Roots of the Game: Drawing a line and refusing to let anyone step over it

B

Bogtrotter07

Guest
Getting back to the roots game: Drawing a line and refusing to let anyone step over it.

After this Michigan game, I have heard many loyal Domers doubt their fan-hood, the direction of the team, and in some cases even BK's decision-making or coaching ability. As always, with this schools tradition, I have heard all kinds of frustration-laden conversation about how long this has been this way, and what happened back in the day . . .

One proposition I would like to put forth is the thing that has changed the most, that single most elusive variable, is that the game has become about the personality and the swagger instead of the job at hand, which translates to more about a choreographed display, rather than about drawing a line and refusing to let anyone step over it. More conversation goes into who gets taunting penalties, or who has more stars, or how fast so and so is. Fantasy football is king; statistics are rewarded; walking the walk, and backing it up, isn't always, anymore.

Back in the day, as they say; the only ones that talked, backed it up. Players simply took ownership for themselves and their teams, refused to let others enter their territory. And if it didn’t work that day, there was always next week, but it would cost your opponent! Words were secondary to action.

The following represents the extreme, but it represents the way the game was played. And that is the principle difference with the game today. Players (and fans) talk first. Instead, do first! It has become about the show, not delivering the business. With our most recent signings, I thought this might be an extremely apropos clarification by example of the seemingly lost art of walking the walk and defending that line:

Atkinson & Tatum
YouTube - Atkinson & Tatum

George Atkinson - Oakland Raiders
YouTube - George Atkinson - Oakland Raiders

George Gipp, Notre Dame’s first All American, and the second consensus All American still holds the Notre Dame, records for “average yards per rush (8.1)”; “average yards per play for total offense (9.37)”; and “average yards per game for total offense (128.4)”. Do you know how he did it? He suffered a broken leg, dislocated shoulder, and a broken collarbone.

There is realness and truth to the combat of football past; that just doesn’t seem to be there now. It used to be purely about bending your opponent to your will; now it seems ratings, polls and premature celebration have encroached. Tough used to mean coming out on every play and exerting your will, trying to destroy the opponents. Now it seems that there needs to be immediate gratification, before the job is even done. What do you think?
 

IrishinSyria

In truth lies victory
Messages
6,046
Reaction score
1,924
I completely disagree.

For one thing, you have to separate the behavior of fans from the behavior of players. Everything we do as fans would be completely unproductive from players. This includes bitch about calls, coaches, playcalls, player performances, Denard Robinson's dreadlocks, etc...This has been, and always will be, a tradition. Fans talk because we care deeply about results we can't do anything about. The internet has just given us a new and more visible forum for this fretting.

Second, while players *may* be more vocal on-field now (though I'm pretty sure Miami in the 80s weren't a bunch of schoolboys) they are DEFINITELY more prepared off the field. Football players today are bigger, faster and stronger than they ever were. They take the game far more seriously. Believe me, if a player is more concerned with talking than doing, he will not be on the field. Period. These guys work their assess off and do more behind the scenes than you can imagine. Again, thanks to the internet and ESPN #s, we have more access to these guys than ever before. So while it may seem like they're more concerned with other things, its just the unprecedented access we have that distorts reality.
 

RDU Irish

Catholics vs. Cousins
Messages
8,628
Reaction score
2,732
I think 95% of the hits in the Tatum/Atkinson clip are illegal by today's rules and would be subject to fines or even suspension. There are good reasons they cracked down on that stuff. If you want to take someone's head off go into the octagon.

That being said, I hope he instilled some of the attitude in his sons! Saw a quote by someone impressive talking about getting a few kids on the roster that "grew up without a mailbox." Meaning tough SOBs that have been permanently ingrained with something to prove. Zorich being the example used. Get three or four guys like that who will run through a brick wall and then eat the bricks or else you will never have an elite defense. I think Calabrese is the only one we have now that fits the mold.

I think the whole "next man in" mentality meant to bring back the toughness and reckless abandon that we all love from old school football. 110% on every play. Don't worry, the next guy in will hold it up while you get your bearings after a big hit/play.
 
B

Bogtrotter07

Guest
Exactly!

This isn't about whose better, old versus new, and obviously, the rule changes to preserve player’s health are paramount. With that, when you watch these films, you have to see a certain indomitable spirit. Like when Atkinson sent a message to Russ Francis, as told by Kenny Stabler. You have to respect the toughness, even if you don't like the method of delivery. Because it’s about being tougher.

This is more of what I am talking about, the attitude. This was football, stripped down. Here are some of the guys who defined the walk and dared you to step over their line:

Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #8 Jack Lambert
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #8 Jack Lambert

Top ten – Jack Tatum # 6
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #6 Jack Tatum

Top ten – Hardy Brown #5
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #5 Hardy Brown

Top ten – Ronnie Lott # 4
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #4 Ronnie Lott

Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #3 Lawrence Taylor
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #3 Lawrence Taylor

Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #2 Night Train Lane
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #2 Night Train Lane

Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #1 Dick Butkus
YouTube - Top Ten Most Feared Tacklers #1 Dick Butkus

N'est Pas?
 
Top