Search results

  1. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    Apart from Carr improving, our defense and OL were functional by the end of the season. And maybe the OC decides to give the ball to the Heisman candidate RB a little more often.
  2. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    Okay? There are good teams every year
  3. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    Yes. Repeating is hard, see OSU. Even when UGA did it in 2022 they very nearly lost to OSU. And that was pre-portal/NIL.
  4. I

    Kurt “The Truth” Cignetti

    He was probably joking about Rudy. And who cares what he says about ND? Even if they lose, frankly, the available evidence indicates they are superior to ND this season. If we win a title, things change. No reason that can't happen soon.
  5. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    It was a set of coaching mistakes. It is what it is. If Golden had stayed, it wouldn't have happened. Still shouldn't have happened, of course.
  6. I

    Marcus Freeman named Dick Corbett Head Football Coach

    It's true that the late shifts in the rankings, especially Bama jumping us, were not responsive to actual events on the field. Did anyone watch Bama play Auburn? Or OU play LSU? And then when Bama got smoked by UGA, ND (not Bama) drops again? Huh? The contrived explanations obviously suggested...
  7. I

    Texas A&M Postgame

    Among the worst losses in recent ND history because its consequences. The coaches/team didn't seem ready, especially on defense. Oh, and the timing of the first two games was the result of awful scheduling.
  8. I

    The Optimal Notre Dame Scheduling Model

    A "tougher schedule to start the season" can mean one "tough" game, not two. It was very unwise to play the two toughest opponents in the first two games. I can't think offhand of another ND season (or, indeed, any team's season) where that happened. I'm sure it has happened, but it's rare...
  9. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    And (to make an obvious point) how did Bama, OSU, and Oregon compare to IU? Or for that matter, how did Illinois or UCLA or PSU or Iowa compare to IU?
  10. I

    2025 College Football Playoffs

    Expansion to 16 or 24 is necessary so long as the committee exists. The committee will usually have a financial incentive to under-rank ND. So this year, ND deserved to be 8 or 9 but ended up at 11. If we deserve to be 11 we will be 14. Etc. Expansion is some protection against that. Also, if...
  11. I

    2026 Transfer Portal - General

    It's paying dividends for IU. The other schools, we'll see.
  12. I

    Marcus Freeman named Dick Corbett Head Football Coach

    130 lbs? Shouldn't wresters -even at 5'5''- be heavier than that? How does that work
  13. I

    Marcus Freeman named Dick Corbett Head Football Coach

    Is this guy a coach at like a bunch of schools/programs? His coaching camp or whatever is in New Carlisle which is like 20 minutes west of SB.
  14. I

    Marcus Freeman named Dick Corbett Head Football Coach

    Just because a police report was filed doesn't mean it was a crime. It might be tortious battery, but that would involve the 5'5'' coach suing, not the DA.
  15. I

    Marcus Freeman named Dick Corbett Head Football Coach

    Sounds like this guy wants to embarrass ND. Whatever. Btw, if you think IU's run is bad for ND (it isn't, really) it's worse for Purdue.
  16. I

    ND's Talking Heads ... The good, bad & ugly

    Right, it's all about money. So get rid of the committee and we can rank the teams more fairly.
  17. I

    ND's Talking Heads ... The good, bad & ugly

    This is just another way of saying the teams are put in the playoff for financial reasons, rather than reasons of quality. And I think that's pretty obviously true, especially this year. The question is whether that is good, or not. I don't think ND should accept being screwed because it isn't...
  18. I

    ND's Talking Heads ... The good, bad & ugly

    Anyone who has watched football this year knows ND deserved to be in ahead of Bama and OU. That was true when Bama jumped us, that was true the day we were snubbed, it's true today. The only people who won't admit this are people who have a fan or financial incentive not to do so (e.g., SEC...
  19. I

    '21 IL OG Pat Coogan (Notre Dame Signee)

    Right, I'm just asking if they promise any players a starting job. If they are promising other players a starting job but not Coogan, I would say there's a colorable argument that ND coaches made a mistake in not promising him the job. If they don't promise any players starting jobs, though, and...
  20. I

    '21 IL OG Pat Coogan (Notre Dame Signee)

    So ND "promises" certain players starting jobs in advance of camp, and just has to decide which players get those promises? Or does ND tell everyone they have to compete for a job, and make no promises, even if players have a sense of whether they are likely to start given the other players on...
Top