Arkansas Five Causing a stir...

C

ChiND

Guest
Not that these parents' should care if their children are receiving an education or not...
FAYETTEVILLE — Parents for Arkansas freshman football players Mitch Mustain, Damian Williams and Ben Cleveland met with Razorbacks Athletic Director Frank Broyles last week to discuss concerns about the direction of the football program.

Rick Cleveland, Ben’s father, confirmed Tuesday that the meeting took place last Thursday in Broyles’ office and lasted about an hour. The meeting included Rick Cleveland, Beck Campbell (Mustain’s mother ), David and Karen Williams, and Broyles.

The meeting centered on whether Arkansas offensive coordinator Gus Malzahn will get more say in how the offense is run, Rick Cleveland said, and if it will be more pass-oriented.

Mustain is a quarterback and Cleveland and Williams are receivers, and all three played for Malzahn at Springdale High School, where they excelled in a Spread, no-huddle offense to help the Bulldogs go 14-0 last season and win the Class AAAAA state championship.

“The reason for the meeting was very simple,” Rick Cleveland said. “We wanted to know what is the direction of Arkansas ’ football program ? Are we eventually going to get to Gus ’ offense ? Or are we going to stay with the way we are at present ?”

In going 10-3 this season and winning the outright SEC West title, Arkansas’ offense has been built around sophomore tailbacks Darren McFadden, a consensus All-American who was the Heisman Trophy runnerup last week to Ohio State quarterback Troy Smith, and Felix Jones. They are the third duo in SEC history to each rush for 1, 000 yards, with McFadden at a school-record 1, 558 and Jones at 1, 018.

It was a big bounce back season for the Razorbacks after they went 5-6 and 4-7 the previous two years to put Coach Houston Nutt’s job status in jeopardy.

Nutt, who hired Malzahn last December to be offensive coordinator and call the plays, was voted SEC Coach of the Year by the media and coaches after the Razorbacks’ six-victory improvement.

“For us, personally, we have nothing against Houston Nutt, nothing against Arkansas ’ program,” Rick Cleveland said. “Every school and its head coach has the full authority to run the offense that they want. That’s what they go recruit people for, to run what they’re comfortable with.

“ That’s not the issue with us. Arkansas has every right to run that and do what they want.”

Cleveland said the issue for the Springdale players and their parents is that the offense isn’t what they were led to believe it would be during the recruiting process.

After Malzahn was hired, Ben Cleveland and Damian Williams switched their commitments from Florida to Arkansas and Mustain recommitted to Arkansas after reopening his recruiting.

“With our kids going to Arkansas, it’s basically like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole,” Rick Cleveland said of the offense. “When Gus came onto the scene, the very first question we would ask was, ‘Do you have full control of the offense and do you have full control of the personnel ?’ Which we were told, ‘Yes.’

“ I don’t believe Gus lied to us. But as the season has progressed, it’s very obvious that this is not Gus Malzahn’s offense and Gus does not have full control of the personnel or the play calling.

“ From our perspective — and it’s only our perspective — it seems as if you’ve been sold a bill of goods.

“ We never would have committed here knowing that this was the offense, because we knew our boys wouldn’t be happy.”

Rick Cleveland said the response from Broyles was that Nutt continues to be in charge of the team.

“His exact words were that experts have told us that Coach Malzahn’s offense will not work in the SEC and for it to work the quarterback has to run the ball 15 to 18 times a game,” Cleveland said. “That made it pretty clear that things are going to stay the way they are and Malzahn’s offense is not going to be run here.”

Broyles said Tuesday he had told the parents they needed to meet with Nutt, not him, but he agreed to see them when they showed up at his office anyway.

“I didn’t want to be rude,” said Broyles, who declined to discuss any details of the meeting.

Nutt declined comment Tuesday about the parents’ meeting but said he doesn’t expect any players to transfer. Malzahn couldn’t be reached for comment.

Rick Cleveland said the parents wanted to meet with Broyles “because he’s the one who ultimately controls everything” at Arkansas.

“Why not go to the person who’s totally in charge ?” Cleveland said. “It was a very pleasant meeting. There was no confrontation whatsoever.”

