"NFL Ready", what is that? I would like for anyone to name an NFL quarterback that was "NFL Ready" when they came out of college, I can think of only two. (Dan Marino & Peyton Manning) and people can disagree with even Manning because Manning threw 28 pics against 26 TD's his rookie year
Plunkett, Elway, Bradshaw, Aikman, A. Manning, Young, & Brees, all stunk up the field as rookies. There are a lot more, Farvre, Montana, Staubach, & Theisman didn't even start as rookies. Would anyone have said that Brady was NFL Ready when he came out of college?
I have always held the opinion that once is a fluke, twice is a trend, & three times is a habit. That is how I look at pro atheletes, and that is how I look at peoples achievments. I look at individual games and seasons the same way. How do we know that Brady Quinn can't play in the NFL? Sure, Anderson came in and had one decent game. But what else 2 completions for 23 yards in his 2nd game back. Anderson is a pretty decent quaterback, could it be that Offensive line sucks and they have no decent receivers? Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, or Tom Brady couldn't help that team. Using my formula for judgement the "once is a fluke theory...," How do Mangini's teams records stack up. I guess what I am trying to say is that two great games with even a good offensive line, does not earn someone a spot in the Hall of Fame, but neither should two bad games with a sorry offensive line and no receivers indicate a QB isn't any good.