return for next season. But that may not be his priority, not sure.
Well if he can't at least participate AND light up his pro day or Combine after not playing this season due to injury he will have no chance as a 1st Rd pick and would be somewhere in the middle of the 2nd or early 3rd.
 

Sizzlechest

Member
Messages
42
Reaction score
73
I’d be happy with a 3 man rotation with Shuler seeing the field on more obvious run plays. JOB is the one who loses the most from Tae’s return as id expect to not see him much after his return
 

IAIrish

The Dude Abides
Messages
1,941
Reaction score
2,518
This isn't an either or scenario fellas as much as it's 3 guys for 2 spots. Spread the reps evenly as all have been banged up and need some reps off for this stretch run.... it's a simple as that.
 

BeatSC

Well-known member
Messages
4,786
Reaction score
1,605
What position is he going to play? Serious question. There's no way you take Talich off the field and Shuler is a captain. Tae at nickel?
Williams is also a captain and doing his part as a role player now. Williams has been a better RB this year than Schuler has been a safety. JOB should probably displace him. Let’s hope we have to figure it out which means Tae is ready to play and actually will play! Agent be damned!
 

PutuporShutup

Well-known member
Messages
5,173
Reaction score
2,161
BTW I think Shuler has been picked on a bit and it's resulted in some big plays for opposing teams but I think not all of it has been on him. Guess I'm saying some people are being a bit too critical. You still want Shuler on the field too.
I think many people and probably coaches are giving him a much longer leash because he's a captain and a 3 year starter despite how bad his play has been since MSU. Same thing with Bowen. It's not surprising to myself and others that our LBs looked remarkably better when a player that hasn't been playing great gets replaced by a future first rounder. Same thing with Shuler, he's never been good in coverage, but I think the staff has asked Shuler to take on more of both safeties roles and he's struggled. Also, the film is clearly out there on how to attack him.

I was listening to ISD and they were somewhat ripping him on how lazy his coverage was on the lofton TD, and how he didn't even try to finish the play like talich did. Then they quickly pivoted to he's a good leader. It's the football equivalent of saying "She's really nice". I had high hopes for shuler this year, he's probably injured, he's dealt with some awful stuff off the field, but the end of the day, your play on the field when talking about football is what matters, and it hasn't been good. I don't know how when Bruantae gets back, and works off the rust and how he isn't in with talich. Shuler can have a 3rd safety role, especially in run situations.

But Brauntae isn't back looking like himself yet, so that isn't even an option at this point.
 

PutuporShutup

Well-known member
Messages
5,173
Reaction score
2,161
Williams is also a captain and doing his part as a role player now. Williams has been a better RB this year than Schuler has been a safety. JOB should probably displace him. Let’s hope we have to figure it out which means Tae is ready to play and actually will play! Agent be damned!
First, Williams is NOT a captain. He is one of the other leaders on the team though, so I agree with your point.

Our staff does not like playing Frosh unless they are forced to. Look at JOB, look at how long it took walton to get to be part of the regular rotation, look at premer, dunham still doesn't play a ton when he's clearly our 3rd best DE, no true frosh corners can get in over Zackery, seriously.
 

The Backer

Well-known member
Messages
295
Reaction score
612
I think many people and probably coaches are giving him a much longer leash because he's a captain and a 3 year starter despite how bad his play has been since MSU. Same thing with Bowen. It's not surprising to myself and others that our LBs looked remarkably better when a player that hasn't been playing great gets replaced by a future first rounder. Same thing with Shuler, he's never been good in coverage, but I think the staff has asked Shuler to take on more of both safeties roles and he's struggled. Also, the film is clearly out there on how to attack him.

I was listening to ISD and they were somewhat ripping him on how lazy his coverage was on the lofton TD, and how he didn't even try to finish the play like talich did. Then they quickly pivoted to he's a good leader. It's the football equivalent of saying "She's really nice". I had high hopes for shuler this year, he's probably injured, he's dealt with some awful stuff off the field, but the end of the day, your play on the field when talking about football is what matters, and it hasn't been good. I don't know how when Bruantae gets back, and works off the rust and how he isn't in with talich. Shuler can have a 3rd safety role, especially in run situations.

