calvegas04
Well-known member
- Messages
- 11,881
- Reaction score
- 8,464
After watching was surprised to see they won. Let’s hope he settles in once he starts playing a soft sec schedule
I hope that in a few years, Carr and Jarrard aren't added to the list...![]()
It's going Clausen/Crist/Kiel/Wimbush/Jurkovec/Buchner, Lakers in 5.
Lmao. I'll take you on the other side of that bet and make a lot of moneyNorth Cobb and Archer both state playoff teams from last year. I wouldn't worry too much, as most people don't truly realize how good GA high school football is. If you took the best seniors and a few juniors in the state put them in one team and had them play Akron or Ball St....GA high schoolers win, and I'd bet on it.
This gotta be sarcasm no? We're tossing this dude on the trash heap after his first game of his junior year at a new school? Come on nowWhy can’t we get top quarterbacks
Lmao you have no clue what your talking about. GA high school football is one of the main feeders into the SEC (I'm sure you've heard of them, they've been pretty good lately). Not only would the skill players dominate (think Travis Hunter, Isiah Bond and Gunner Stockton) these 18 year old offensive lineman average 6'6 305 and the DL avg 6'4 270 Mykel Williams anyone...He started as a Freshman and won a Natty at UGA before going to the 49ers 11th overall. The guy ranked behind him Overton played a ton as a freshman for A&M. Joshua Joseph coming off the edge...played a ton at Tennessee as a true freshman. And Starks at Safety is now a Raven. I'm sure Ball state has a bunch of kids that turned down UGA, Bama, Auburn, SC, Tenn, Ole Miss and Texas AM to go there.Lmao. I'll take you on the other side of that bet and make a lot of money
They would get cooked by Ball StateI'm bored so I dug into Ball state a little, they won 12 games over the last 3 years and during that span their highest ranked recruits yearly are 1500+ nationally and even those kids are only ranked nationally on rivals.
Not only would I bet on the GA high schoolers....I'd bet my life. 2 completely different breeds of athletes.
Don't be stupid. But firing from the hip, we may not have had a battle tested QB come to ND that went through a high school gauntlet like Teddy since maybe Clausen.So Teddy played the GA All-stars? GTFO!
So all these kids that played as true freshman and played well in the SEC would get smoked by a bunch of 2 star MAC kids. ROOOOOGER THATThey would get cooked by Ball State
So Caleb Downs and our guy Kyle Hamilton wouldn't have been able to man up against Ball St? Even though both did fine as true freshmans. Um...okayThis is similar to the argument that one of Saban’s Alabama teams was good enough to beat the 0-16 Browns. Both arguments are ridiculous. Ball St would beat the shit out of a high school all star team from ANY state. You can’t tell me that 22 and 23 year old players that have been in a college weight room and nutrition program would lose to 17 and 18 year olds. Sorry, not buying it.
This is one of the dumbest things I have ever read on this site and that’s saying a lot.Lmao you have no clue what your talking about. GA high school football is one of the main feeders into the SEC (I'm sure you've heard of them, they've been pretty good lately). Not only would the skill players dominate (think Travis Hunter, Isiah Bond and Gunner Stockton) these 18 year old offensive lineman average 6'6 305 and the DL avg 6'4 270 Mykel Williams anyone...He started as a Freshman and won a Natty at UGA before going to the 49ers 11th overall. The guy ranked behind him Overton played a ton as a freshman for A&M. Joshua Joseph coming off the edge...played a ton at Tennessee as a true freshman. And Starks at Safety is now a Raven. I'm sure Ball state has a bunch of kids that turned down UGA, Bama, Auburn, SC, Tenn, Ole Miss and Texas AM to go there.
