ESPN CFB Live "Top 20 Roundtable"

[rock_knutne]

Personally, good forum even though IMO, Todd Blackledge is the only one who is "really" genuine, Herby and Robert Smith come off as the ultimate O$U/Big 10 homers and Palmer/Pollack are pretty good once you get by the "pretty boy" attitude. One thing's for sure, they aren't very ND friendly.

Thoughts....................

 

[AdmiralBackhand]

For me personally, it is hard to watch this show or anything on ESPN anymore. I watch it anyway to find out other information on programs I don't normally follow.

 

[IrishSteelhead]

Palmer - Objective, and reasonable 100% of the time
Blackledge - Objective, and reasonable 90% of the time
Herbstreit - Objective, and reasonable 75% of the time
Smith - Objective, and reasonable 50% of the time
Pollack - Objective, and reasonable about as much as Mark May & Lou Holtz

*Pollack and MayDay are the only ones I feel truly hate ND. Palmer seems to stick up for them quite a bit, while the rest are indifferent (Herbie comes and goes, think he really liked Weis).

 

[Sherm Sticky]

I like Todd Blackledge and Jessie Palmer. Herby and Robert Smith are alright, but they are B1G homers. I CAN'T STAND POLLACK! i LOVED HIM AS A FOOTBALL PLAYER, BUT HE IS A TOTAL MORAN AND DUCHE AS ANALYST. HE IS THE ULTIMATE ND HATE!

 

[PANDFAN]

smith actually last year was high on ND...but i would agree w/ most of everyone's opinions

 

[rock_knutne]

Yeah, gotta agree on Pollack, the guy definitely hates ND but so does 95% of CFB fans who don't pull for the Irish.