CANONIZEFATHERSORIN
Well-known member
- Messages
- 1,081
- Reaction score
- 906
Would have never guessed at the time of hiring that Marcus freeman would be a far better on field coach than recruiter three years in
I'm huge Tank fan as well but IMO he's a true "MIKE" whereas I see Clapper as a potential WILL and/or ROVER.I still like Tank the best but a good group either way
Would have never guessed at the time of hiring that Marcus freeman would be a far better on field coach than recruiter three years in
You are a f*ing douche.Great another high ranked WR whose we won’t pay and will go somewhere else
ToucheYou are a f*ing douche.
This post makes no sense in the context of we're on our best 4 year recruiting run of the internet era and the visitor list for this weekend is 15+ top 300 recruits.
I think we're recruiting slightly better but probably at the best level possible. If we don't get any 5* kids after the season we had and the publicity Freeman has gotten, then it's obviously an institutional problem.Are we??? Our classes are routinely finishing in the rankings at or below where Kelly classes did and Kelly’s best class was better than freeman’s best class. And still no five stars
Are we??? Our classes are routinely finishing in the rankings at or below where Kelly classes did and Kelly’s best class was better than freeman’s best class. And still no five stars
I'll be surprised if we sign a 5* this cycle since we aren't really dropping bags for recruits. Unless they're the son of a former NFL player or value academics like Guerby Lambert, I just don't see it. I hope I'm wrong.I think we're recruiting slightly better but probably at the best level possible. If we don't get any 5* kids after the season we had and the publicity Freeman has gotten, then it's obviously an institutional problem.
Agree. Nobody likes to self impose restrictions like ND.I'll be surprised if we sign a 5* this cycle since we aren't really dropping bags for recruits. Unless they're the son of a former NFL player or value academics like Guerby Lambert, I just don't see it. I hope I'm wrong.
2022 #7 Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 236
2023 #12 Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits : 226
2024: #9 Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 283
2025: #12 Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 305
Average rank: 262.5
Now let's look at Kelly's most recent 4 year run:
2018: #10, Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 277
2019: #16, Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 280
2020: #18, Average recruit rank of top 16 recruits: 368
2021: #9, Average recruit rank of top 20 recruits: 306
Average rank: 307.5
That's a 15% improvement in Freeman's era despite being handcuffed by our high school NIL policy in ways that Kelly was not. Freeman is getting more blue chippers, but also taking some lower ranked players than Kelly did (in some cases). And I get Kelly is partly responsible for 2022, but Freeman and co held it together + recruited many of the defensive studs, and using it for the sake of 4 years.
All I will say from this exercise was that the 2018 and 2019 classes were a lot better than I remember. It's also amazing what Kelly accomplished in 2020 and 2021 when the average recruit rank of the '16 and '17 classes was 340.
ND can't have another class like 2025. 2026 needs to be back in that 2023 average range with more high end talent.
?Man I want Fitz’s kid so bad Just to have him around the program but if Faison JR Isn’t going to be a player then I don’t know if you can take both of them. Certainly aren’t going to process Larry Fitzgerald‘s kid at the end of the class
247sports.com
Mike Frank said there were plenty of recruits the last few years that were good fits for ND but went elsewhere because they got a big bag, and that if ND just offered them bags, they'd come to ND and be fine (not be locker room cancers). I agree with him. Regarding going to class, the ND staff should just say to the recruits that if they just do what they've done in HS, then they'll be fine at ND.Let's be real fellas, how many elite 5 star prospects really want to attend class and actually be a student-athlete? My guess, not many. Can you remember the last time a starter from a Power 4 Conference was ineligible due to grades? Some schools have always been that way, but now with NIL, school is now a choice for 99% of these universities.
I love Marcus Freeman's approach of choosing hard, but in a time where most of these kids are softer than baby-shit, they're choosing easy (money & being an athlete only).
Are we??? Our classes are routinely finishing in the rankings at or below where Kelly classes did and Kelly’s best class was better than freeman’s best class. And still no five stars
Let's be real fellas, how many elite 5 star prospects really want to attend class and actually be a student-athlete? My guess, not many. Can you remember the last time a starter from a Power 4 Conference was ineligible due to grades? Some schools have always been that way, but now with NIL, school is now a choice for 99% of these universities.
I love Marcus Freeman's approach of choosing hard, but in a time where most of these kids are softer than baby-shit, they're choosing easy (money & being an athlete only).
Interesting to compare this list to last year's Junior Day (below, taken from last year's thread).Junior Day - Jan. 25th
---------------------------------------------
Noah Grubbs - 4* FL QB - Commit
Thomas Davis Jr - 4* NC LB - Commit
Ben Nichols - 4* MI OL - Commit
Sully Garvin - 3* MI OL - Commit
---------------------------------------------
Ekene Ogboko - 5* NC OT - Offer
Jakobe Clapper - 4* OH LB - Offer
Kaydon Finley - 4* TX WR - Offer
Jonaz Walton - 4* GA RB - Offer
Tiki Hola - 4* TX DT - Offer
Jordan Deck - 4* TX - Offer
Simeon Caldwell - 4* FL S/LB - Offer
Connor Salmin - 4* MD WR - Offer
Tyler Merrill - 4* PA OL - Offer
Evan Goodwin - 4* AR OT
Jakore Smith - 4* AR LB - Offer
Brayden Robinson - 4* TX WR - Offer
Zech Fort - 4* CA/IMG S - Offer
Ksani Jiles - 4* CA/IMG - Offer
Kenneth Goodwin - 4* CA LB - Offer
Devin Fitzgerald - 3* - AZ WR
Hakim Satterwhite - 3* MD CB - Offer
Joey Quinn - 3* IL DE
Nick Hankins - 3* IL CB
Ebenezer Ewetrade - 3* NC Vyper
Dakota Dickson - 3* CA DT
Zavion Griffin-Haynes - 4* ND DE - Offer- Going to UNC instead
Not locked in yet but looking to come:
Naheem Burroughs - 4* FL WR - Offer
Greg Patrick - 4* MI OL - Offer
It's not even "a bag" anymore. That was cheating, this is just recruiting. Not wanting to get into that part of recruiting only hurts us. It's like when Dabo was trying to eschew the portal. Fine, handcuff yourself.Is there some reason to think that 5*s are less intelligent or willing to go to class than 4*s? I doubt it. If its about a bag, then give them the bag.
Certainly won't be offensive firepower, maybe a 5* OL or possibly a defensive guy.I'll be surprised if we sign a 5* this cycle since we aren't really dropping bags for recruits. Unless they're the son of a former NFL player or value academics like Guerby Lambert, I just don't see it. I hope I'm wrong.
That's tired because how would we be the only one not getting 5*s that play top 10 Football.Is there some reason to think that 5*s are less intelligent or willing to go to class than 4*s? I doubt it. If its about a bag, then give them the bag.
King or Ili???