But Brauntae isn't back looking like himself yet, so that isn't even an option at this point.

Agreed. They've been hiding Shuler a lot in 1 high safety looks. He hasn't done anything egregiously wrong but he isn't making any plays from that spot either. Adding a guy like Johnson with some of what he showed last year would be a huge boost for an already elite defense.
 

GowerND11

Well-known member
Messages
6,885
Reaction score
3,893
If you play all 3 who comes off the field though? Gray? It will probably boil down to does the staff think Gray is better at nickel right now than Shuler is at safety, which is definitely something you can make an argument for. Granted you have to factor in that one of Talich/Tae will be learning a different spot (boundary safety). I don't think it would be super hard for them, but still it's a different role with different responsibilities. Tae would have to learn nickel as well which I'm betting is much more difficult than learning boundary safety.
Early downs you can run a 4-2-5 with Talich in the box in the "Nickel" spot as the box safety, then have him come off for a traditional Nickel, Gray.
 

pumpdog20

Well-known member
Messages
5,611
Reaction score
4,563
Williams is also a captain and doing his part as a role player now. Williams has been a better RB this year than Schuler has been a safety. JOB should probably displace him. Let’s hope we have to figure it out which means Tae is ready to play and actually will play! Agent be damned!
The captains are Carr, Faison, Drayk, and Shuler.
 

Dale

Well-known member
Messages
20,903
Reaction score
37,336
My assumption would be rotation would be offensive personnel driven. Right now JOB plays in Dime and against certain 12 personnel.
 

PutuporShutup

Well-known member
Messages
5,173
Reaction score
2,161
My assumption would be rotation would be offensive personnel driven. Right now JOB plays in Dime and against certain 12 personnel.
That makes sense in principle, but I'm struggling to think of what offensive personnel i'd prefer Shuler in either over one of Tae/Talich or another LB, or another DB.

Shuler just keeps putting out bad tape in big moments, or when he has a shot to make a play almost every game post Rice. I'm actually struggling to remember any really good plays he's made since Rice.

Lets assume we're talking first round of playoffs. Brauntae has played 1-2 games to end the season to get rust off and you're confident he's himself. DJ is back. When are you playing shuler outside of giving one of them a break? I can't think of a opposing offensive personnel where he should be in with how he's playing. Maybe big dime packages with 3 safeties (i'd still prefer JOB). Maybe some goal to go situations with specific personnel (but even here he's so bad at covering TEs and they're weapons goal to go).

If Brauntae is really ramping up practice this week with the expectation to play next week Shuler has to know his play isn't going to cut it. I would assume the coaches have been challenging him before the return of brauntae. He's a captain. You want your captains to also be your best players, on D this year, your 2 captains have not played well.
 

Fbolt

I've been around
Messages
7,574
Reaction score
2,712
It seems to me that either Adon has been injured or he's been covering for Tae and picking up areas that Talich has not/is unable to do.
 

MeanGreenBeans

Well-known member
Messages
1,366
Reaction score
1,269
It seems to me that either Adon has been injured or he's been covering for Tae and picking up areas that Talich has not/is unable to do.
Crazy to think what this defense could've been in the regular season with all our starters. It's all in the game though. Injuries happen, and we're about to get Brewu, Onye, and Brauntae back for the CFP run. It's been a while since 1988, and now it's time fellas...

 

MeanGreenBeans

Well-known member
Messages
1,366
Reaction score
1,269
Anyone else think he's about to ball out? He's the kind of player we used to watch play for Miami/OSU/Bama/Florida/Georgia and wonder why ND doesn't have him. And now here he is... Let's fucking go Brauntae.
 

NDMD

Well-known member
Messages
564
Reaction score
1,008
Early downs you can run a 4-2-5 with Talich in the box in the "Nickel" spot as the box safety, then have him come off for a traditional Nickel, Gray.
I think it's more likely that Shuler would come off obvious passing downs, assuming Johnson is healthy and sharp
 

GowerND11

Well-known member
Messages
6,885
Reaction score
3,893
I think it's more likely that Shuler would come off obvious passing downs, assuming Johnson is healthy and sharp
It's possible. Whatever it may be, it's good problems to have if Tae is back and healthy.
 
Top