Since Malzahn was hired, he and Nutt have said publicly the offense would be a combination of what has worked well at Arkansas in the past with additions brought in by Malzahn and new quarterbacks coach Alex Wood, a former NFL offensive coordinator.

Malzahn has said the running backs are Arkansas’ best players and the team would play to its strengths, and his greatest contribution has been putting together an offense that enables McFadden and Jones to be on the field at the same time.

The Razorbacks have run numerous trick plays for big gains and excelled in a “Wildcat” package with the versatile McFadden at quarterback.

Nutt and Malzahn also have said they expect the passing game to continue to progress next season.

David Williams, Damian’s father, declined comment on the meeting and whether his son is considering transferring from Arkansas.

“To be honest with you, I don’t think any of the boys want to transfer. They love Arkansas,” Rick Cleveland said. “But as a ballplayer, you want to be used to the best of your abilities.”

Ben Cleveland and Damian Williams each made the SEC All-Freshman Team and are among Arkansas’ top six receivers.

Williams is tied for second on the team with 19 catches for 235 yards and 2 touchdowns, including a score that put Arkansas ahead to stay just before halftime in its SEC West title-clinching 28-14 victory at Mississippi State.

Cleveland is tied for fourth on the team with 11 catches for 98 yards and 2 touchdowns, including the game-tying reception in overtime against Alabama before Jeremy Davis hit the winning extra point in a 24-23 victory.

Mustain has completed 64 of 122 passes for 853 yards and 10 touchdowns with 8 interceptions. He started eight games, all victories by the Razorbacks, before being replaced by sophomore Casey Dick.

While the three Springdale freshmen have played key roles in the Razorbacks’ season, Rick Cleveland said they anticipated having more impact on the offense.

“It’s a very fluid situation,” Cleveland said of whether he expects any of the Springdale players to transfer. “These are 18-year-old kids. One day they want to stay. One day they’re upset and want to leave.

“ What the coaching staff has to understand is that they can’t keep telling these kids, ‘This is going to happen, this is going to happen, this is going to happen,’ and it doesn’t happen.”

Rick Cleveland said his son and Damian Williams want to play in an offense where they’ll catch 60 passes per season.

J. J. Meadors, with 62 catches in 1995, is the only Razorback with 60 or more catches in a season in the program’s history.

Five SEC players have 60 or more catches this season; three had 60 or more last season.

“Our boys are used to catching 60 passes a year,” Rick Cleveland said. “They want to go to a college where they get the same opportunity. Whether they’re good enough to do that or not is a whole different question. They have to earn that.

“ They are team players... but they’re saying, ‘Hey, I don’t know if I’ll be happy being in this offense, catching 10 balls a year or 15 and blocking 90 percent of the time.’”
 
T

TexasDomer

Guest
You've got to be kididng me. If I were the head coach, I'd rip these kids a new rear end. You don't go over my head about the offensive playcalling.
 

njuneardave

Member
Messages
406
Reaction score
14
talk about the ultimate Zook recruiting strategy... forget bringing in the recruit's h.s. friends.... nutt brought in the recruits coach and promised them a land of milk and honey of offense under malzahn, but he gave them some blocking arm guards.


nutt was a liar... but his offense worked. but, nutt was a liar.
 

irishtexan

Oklahoma smells like pee
Messages
620
Reaction score
18
You've got to be kididng me. If I were the head coach, I'd rip these kids a new rear end. You don't go over my head about the offensive playcalling.



No joke!!!! I would be so freaking pissed if I was the coach!
 
C

ChiND

Guest
This cannot help Arkansas in recruiting; I would say! :smilewink
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
this goes to show how some schools will do whatever it takes to get these kids to go to thier schools. It sure could not be helping thier recruiting.
 
F

FatBaldy

Guest
Yes they went around the coach which was wrong, but it appears Nutt created the situation. This is important stuff to the kids--the offensive scheme could dictate whether they go to the NFL or not. If the receivers changed their commitment based on the promise of a spread offense (not entirely sure from the article that the spread offense was promised), and they are running the current offense...I believe they have someting to complain about. Yes, they should have started with Nutt, but they probably felt like Nutt already lied to them once, so...

