Who says Brain Kelly staff will be better? From what it looks like he's going try to bring in the Cincy defensive staff which was piss poor staff too. Cincy defense got worst under his defensive staff and that's been proven already been discuss. Please spare me the lack of talent excuse if it's all about development than they shouldn't drop off that much year after year.
How do you figure that it was piss-poor? They weren't spectacular, but they weren't nearly as bad as you are making it seem. Do some research. In each of the last three seasons Cincinnati finished in the Top 10 nationally in sacks. This past season they finished 3rd nationally in tackles for loss, after finishing 23rd and 18th in the previous two seasons. When have you seen ND defenses do that? Even with all of Tenuta's blitzes, we couldn't sniff the QB. And, in each of his three seasons Kelly’s defenses finished in the Top 25 nationally (13th, 25th, 24th). His 2007 defense forced 42 (!!!) turnovers. Not great numbers overall, but not horrible whatsoever. Definitely not 'piss-poor'. And before you throw the strength of schedule argument at us, also remember that he's doing it with 2 and 3 star guys. He won't be doing that at ND.
In 2008, Kelly's QBs were falling like dominoes, and his team still didn't fall apart. Why? His defense stepped up. Go look it up. Seriously, how bad would we have been had Clausen gotten hurt? How about if Clausen, Crist, AND Sharpley got hurt? But yet Kelly still got his team in the BCS bowl, because his defense stepped up.
Yes, they ended this year in very poorly defensively. But that's what happens when you lose 10 out of 11 starters on defense, you turn ND's starting QB into your starting LB, and even HE gets hurt. And guess what, he still got his team to 12-0, and beat teams that ND couldn't beat with our 4 and 5 star guys. Pretty damn impressive.
You're backing up D'Antonio's defense, which is fine, but his team was nowhere near as good as Kelly's. He even went 4-8 his second year (out of only 3). Kelly's record at Cincy dwarfs D'Antonio. Not even close.
ND fans are split on Brown and his effectiveness. Was it Tenuta's crappy system? Was it Brown's lack of coaching-up his secondary? I don't know and I wasn't there. I do know that Cincy's defense wasn't nearly as bad as you guys are claiming...