Best Units

military_irish

New member
Messages
4,725
Reaction score
304
I was just thinking, since there are so many position battles going on, I would ask what everyone thinks were the best units we have had in the last decade so 2000-2009

Mine are -

OFFENSE

QBs-2006 (Brady Quinn, Evan Sharpley, David Wolke) I chose Brady and Evan over Jimmy and Evan because Brady had better on field results, and i think Evan was more talented than he was allowed to show.

RBs/FBs-2003 ( Julius Jones, Ryan Grant, Rashon Powers-Neal) Julius Jones for obvious reasons, Ryan Grant proved to be better than what was allowed from him, being passed on the depth chart by Walker a year later, and Powers-Neal was a great FB, just sucks in 2005 he got suspended.

WRs/TE's-2005 ( Stovall, The Shark, Rhema McKnight, Anthony Fasano, Marcus Freeman) With this group they were all just towers, you could throw it up and more than likely anyone of them could out jump the DB. Many other reasons they were great too. Hard to choose last years WRs because of the results on the field

OL- 2000 (Jordan Black, Jim Jones, Jeff Faine, Mike Gandy, John Teasdale, Kurt Vollers, Sean Mahan) I know at least 3-4 made it on NFL rosters for awhile, and Jeff Faine still is.

DEFENSE

DL-2004 (Justin Tuck, Greg Pauly, Derek Landry, Victor Abiamiri, Trevor Laws, Chris Frome) This was a tough one, never really realized how ND hasn't had a very dominant front in awhile. But with Tuck and Abiamiri, Landy, and Laws as a Freshmen, figured I couldn't go wrong

LBs-2002 (Courtney Watson, Derek Curry, Mike Goolsby, Corey Mays) Same like the DL, it was hard to choose because none have been that dominant, but all four of those guys had a pretty good year and career at ND.

DB's- 2002 (Vontez Duff, Shane Walton, Gerome Sapp, Glenn Earl) This group was the easiest to chose for the defense, they just seemed dominant, compare to anything we have had lately. The D in 2002 was ranked pretty high, with alot of it because of this group, IMO

just something i thought i would throw together because of all the postion battle stuff going on
 

IrishAlum1997

"Gru" the Dew
Messages
2,466
Reaction score
216
Oops...sorry for interrupting. Saw the title and thought the thread was going in another direction. Was gonna vote for mine.

Please, carry on. Carry on.
 

Riddickulous

"That" Guy
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
8,325
QBs - 2009. Why? Jimmy Clausen was better than Brady Quinn, we have a fifth-year guy with experience in Evan Sharpley, and a guy with enormous potential in Dayne Crist.

RBs/FBs - Agree.

WRs/TEs - Agree.

OL - Agree.

DL - Agree.

LBs - 2005. Brandon Hoyte, Corey Mays and Mo Crum.

DBs - Agree.
 

military_irish

New member
Messages
4,725
Reaction score
304
QBs - 2009. Why? Jimmy Clausen was better than Brady Quinn, we have a fifth-year guy with experience in Evan Sharpley, and a guy with enormous potential in Dayne Crist.

.

i don't know what it was, but it just seemed like when Brady was out there I always felt ND could win, but when Jimmy was out there some doubt was always in my mind. Don't get me wrong though i have always been a Clausen fan, and he does have more talent overall to succeed at any level of football.
 

Riddickulous

"That" Guy
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
8,325
i don't know what it was, but it just seemed like when Brady was out there I always felt ND could win, but when Jimmy was out there some doubt was always in my mind. Don't get me wrong though i have always been a Clausen fan, and he does have more talent overall to succeed at any level of football.

Quinn was terrible when faced with good competition or when he had little time to throw. That's why I like Clausen more.
 

calvegas04

Well-known member
Messages
11,861
Reaction score
8,440
I would take Quinn over Jimmy.. Brady was a little more mobile too
 

phork

Raining On Your Parade
Messages
9,863
Reaction score
1,019
Keep in mind that Jimmy had torn ligaments in his foot most of last year. Nothing wrong with the offense, it was the defense, or lack there of, that killed us last year.
 

GreatGolson

Formerly GreatDayne
Messages
2,956
Reaction score
133
If i was picking who i like as a person, Brady, as a representative of ND football Brady, as how a college football player should act Brady, as a guy who won games Brady, as a quarterback...Jimmy
 

Sherm Sticky

The Prophet
Messages
19,321
Reaction score
1,638
QBs - 2009. Why? Jimmy Clausen was better than Brady Quinn, we have a fifth-year guy with experience in Evan Sharpley, and a guy with enormous potential in Dayne Crist.

RBs/FBs - Agree.

WRs/TEs - Agree.

OL - Agree.

DL - Agree.

LBs - 2005. Brandon Hoyte, Corey Mays and Mo Crum.

DBs - Agree.
I agree with everything you put except for WR-2009-Tate, Floyd, Parish, Shaq, Kumara, Rudolph, etc
 

military_irish

New member
Messages
4,725
Reaction score
304
I agree with everything you put except for WR-2009-Tate, Floyd, Parish, Shaq, Kumara, Rudolph, etc

i would say stovall and the shark, have the equal talent of Tate and Floyd, but just different skill sets. I would take McKnight over Shaq, at this time and I would take Matt Shelton over Parish, once again they had different skill sets but i like Shelton more.

And with Rudolph, he has more talent than Fasano and Freeman, but as i group of TE's i would say 2005 is better i would take Freeman over Ragone, and i think at that time Carlson was on the team, so he is better than all the backups of 2009 also
 

Sherm Sticky

The Prophet
Messages
19,321
Reaction score
1,638
i would say stovall and the shark, have the equal talent of Tate and Floyd, but just different skill sets. I would take McKnight over Shaq, at this time and I would take Matt Shelton over Parish, once again they had different skill sets but i like Shelton more.

And with Rudolph, he has more talent than Fasano and Freeman, but as i group of TE's i would say 2005 is better i would take Freeman over Ragone, and i think at that time Carlson was on the team, so he is better than all the backups of 2009 also
All fair points...I think you are probably correct that Fasano, Freeman and Carlson was a better unit at TE. I think the two starters in 2009 are a little more talented and better players, but the quality of depth was def 2005....Close call
 
Top