Pretty interesting article, thanks for posting it.
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
I agree totally. If nutt told the coach he would have complete control of offence then when he got these kids in school he went back on his word.then I don't really blame the parents for going over his head.
 
F

FleaFlicker

Guest
I can see both sides of it.

It is really inappropriate to go behind a coaches back like that. ESPECIALLY when the three guys in question are all true freshman. I mean, what do they expect, to be stars from day one?

But I bet this has more to do with how outstanding McFadden has been... then anything. McFadden will be a Junior next year, so these parents realize that if McFadden is the teams Golden boy for at least 2 more years, that means their sons won't be.

WHich isn't a big deal in itself, except for when a coach basically goes back on his word.

But really, can you blame the guy? In the end, Nutt needs to win games. If I am planning to get to a more passing-oriented offense eventually, but it turns out that I have a Heisman winner that no SEC defense can stop, that is a running back, I will use him as much as I need to win.

After all, Nutt doesn't get fired for going back on his word with recruits. But he does get fired for losing games.
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
I agree with what you said fleaflicker, but on the other hand you can not blame the parents for wanting the best for thier kids either. nutt does have to look after his job and if mcfadden kepts his job for him then you can not blame him but why did he have to tell the other coach and kids a lie to get them there.
 
T

TexasDomer

Guest
Having my child on scholarship doesn't give him or me permission to go to the AD with my concerns about the direction of the program unless I have attempted and failed to do so with the Head Coach, and even then, it's incredibly inappropriate.

The Head Coach is the leader of the team and the program, and it's his tail on the line if he fails. If he makes a decision that others disagree with, that's his prerogative.
 

njuneardave

Member
Messages
406
Reaction score
14
and if the coach blew smoke up their colons again, just as he has obviously done in the past? where does that get them?
 
C

ChiND

Guest
The coaches might have discussed that these kids could be an awesome spread offense and with their coach coming on board, they could start to implement. However, how can anyone argue the success they had and personally I would also change my gameplan with a McFadden on the team. I have never seen parents go in and bitch with players before the season is even over; let alone they are back as a top team again. This is not U of I, this is a top 15 team. Unprecedented to say the least!!!
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
you can't blame nutt for using mafadden. The only thing I saying is why did nutt tell the coach he would have complete control of offence when he didn't.
 

SillyIrish

New member
Messages
1,020
Reaction score
22
The coaches might have discussed that these kids could be an awesome spread offense and with their coach coming on board, they could start to implement. However, how can anyone argue the success they had and personally I would also change my gameplan with a McFadden on the team. I have never seen parents go in and bitch with players before the season is even over; let alone they are back as a top team again. This is not U of I, this is a top 15 team. Unprecedented to say the least!!!

ChiND you beat me to it. Kind of hard to argue the success of McFadden and the year Arkansas has had. Without McFadden that team would not have finished the sameway if they had run a spread all year with Mustain at the helm. The coach's job is to win football games as he is ultimately responsible for the outcome of the team. So if he decides to go to a run orientated offense during spring drill or in the summer, too bad. These kids have been pampered their entire lives and these parents are use to coddling them, welcome to the real world.
 
F

FleaFlicker

Guest
ChiND you beat me to it. Kind of hard to argue the success of McFadden and the year Arkansas has had. Without McFadden that team would not have finished the sameway if they had run a spread all year with Mustain at the helm. The coach's job is to win football games as he is ultimately responsible for the outcome of the team. So if he decides to go to a run orientated offense during spring drill or in the summer, too bad. These kids have been pampered their entire lives and these parents are use to coddling them, welcome to the real world.

Yeah, I agree...

Although, if I was Mustain's parent. I would be a little pissed that, when my son played, we won all of our games.

And then when Casey Dick got healthy, he took my son's spot and we lost 2 of our last three games. Which includes him passing for 3/17 against LSU.
 

grantland

New member
Messages
460
Reaction score
15
It's actually a pretty good life lesson. You don't always get what you think you are going to get or what you are told you are going to get.

And, how can you freakin' argue with playing MCFadden the most?