Ps...That was just the '22 class, I looked at them first because that was the first year for on3. If Caleb Downs was a year older they win the game by 14+
No, the score would be a blow out tooSo Caleb Downs and our guy Kyle Hamilton wouldn't have been able to man up against Ball St? Even though both did fine as true freshmans. Um...okay
As 18 year olds without the collegiate coaching, strength and conditioning, and 3-4 years of growth, no. You have two absolute freaks of nature that maybe 1-2 of which would be on the GA all star team. Then you have to consider that you are going into your 2 deep to play during an actual football game…. You’re smoking crack if you think they winSo Caleb Downs and our guy Kyle Hamilton wouldn't have been able to man up against Ball St? Even though both did fine as true freshmans. Um...okay
I’m not being a dick but have you ever played sports past high school? The development that takes place post high school is insane, and especially with football, the physical development that the Ball State team would have is insurmountable for high school kids. Yes the skill position kids could flash but they would get whipped in the trenches.Don't be stupid. But firing from the hip, we may not have had a battle tested QB come to ND that went through a high school gauntlet like Teddy since maybe Clausen.
Why do you think them Texas QBs always produce in college? Battle tested! Just look at Ewers, Milroe, Klubnik, Nussmeier, and Weigman to name a few. Long story short, I'm not familiar with CJ Carrs competition, but I'm certain if it was like Ga, Fla, TX or Cali....we wouldn't have a QB battle.
Edit..For some reason I thought Clausen went to Mater Dei, so don't come at me. No clue about Oaks Christian competition.
Dude, I promise I'm not being a dick or trolling either. But go look at Mykel Williams in high school. Also, real talk....is anyone here calling me crazy from the South? Because until someone from GA, Fla, Bama, LA calls me crazy I'm chalking it up as you guys just don't get it. Like not being a dick....but you just don't understand this level of play. And I'm not saying a specific high school would win, that's far from possible. I'm saying you take the top 50 seniors and Juniors...the kids that will be playing in the SEC as Freshman. They would match up well with Ball St, not a doubt in my mind.I’m not being a dick but have you ever played sports past high school? The development that takes place post high school is insane, and especially with football, the physical development that the Ball State team would have is insurmountable for high school kids. Yes the skill position kids could flash but they would get whipped in the trenches.
Why are only Southern posters valid here? You are basically asking would IMG beat Ball State. No they wouldn’t. Those freaks like Mykel Williams are relying on veteran players around them so they can shine. You put a bunch of 17/18 year olds together there would be mistakes everywhere.Dude, I promise I'm not being a dick or trolling either. But go look at Mykel Williams in high school. Also, real talk....is anyone here calling me crazy from the South? Because until someone from GA, Fla, Bama, LA calls me crazy I'm chalking it up as you guys just don't get it. Like not being a dick....but you just don't understand this level of play. And I'm not saying a specific high school would win, that's far from possible. I'm saying you take the top 50 seniors and Juniors...the kids that will be playing in the SEC as Freshman. They would match up well with Ball St, not a doubt in my mind.
I'd just ask everyone that shits on me, please tell me what state your in so I can get an idea of your knowledge.
Because I would value their opinion more if they saw what I saw. I don't wanna argue with someone that pays zero attention to GA high school football.Why are only Southern posters valid here? You are basically asking would IMG beat Ball State. No they wouldn’t. Those freaks like Mykel Williams are relying on veteran players around them so they can shine. You put a bunch of 17/18 year olds together there would be mistakes everywhere.
Born and raised in Pittsburgh, I used to think that Ohio Valley Pittsburgh area had great football too Aliquippa with Revis...but it's nothing like the south.🤣Is Kingbish from the South does anyone know?
Handwaiving the “…..with a bunch of subs” is doing a lot of work here.Because I would value their opinion more if they saw what I saw. I don't wanna argue with someone that pays zero attention to GA high school football.
And IMG alone would lose to Ball St. But the 11 best Offensive recruits and the 11 best defensive recruits in the state of Fla....with a bunch of subs, would beat Ball St. That's my argument, but the main point was Teddy is playing against very high level competition.
I hope Teddy is the real deal. But let’s not put all these kids on a pedestal just because they play in GA. You are disrespecting the Ball State players and I don’t think you realize that there are good players outside of the south.Because I would value their opinion more if they saw what I saw. I don't wanna argue with someone that pays zero attention to GA high school football.
And IMG alone would lose to Ball St. But the 11 best Offensive recruits and the 11 best defensive recruits in the state of Fla....with a bunch of subs, would beat Ball St. That's my argument, but the main point was Teddy is playing against very high level competition.
I feel like I’m losing my mind reading this thread.This gotta be sarcasm no? We're tossing this dude on the trash heap after his first game of his junior year at a new school? Come on now