And, these guys (and their parents) were incredibly inappropriate. If I am an NFL GM and/or coach I take this little incident and mark it in the negative column. Apple can't fall too far from the tree.
 
C

ChiND

Guest
Seriously have to agreae with you about suspending for the Bowl game. If Nutt backs down, this could only get worse and this type of poison spreads VERY quickly on a team full of competitive athletes. If the kids really feel slighted, then they should transfer. This shit is unreal!
 
S

ShivaIrish

Guest
Another concern is how much can you trust what these parents are saying? Aren't they the only source out there exclaiming that they were told the offense would be like Gus's old offense in high school? Isn't Mustain's mother the same one who made some remark about Weis recruiting her son, which may not have been true? I'm not so sure that there even is two sides to this story. It could just be some complaining parents who believe their son's are entitled to being superstars.
 

ashellm

New member
Messages
44
Reaction score
4
listen, coach nutt wont have to say a word to these kids. could you imagine being an upperclassman who has lived through all the bad times and then finally see some success, only to hear some snotnose punk kid, spoiled rotten brat, go complain to the ad that they were lied too?? don't you think these guys are gonna have something to say about this. i know i would, and it wouldn't be good. for christs sake, they won the sec west!!!! remember, its about the team, not you.
 

nd1

New member
Messages
2,036
Reaction score
24
I kind of agree with what your saying but them kids would not of been thier if nutt wouldn't promised them thier coach would have control. Look two receivers were commited to florida and they changed thier mind when thier high school coach got hired. put 2 and 2 together.
 

LOVEMYIRISH

old timer
Messages
5,125
Reaction score
409
listen, coach nutt wont have to say a word to these kids. could you imagine being an upperclassman who has lived through all the bad times and then finally see some success, only to hear some snotnose punk kid, spoiled rotten brat, go complain to the ad that they were lied too?? don't you think these guys are gonna have something to say about this. i know i would, and it wouldn't be good. for christs sake, they won the sec west!!!! remember, its about the team, not you.

Parents and players like this are a CANCER in a team.

Nutt gets paid a lot of damn money to do what he does. He won the SEC-West (as you mentioned)...he bounced back well from the USC game. I think he deserves kudos.

Screw these parents...

Seriously, I would at the very least suspend their kids from the bowl game.
 

LOVEMYIRISH

old timer
Messages
5,125
Reaction score
409
I kind of agree with what your saying but them kids would not of been thier if nutt wouldn't promised them thier coach would have control. Look two receivers were commited to florida and they changed thier mind when thier high school coach got hired. put 2 and 2 together.

Still, that's life.

Nutt is what I call the OTC. One Throat to Choke.

It's his ass on the line, not the parents or the kids. He makes the calls. And if their coach is not up to the task, to hell with him.

Gerry Faust was a tremendous High School coach, but his Head Coaching job went...poorly... This guy could be the same.
 
J

jerseyborn1971

Guest
Did these people ever once consider that when a HIGH SCHOOL coach was hired as the offensive coordinator for an SEC team that something might not be on the up and up? Gee, we didn't hire this HIGH SCHOOL coach to get his 3 stud recruits, we hired him for HIGH SCHOOL offensive play-calling skills. If they were so dumb as to buy that, then they deserve the screwjob they just got.
 
J

johnchampion

Guest
This is awfully familar to what happened with UNC basketball under Matt Doherty. Take about an uprising.
Mommys and daddys having summit meetings....Division I football?
 
Messages
815
Reaction score
15
Seriously have to agreae with you about suspending for the Bowl game. If Nutt backs down, this could only get worse and this type of poison spreads VERY quickly on a team full of competitive athletes. If the kids really feel slighted, then they should transfer. This shit is unreal!

I m alittle taken aback by this. First Mustain commits, the ndecommits hoping to go to ND and CW says eh-eh I got my boy Claussen coming in. So he goes back to Nuttjob hanging his head and then gets benched. Ouch!.
 
J

johnchampion

Guest
Mustain and Clausen had nothing to do with each other.
Weis had Frazer and Jones already in his pocket. He said he'd take two QB and he stuck to his word.
Clausen wasn't a factor in the situation.
 
Top